The has set aside a massive income tax assessment order against the (), citing the tax authorities' failure to adhere to the mandatory procedural requirements under the . The ruling marks a significant victory for the state-owned infrastructure developer, which had been served with a tax demand stemming from an income determination of approximately ₹2,526 crore for the assessment year.
A division bench comprising Acting Chief Justice P. Sam Koshy and Justice Narsing Rao Nandikonda determined that the assessment process was fatally flawed due to the omission of essential procedural safeguards. The Court has directed the to undertake the assessment afresh, strictly following the statutory framework prescribed under . This outcome effectively wipes the slate clean for the corporation, requiring the tax department to issue a proper and provide the petitioner with a genuine opportunity to contest proposed variations in its income.
The dispute arose after the state-owned entity, established to promote industrialization through infrastructure, challenged the assessment order dated . The corporation had originally declared an income of ₹70.35 crore in its 2018 return, a figure subsequently revised to ₹65.63 crore. The tax authorities, however, drastically recalculated the total income to over ₹2,526 crore. The petitioner argued that this exorbitant leap in valuation was reached without the issuance of a or any meaningful mechanism for the corporation to offer its objections before the final order was passed.
Central to the Court’s decision was the interpretation of Section 144B, which governs the faceless assessment system. The petitioner successfully argued that the tax department had conflated the simple issuance of information requests under with the mandatory notice requirements for proposed income variations. The Court agreed with this assessment, finding that the department had bypassed the requirement for a , which serves as a critical bridge between internal review units and the final determination of liability.
During the proceedings, the bench emphasized that these procedural steps are not merely administrative formalities but are essential pillars of . In the words of the Court, “The opportunity contemplated under the said provision is not an empty formality, but a substantive procedural safeguard intended to enable the to effectively explain its case before the assessment is finalised.” The Court further observed that the notices issued during the assessment were inconsistent, as the figures eventually adopted in the final order differed significantly from those discussed in earlier communications, leaving the petitioner in the dark regarding the basis for the massive additions.
The Revenue authorities had contended that the petition was not maintainable, citing the existence of an via an appeal. However, the High Court rejected this, holding that the availability of an appeal does not preclude a where a fundamental violation of procedural fairness has occurred. By citing the established precedent in , the bench reinforced the principle that the faceless assessment procedure is a departure from older systems and demands strict adherence. The court noted that once the faceless regime is engaged, the authorities cannot substitute its mandatory stages with informal, non-statutory practices.
The judges also dismissed the contention that the requirement for a was limited only to specific "eligible assessees" under . The Court clarified that the faceless assessment procedures under Section 144B must be interpreted as a standalone mandatory requirement that applies across the board, regardless of the classification under other sections of the Income Tax Act. By ignoring the directive to allow the taxpayer to against the specific variations proposed, the deprived the corporation of its right to a transparent and fair adjudicatory process.
Under the current directions from the High Court, the matter has been remitted back to the Assessing Authority. The authorities are now obligated to issue a formal that explicitly highlights the proposed additions. Furthermore, the Court has stipulated that if the corporation requests a personal hearing, the authorities must grant it, ensuring the principles of are fully satisfied.
The Court maintained a neutral stance on the underlying merits of the tax additions, emphasizing that it had not expressed an opinion on the veracity of the income figures. All contentions regarding the financial particulars remain open for the petitioner to argue when the fresh assessment process commences. For the time being, the original assessment order of , and its consequential demand notices have been rendered , providing the state-owned corporation the procedural protection it sought to contest the tax authorities’ findings on fair and legal grounds. The resolution of this case underscores the judiciary’s strict stance on maintaining procedural rigor within the digital, faceless tax environment, ensuring that state-run entities and private taxpayers alike are not subjected to arbitrary determinations without sufficient opportunity to defend their returns.
procedural fairness - statutory compliance