The has dismissed a legal challenge seeking to set aside land acquisition proceedings for the Kalwakurthy bypass project on National Highway 167K. A division bench, comprised of Acting Chief Justice P. Sam Koshy and Justice Suddala Chalapathi Rao, held that courts are not technically equipped to evaluate the feasibility or alignment of vital infrastructure projects, reaffirming that judicial intervention in such matters is restricted to cases involving clear illegality or demonstrated .
The appellant, Talasani Sravan Reddy, had moved the court to challenge a single-judge order that dismissed his plea against the acquisition of his land in Kotra village, Nagarkurnool district. The petitioner’s core contention was that the bypass road alignment was modified contrary to an earlier final map, specifically alleging that the project should have commenced at Chainage 76/400. He argued that had the original alignment been followed, his one-acre landholding would not have been impacted. Furthermore, he claimed that the Revenue Divisional Officer, acting as the Competent Authority for Land Acquisition, failed to pass a " " while rejecting his objections, thereby acting in a mechanical and arbitrary manner.
Challenges Over Alleged Alignment Deviations
The respondents, representing the and the state land acquisition wing, maintained that the alignment was finalized based on rigorous technical feasibility studies. According to the state’s counter-affidavit, the Detailed Project Report (DPR) consultant had provided three distinct alignment options. The ministry ultimately approved the third option, which mandated the bypass to commence from Chainage 76/100, deviating from the earlier proposal to separate from the Hyderabad-Srisailam road at Chainage 76/400.
The court noted that these objections were not ignored by the authorities. The record established that the competent authority had processed the petitioner's grievances through various endorsements in October and . By the time the final notification under , was published, the legal process for vesting the land in the central government was substantially complete. The bench observed that the land, once notified under Section 3D(1), vests absolutely in the central government, free from all .
Regarding the petitioner’s grievance over the rejection of his objections, the division bench found no procedural infirmity. The court pointed out that the competent authority had provided the necessary clarifications, and the petitioner was afforded adequate opportunity to raise concerns. The bench stated,
"The contention that the objections raised by the petitioner were not considered cannot be accepted."
Limited Judicial Scope in Infrastructure Projects
Central to the court’s decision was the principle that national highway development is the domain of professional experts. Relying on established precedents, the bench emphasized that bodies like the are tasked with balancing vehicular traffic density with the . The judgment clarified that courts are ill-equipped to second-guess the engineering decisions inherent in highway construction.
Citing the Supreme Court’s observations in
, the bench reiterated:
"The courts are not at all equipped to decide upon the viability and feasibility of the particular project and whether the particular alignment would subserve the larger
."
This legal doctrine underscores that
in infrastructure acquisition is narrowly confined. The bench noted that while the petitioner alleged arbitrary conduct, he failed to substantiate any claim of malice or bad faith, nor could he establish a clear departure from the mandate of the National Highways Act.
The court further highlighted the broader public impact of the litigation. The state informed the court that the project is currently 95% complete, but the bypass remains inaccessible to the public due to the ongoing dispute over a 200-meter stretch of land. This delay has prevented the operationalization of a crucial infrastructure link intended to facilitate traffic between Kalwakurthy and Kollapur.
In its final analysis, the court found the order of the learned Single Judge to be well-considered and legally sound. The division bench ruled that the acquisition process followed the prescribed and that the appellant had failed to demonstrate sufficient grounds for the court to nullify a completed administrative act. By dismissing the , the court has effectively upheld the final notification under the Act and cleared the path for the completion of the bypass.
The dismissal concludes the current round of litigation for the appellant, though the court’s order keeps intact his right to seek other available legal remedies, such as those pertaining to compensation for the acquired land, under the relevant statutory provisions. With this ruling, the state and the highway authorities are expected to proceed with the remaining construction work on the Kalwakurthy bypass. No costs were awarded in the dismissal of the appeal, and all pending miscellaneous petitions were ordered to be closed.
Highway Alignment - Judicial Review