The Allahabad High Court has directed the Uttar Pradesh state authorities to refund a contractor’s performance security deposit of ₹5,54,000, along with interest at a rate of 8.5% per annum and additional costs of ₹25,000. This ruling comes after the Court found that officials from the Minor Irrigation Department had cancelled a tender in a clandestine manner, failing to provide the petitioner with any formal notice or an opportunity to be heard. The bench of Justice J.J. Munir and Justice Indrajeet Shukla observed that the department’s actions were not only contrary to the principles of natural justice but also constituted an arbitrary exercise of power in violation of Article 14 of the Constitution.

The dispute arose following an e-tender notice issued by the Executive Engineer of the Laghudal Nahar Khand, Banda, for work on the Ram-Janki pump canal project. The petitioner, Arvind Kumar Mishra, had emerged as the L-1 bidder and was subsequently asked to deposit a performance security totaling ₹5,47,861. Upon fulfilling this requirement by depositing ₹5,54,000, the petitioner repeatedly requested the formal execution of the contract. Despite his compliance, the department remained silent, eventually leading the petitioner to approach the Court. It was only during the judicial proceedings that the petitioner discovered his tender had been rejected as early as December 2024, a fact that had been deliberately withheld by the department.

Describing the department's conduct, the Court noted, "In a clandestine manner, the decision to cancel the tender was taken and even before this Court the respondents have tried to play tricks, firstly by passing of the letter, which was communication amongst themselves, as sufficient information to the petitioner for making the shortfall of additional performance security good, without making over a copy thereof to the petitioner and even disclosing the fact as to whom the tender was allotted and work got done."

Procedural Opacity and Unjustifiable Delay The department’s defense rested on the claim that there was a minor deficiency of ₹93,861 in the performance security amount and that the petitioner, being a regular contractor, should have been aware of the requirement. However, the Court rejected this argument, pointing out that the state had failed to produce any evidence of written communication addressed to the contractor. Instead, the authorities attempted to rely on internal office notes that were neither served upon the petitioner nor carried any official reference numbers. The Court emphasized that this behavior undermined public confidence in the tendering process.

Furthermore, the legal basis cited by the state for the cancellation—a Government Order from 2012—had been superseded by a subsequent order issued in August 2024, which significantly changed the performance security requirements. The Court found it particularly troubling that the authorities continued to rely on an obsolete policy to justify their arbitrary cancellation, while simultaneously failing to inform the contractor that the project had already been re-tendered and completed by another party.

Enforcing Constitutional Accountability The judgment underscores the principle that the state, even when acting in a contractual capacity, is bound by the mandate of fairness and transparency. Invoking the Supreme Court 's jurisprudence, the Court reaffirmed that governmental policy in contractual matters must conform to the requirements of Article 14. "The State cannot be attributed the split personality of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde in the contractual field so as to impress on it all the characteristics of the State at the threshold while making a contract requiring it to fulfil the obligation of Article 14 of the Constitution and thereafter permitting it to cast off its garb of State to adorn the new robe of a private body," the Court remarked while highlighting the state's duty to act justly.

The Court’s decision to award interest at 8.5% is rooted in the doctrine of restitution, intended to compensate the contractor for the deprivation of his funds. Given that the work had already been completed by another party, the Court deemed it futile to issue a writ of mandamus for the execution of the original agreement. Instead, it chose to mould the relief by ordering a full financial refund and imposing costs, ensuring that the state could not unjustly enrich itself at the expense of the citizen.

Future Directives and Departmental Inquiry In a strong critique of the administrative failure, the Court has directed the Principal Secretary of the Minor Irrigation Department to initiate a formal inquiry against the erring officials responsible for the opaque handling of the tender. The directive aims to fix personal liability for the financial burden imposed on the state due to the interest and costs awarded. The Court has clearly signaled that such departures from competitive and transparent tendering practices are not merely administrative lapses but serious violations of public law obligations.

This inquiry is expected to look into why the cancellation was kept secret and why the officials involved attempted to misrepresent facts before the Court. The order has been communicated to the relevant authorities, including the Superintending Engineer at the Nalkool Mandal in Banda, to ensure compliance within a period of three weeks. By choosing not to issue a futile order of certiorari while still holding the state accountable for its arbitrary conduct, the High Court has reaffirmed that constitutional protection against irrational state action extends fully into the realm of government contracts.