The Allahabad High Court has ruled that authorities acting under the National Highways Act, 1956, possess no inherent power to review or revise compensation awards once they have been finalized. In a significant decision for landowners, the court declared that a Competent Authority cannot unilaterally diminish a previously determined compensation amount by issuing a subsequent "supplementary" award without explicit statutory authorization. This ruling ensures that landowners whose property is acquired for infrastructure projects are protected from arbitrary re-evaluations by the very bodies responsible for the initial determination.

The dispute arose from the acquisition of land in Village Mawai, District Kaushambi, for the expansion of National Highway No. 731A, also known as the Ram Van Gaman Marg. The petitioner, Vasudev, challenged a secondary award dated August 14, 2024, which significantly reduced the compensation amount for his RCC construction from the initial figure established in a prior supplementary award dated August 4, 2023. While the initial award had set the compensation at Rs. 68,00,650.78 following thorough verification by the Public Works Department and local revenue officials, the authorities later conducted a fresh, unauthorized verification, slashing the payout to Rs. 17,79,056. The court found this revision to be a violation of the legal framework governing land acquisition.

Constraints on Administrative Power

The division bench of Justice Siddhartha Varma and Justice Kunal Ravi Singh emphasized that the Competent Authority is created by statute and is strictly confined to the powers granted by the governing legislation. The court highlighted that the National Highways Act, 1956, functions as a self-contained code, and it does not grant the authority the power to sit in appeal over its own decisions. By attempting to re-verify the value of the structures months after the initial award was issued, the authority acted beyond its jurisdiction.

"The Competent Authority is a statutory authority . It has only the powers that the Act, 1956 gives it, expressly or by necessary implication," the court observed. The ruling reiterated that administrative convenience or a later change of perspective regarding valuation does not empower an official to reopen settled matters. The court held that if the National Highways Authority of India ( NHAI ) or any other respondent believed the original valuation was flawed, the law provides a specific, mandatory path for redress—an application before an independent arbitrator under Section 3-G(5) of the Act .

The Principle of Functus Officio

Central to the court’s decision was the doctrine of functus officio . Once the Competent Authority passed the supplementary award on August 4, 2023 , it had effectively completed its duty regarding the valuation for the petitioner's specific assets. The court stated, "Once the Competent Authority passed the supplementary award dated 04.08.2023 determining compensation under Section 3-G(1) , its jurisdiction on that matter was exhausted and it became functus officio ." This principle prevents an official from revisiting or altering an order after the decision-making process has concluded, unless the statute specifically permits such a review.

The court further noted that the second award was not a mere clerical correction or an attempt to fix an arithmetic slip. Instead, it involved a substantive re-assessment of the valuation, effectively acting as an appeal. By failing to seek recourse through the statutory arbitration process, the respondents circumvented the legal safeguards intended to ensure fairness in land acquisition. The court emphasized that the power of review is not an implied or incidental authority, stating, "The power of review is not an inherent or incidental power. It exists only if the statute confers it."

Protecting Constitutional Property Rights

The judgment also underscored the broader constitutional implications of the dispute. Under Article 300A of the Constitution of India, property cannot be deprived except by the authority of law. The court held that when compensation has been finalized in strict accordance with the established legal process, reducing it through unauthorized administrative action infringes upon the rights of the citizen. The respondents could not provide any justification or legal provision that authorized their attempt to reduce the compensation, leading the court to quash the second award entirely.

The court also expressed concern over the conduct of the authorities, noting that even the original compensation amount had not been released to the petitioner despite the completion of necessary document verification. The petitioner’s representation to rectify the error had been met with official inaction, leaving him in a state of financial uncertainty. The court concluded that the second supplementary award was a nullity and that the first award must remain in full force.

Operative Directions and Next Steps

The Allahabad High Court allowed the writ petition, ordering the immediate quashing of the supplementary award dated August 14, 2024, insofar as it concerned the petitioner. The respondents, including the Executive Engineer of the Highway Division of the Public Works Department, were directed to release the original compensation of Rs. 68,00,650.78 to the petitioner within one month, after accounting for any partial payments already made.

Crucially, the court clarified that this order does not prejudice the rights of the NHAI or the state to challenge the original valuation if they remain dissatisfied. However, such a challenge must now proceed through the formal legal channel mandated by the National Highways Act. By mandating adherence to the arbitration mechanism, the court has effectively reaffirmed that land acquisition disputes must be resolved through established legal forums rather than through the discretionary and unchecked actions of administrative officers. This decision provides a definitive check against the potential misuse of administrative power in infrastructure projects, reinforcing the rule of law for property owners across the state.