The Supreme Court of India has ruled that creditors cannot invoke the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC) to recover dues exceeding the scaled-down values prescribed in a previously approved rehabilitation scheme for a sick industrial company. A bench comprising Justice Sanjay Kumar and Justice Sanjeev Sachdeva set aside a judgment of the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT), which had attempted to revive a corporate insolvency resolution process (CIRP) against the appellant, M/s. Ganesh Benzoplast Ltd. The Court emphasized that once a rehabilitation scheme under the Sick Industrial Companies (Special Provisions) Act (SICA) is sanctioned, it becomes legally binding on all creditors, thereby precluding them from using insolvency proceedings to bypass established financial compromises.

The dispute originated from business transactions between the appellant and the State Trading Corporation of India (STC) dating back to 2003. Ganesh Benzoplast, a company engaged in the manufacturing and storage of chemicals, had previously sought relief under SICA due to significant erosion of its net worth. The Board for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction (BIFR) declared the appellant a sick industrial unit in May 2010. A Draft Rehabilitation Scheme was subsequently prepared, which provided for the scaling down of unsecured liabilities to 25% of the principal dues, payable over five annual installments. This scheme was approved by a Division Bench of the Delhi High Court in December 2015.

Crucially, the STC was not listed as a standard unsecured creditor in the scheme, but was instead identified in an annexure titled “List of Contingent Liabilities.” Despite the public notice and the publication of the scheme in newspapers, the STC never challenged its inclusion or the manner in which its claims were treated. It was not until 2018, years after the approval of the scheme, that the STC issued a demand notice under Section 8 of the IBC, seeking to recover nearly ₹24.26 crore.

The Supreme Court observed that the STC’s attempts to use the IBC as a mechanism for recovery were legally untenable. The Court underscored the necessity of finality in rehabilitation proceedings, noting that the legislative objective of SICA was to facilitate the revival of sick companies through a process of collective sacrifice. Allowing individual creditors to bypass these schemes would undermine the entire purpose of the rehabilitation process. As the Court remarked, “minority creditors and unsecured creditors could not be permitted to stall rehabilitation of a sick company by not accepting the scaled-down value of their dues as unless and until there was a sacrifice by all concerned, including creditors, financial institutions, unsecured creditors and labourers, there could not be revival of the sick industrial company.”

The Court further clarified the legal status of contingent liabilities, pointing out that an entity categorized as such does not possess the same standing as an unsecured creditor until the claim is formally crystallized. Even in the event of crystallization, the claimant would be bound by the terms of the rehabilitation scheme. The judgment noted, “Insofar as the so-called second option under Clause 11.11 of the RS is concerned, the NCLAT strangely refused to give effect to the decision of this Court in Modi Rubber Limited vs. Continental Carbon India Limited. Therein, this Court noted that after amendment of the SICA in 1994, the BIFR was empowered to scale-down/vary the dues of creditors.”

The appellant had, in a gesture of goodwill, offered to settle the STC’s claims at the 25% rate stipulated in the rehabilitation scheme, even before the legal status of the liability had been fully crystallized. The National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) had initially accepted this offer, quantifying the amount at ₹2,18,88,421 and disposing of the insolvency petition. The STC, however, contested this, leading to protracted litigation that reached the appellate stage.

The Supreme Court’s decision effectively closes the door on the STC’s efforts to pursue higher recoveries through the IBC. The Court noted that by the time the matter was being heard, the appellant had already paid the sum determined by the NCLT, and the STC had accepted that amount without prejudice. The ruling clarified that the IBC framework does not provide a mechanism for the determination or quantification of liabilities arising from previous SICA-sanctioned schemes.

Regarding the attempt by the NCLAT to reopen the matter, the Supreme Court was firm, stating that the appellate body had erred in overlooking the fact that no substantive issues remained to be adjudicated. The Court observed, “The reasoning of the NCLAT failed to take note of the fact that the STC issued a demand notice on 20.03.2018, well within the seven year period under the so-called second option in Clause 11.11 of the RS sanctioned by the Delhi High Court on 04.12.2015. Further, the NCLAT also lost sight of the fact that the options were available only to an ‘unsecured creditor’ and not to claimants under the category of ‘contingent liabilities’.”

By allowing the appeal and restoring the NCLT’s original order of 13.02.2020, the Supreme Court has reaffirmed the principle that once a company is successfully rehabilitated under the previous regulatory regime, it cannot be dragged into insolvency proceedings based on legacy debts that were already settled by a court-approved scheme. The judgment provides significant clarity for companies that have undergone revival processes, shielding them from attempts by creditors to use the IBC to reopen settled financial matters. The case serves as a definitive precedent on the binding nature of rehabilitation schemes and the limited scope for creditors to challenge the distribution of dues once a scheme is finalized and implemented. Parties are now required to bear their own costs, with the restored NCLT order marking the final conclusion of the insolvency application.