The has set aside an order discharging a former manager in a major financial fraud case, directing the to immediately resume proceedings and frame charges against him. Justice Uday Kumar, in a significant ruling on a , concluded that the lower court had committed a "" by conducting an impermissible "" while deciding on a . The decision paves the way for a full-scale criminal trial against Jyoti Ranjan Kanungo, who previously served as the Chief Manager and Relationship Manager at the bank's Industrial Finance Branch in Kolkata.
The legal battle stems from a colossal financial fraud, estimated at ₹164.99 crore, involving . According to the , the company and its promoters allegedly engaged in a multi-year scheme between and that systematically siphoned public banking funds. The investigation revealed that the accused used the Cash Management Product (CMP) facility to engage in "kite flying"—a process involving the deposition of cheques drawn on shell entities with insufficient funds to create an illusion of liquidity. Further, the probe unearthed the fraudulent engineering of six Letters of Credit amounting to ₹18.48 crore, backed by fabricated invoices and invoices for irrelevant transport receipts, such as agricultural machinery, which were entirely unsuitable for the company’s steel transport operations.
Evidence presented by the CBI specifically implicated Kanungo in the systemic facilitation of these fraudulent activities. Investigators found that he allegedly permitted the continuous operation of the CMP facility despite chronic, recurring cheque bounces that saw overdues peak at over ₹41 crore. More alarmingly, the CBI highlighted that Kanungo purportedly opened an unauthorized cash credit account specifically to absorb an unbacked ₹15 crore Real-Time Gross Settlement (RTGS) exposure extended to an outside firm, , at a time when the borrower’s account balance was a mere ₹5,117. By consistently signing monthly irregularity reports that obscured the true extent of these defaults, the agency argued, Kanungo acted as an internal protector for the fraud, shielding the account from being classified as a long after it had effectively failed.
In its defense, the legal team for Kanungo had successfully argued before the that his actions were routine administrative decisions processed under standard banking protocols. They maintained that he possessed no criminal intent, noting that the bank's internal departmental proceedings had previously cleared him of any corrupt practice, limiting his reprimand to a minor administrative warning. The , initially accepting these submissions, had discharged him under , citing a lack of evidence regarding personal financial enrichment.
However, the
rejected this reasoning, clarifying that the absence of direct kickbacks or personal enrichment does not preclude a charge under the
. Justice Uday Kumar observed,
"Personal monetary enrichment or direct kickbacks are not an inflexible
under this provision. Where a bank official acts in active tandem with private fraudsters to funnel public funds and artificially sustain an NPA, the statutory ingredients of abuse of position to grant pecuniary advantage to the borrower are
satisfied."
The Court found that the
had incorrectly evaluated the weight and credibility of the evidence, essentially conducting a "
" to determine the innocence of the accused, a step that is barred at the stage of framing charges.
Refining the scope of judicial review at the pre-charge stage, the High Court emphasized that the judiciary's task is limited to checking if the materials collected by the prosecution, when viewed at face value, disclose a "" of an offense. By ignoring the substantive logs of unauthorized account creation and the systematic concealment of massive liabilities, the allowed the accused to evade trial based on a premature and partial interpretation of the evidence. The High Court affirmed that the nature of the allegations, particularly the clandestine creation of accounts and the manipulation of systemic reporting, pointed toward a deeper, coordinated conspiracy that required oral testimony and cross-examination to properly adjudicate.
The ruling underscores a critical boundary for trial judges in complex economic offenses. The High Court stressed that it is not for the court at the discharge stage to weigh the comparative strengths of rival evidence or determine whether a conviction will eventually follow. Instead, the court must ensure that legitimate accusations are not stifled by an over-reliance on departmental exonerations or defense-led explanations that have yet to be tested under oath. In doing so, the High Court’s order effectively bridges the gap between the private beneficiaries of the fraud and the internal banking facilitators, ensuring that both sets of actors face the same legal scrutiny.
Following this judgment, the has been ordered to restore the case to its original file and proceed with the framing of charges against Kanungo for offences under the and the Prevention of Corruption Act. The matter will now proceed to trial in tandem with the other co-accused individuals. This reversal serves as a vital precedent for the investigation and prosecution of financial crimes in India, reinforcing that public servants involved in corporate banking failures face the full weight of the law, regardless of whether direct individual gain is immediately evident in the preliminary documentation. The is expected to formalize these charges in the coming hearings, signaling a new phase for the legal proceedings in this major financial scandal.
economic offenses - judicial oversight