The has formally requested the to clarify the scope of protection afforded to individuals covering public protests, specifically arguing that social media influencers and content creators should not be granted the same as professional journalists. This submission, made in a filed before the Apex Court, addresses growing concerns regarding the treatment of media personnel during recent demonstrations against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar. The police maintained that while the judiciary has rightly protected the media's duty to report on public events, that mandate does not equate to a blanket exemption for all individuals wielding cameras or recording equipment at protest sites.
The affidavit, filed by Joint Commissioner of Police Surender Kumar, marks a significant development in the ongoing initiated by the , the , and several regional unions of working journalists. These organizations had petitioned the Court following allegations that police personnel obstructed, detained, and harassed reporters during protests organized by the in the national capital. The police response seeks to reframe the debate, shifting the focus from the act of recording to the intent behind the content generation.
"The said direction protects journalists in the discharge of their
and does not, and was not intended to, exempt the so-called reel-makers and social media influencers or unruly elements from the operation of the
or from compliance with the lawful directions of the Law Enforcement Agencies at the site of a
,"
the affidavit stated. The police emphasized that this distinction is critical for maintaining order at sites of prohibited or tense assemblies where distinguishing genuine reporters from protesters attempting to exploit content for commercial gain presents a practical challenge to law enforcement.
The police have pointed to specific instances to illustrate the complexity of the ground situation. According to the affidavit, some individuals carrying microphones and cameras identified themselves as journalists while actively participating in protests and shouting slogans. In one cited instance, a person who initially identified as a student and journalist reportedly admitted to not being a working reporter upon further questioning. The police argued that such behavior complicates the ability of officers to identify and facilitate press members, necessitating a standard for distinguishing journalism from social media content creation.
Despite these assertions, the emphasized that it does not mandate formal accreditation for all reporting. It explicitly recognized that the to gather, record, and publish news extends to independent journalists, freelancers, and individuals reporting through digital platforms, provided their primary intent is news dissemination. The absence of accreditation or employment with a recognized news house, the police noted, is not a ground for denying the right to document events. However, they maintained that this freedom is not absolute and remains subject to general laws and lawful police directions meant for crowd control and public safety.
The affidavit further addressed specific allegations of police misconduct during the protests. Regarding claims of sexual harassment made by three female journalists on , the police stated that their inquiry, which included the examination of CCTV footage, did not corroborate the allegations. They noted that two complainants declined to pursue their grievances, while the third did not participate in the investigation, leading to the closure of the files. The police also denied the seizure of any media equipment, maintaining that all items handled by officers during protest management were seized in accordance with as unclaimed or prohibited property.
In response to the specific detention claims, the department provided detailed accounts of its interactions with various media personnel. The police rejected allegations that journalists were targeted, explaining that individuals such as those associated with Peek TV or other digital platforms were briefly removed or detained during crowd-control measures, often due to mistaken identity, and were subsequently released once their professional credentials were verified. For example, regarding journalist Paranjoy Guha Thakurta, the police denied , claiming he was transported a short distance before being released, rather than being taken to a police station.
The debate over the status of content creators versus journalists is occurring against a backdrop of evolving media standards. The has referenced the , which define a working journalist based on criteria such as journalism being the individual’s principal vocation. Furthermore, they cited the recent guidelines issued by the in , which emphasize responsible reporting and professional conduct at demonstrations. By invoking these frameworks, the police are inviting the Supreme Court to establish a more granular test for determining who qualifies for the protection of "."
The police have urged the Supreme Court to consider that the predominant intent behind an individual's activity—whether it is news gathering or the commercial exploitation of online content—should be the decisive factor in assigning status. This request places the burden on the Court to potentially define the boundaries of digital journalism in a way that respects constitutional speech rights while allowing law enforcement to maintain order in public spaces.
The current legal landscape remains defined by the Supreme Court’s order, which directed that professionals, including journalists, should not be obstructed in the performance of their duties. The asserts that it has complied with this order, denying any coordinated effort to interfere with news reporting. As the matter proceeds, the Court will be expected to reconcile the police's operational difficulties in crowd management with the fundamental rights of independent and digital reporters. The petitioners, including the various journalist unions, are expected to respond to these claims in the upcoming hearings, as the Court decides whether to adopt the police's suggested criteria for distinguishing journalists from digital influencers. The outcome of these proceedings will likely set a lasting precedent for how law enforcement interacts with the diverse landscape of modern media during times of civil unrest.
journalistic immunity - protest coverage rights - content creator status - police accountability measures - digital media freedom