Judgment

DUA, J.: In this appeal special leave was limited to the question whether relief by way of payment of compensation should not be substituted for the relief by way of reinstatement granted by the Labour Court to the workman, H. P. Bhagavati, Store Clerk.

2. The Panitole Tea Estate belongs to the Jokai (Assam) Tea Co., Ltd., Panitole, Depot Line was one of the Out Garden under this Tea Estate and it had a separate godown. One B. K. Borgohain, a part-time clerk was in charge of this godown. Ammonia sulphate fertiliser was stored in this godown, 970 bags having been received there between December 12, 1960 and January 5, 1961. Pursuant to receipt of an anonymous letter that there was pilferage of these bags the stock was checked and 89 bags were found missing. In the course of the domestic enquiry against Borgohain a chit (Ex. 12) was produced by him which suggested N. P. Bhagavati s collusion with Borgohain in this affair. Bhagavati was accordingly also chargesheeted and after domestic enquiry he was dismissed with effect from March 23, 1961. This order of dismissal of Bhagavati gave rise to an industrial dispute which was duly referred to the Labour Court of Assam at Dibrugarh