1. Employee, a member of a disciplined force, challenges removal from service following disciplinary proceedings initiated after alleged misconduct concerning unauthorized leave and insubordination. (Para 3 )
2026 Supreme(SC) 1362
SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
SATISH CHANDRA SHARMA, NONGMEIKAPAM KOTISWAR SINGH, JJ.
Sumit Kumar – Appellant
Versus
Union Of India & Ors. – Respondents
Civil Appeal No(s). 14244 of 2026 [Arising out of SLP (C) Nos. 28027-28028 of 2024]
Decided On : 16-11-2026
Important Points
Disciplinary punishment must be proportionate to proven misconduct and based on evidence, not suspicion. Denial of translated documents and defense assistance violates natural justice. Additionally, past penalties cannot be treated as new misconduct or used to compensate for a lack of evidence in current proceedings.
Subject
Service Law - Disciplinary Proceedings
Act Referred
Headnote
(A) CISF Rules, 2001 - Rule 36, Rule 36(8)(a) and Rule 36(10)(b) - Constitution of India - Articles 14 and 226 - Official Languages Rules, 1976 - Rule 7(3) - Disciplinary proceedings - Removal from service - Quantum of punishment - Findings unsupported by evidence - Violation of principles of natural justice - Judicial review in disciplinary matters is warranted where proceedings are inconsistent with the rules of natural justice or statutory rules, or where the conclusion is so wholly arbitrary that no reasonable person could have arrived at it (Paras 11 - 12 ). Where the punishment imposed is so disproportionate to the misconduct proved as to shock the conscience of the Court, it is arbitrary and offends Article 14 of the Constitution (Para 13 ).
(B) Misconduct - Evidence - Disciplinary liability must be founded upon misconduct attributable to the employee and established through evidence in the inquiry; an employee cannot be held responsible merely by reason of a relationship with persons alleged to have engaged in misconduct (Paras 18 - 19 ).
(C) Past Record - Previous misconduct for which an employee has already been subjected to disciplinary action cannot be treated as a fresh instance of misconduct for the purpose of imposing another penalty, nor can it be used to supply a deficiency in proof of the charges in present proceedings (Para 20 ).
(D) Fair Hearing - Failure to provide translated copies of relied-upon documents in a language understood by the employee before the examination of witnesses, and the denial of a defense assistant, deprives the employee of an effective and meaningful opportunity to defend themselves (Paras 21 - 22 ).
Facts of the case:
An employee of an armed force was removed from service following a departmental inquiry on three charges: failure to appear before a superior officer despite directions, alleged circulation of a video of his wife and intimidation of the administration through relatives, and a history of five prior minor penalties. The employee had sought leave to attend to his wife, who underwent major surgical procedures. During the inquiry, his request for Hindi translations of English documents was granted only after the closure of evidence, and his request for a defense assistant was rejected. The High Court upheld the removal, viewing the employee as a habitual offender.
Findings of Court:
The court found that there was no contemporaneous material establishing that a specific direction to appear had been communicated to the employee. There was no evidence connecting the employee to the circulation of the video or the conduct of his relatives. Furthermore, the previous minor penalties could not be used to sustain the current charges. The procedural lapses regarding translation and defense assistance were deemed significant violations of natural justice.
Issues: Whether the findings of the inquiry were supported by evidence, whether the departmental proceedings were conducted in breach of the principles of natural justice and statutory rules, and whether the penalty of removal from service was shockingly disproportionate to the alleged misconduct.
Ratio Decidendi: The sentence must suit the offense and the offender and should not be vindictive or unduly harsh. When findings are not supported by evidence and the procedure is vitiated by the denial of basic defense rights, the resulting punishment is arbitrary. In this case, the removal from service was manifestly excessive and disproportionate to any established misconduct.
Result: Appeals allowed. Judgment and order of High Court and the order of removal set aside. Employee reinstated with consequential benefits and 50% back wages.
Legal Category Hierarchy
For the Petitioner(s): Mr. Rakesh Kumar Khanna, Sr. Adv. Ms. Amita Singh Kalkal, AOR Ms. Aditi Gupta, Adv. Mr. Aditya P Khanna, Adv. Ms. Arushi Jindal, Adv. Mr. Devinder N. Grover, Adv. Ms. Vijay Lakshmi Grover, Adv. Mr. Govind Kashyap, Adv. Ms. Anchal Aggarwal, Adv.
For the Respondent(s): Mr. Brijender Chahar, A.S.G. Ms. Pooja Chahar, Adv. Mr. Anmol Chandan, Adv. Ms. Nasadiya Singh, Adv. Mr. Rajan Kumar Chourasia, Adv. Mr. Amrish Kumar- 2986, AOR Dr. Arun Kumar Yadav, Adv. Mr. Arvind Kumar Sharma-AOR, Adv.
Table of Contents
2. Appellant contends penalty is disproportionate, procedure breached natural justice, and prior penalties cannot justify removal; Respondents argue appellant was habitual offender and procedure was standard. (Para 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 )
3. The court observed that the disciplinary findings lacked substantive evidence, procedural requirements were violated, and the punishment was shockingly disproportionate given the surrounding circumstances. (Para 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 , 23 )
4. A penalty that is disproportionate to the misconduct, causing the court's conscience to shock, infringes upon constitutional guarantees and constitutes grounds for judicial interference. (Para 13 , 14 , 24 , 25 )
5. The appeals are allowed, removal orders are quashed, and immediate reinstatement with consequential benefits and partial back wages is directed. (Para 26 )
6. Can previous minor penalties already served be used as a fresh basis for removing an employee?
No. Past disciplinary record can only be considered for determining the quantum of punishment for acts independently established, but it cannot be used to bridge deficiencies in evidence or constitute a new instance of misconduct. (Para 20 )
7. Does the failure to provide translated documents to an employee not conversant with the source language constitute a violation of natural justice?
Yes. Failure to supply documents in a language understood by the delinquent employee prior to the completion of the inquiry denies an effective opportunity to defend, violating principles of natural justice and fair procedure. (Para 21 )
8. When may a constitutional court interfere with the quantum of punishment imposed in disciplinary proceedings?
A court may interfere if the punishment is so disproportionate to the proven misconduct that it shocks the conscience of the court, appearing arbitrary or unreasonable, thus offending Article 14 of the Constitution. (Para 13 , 14 , 24 , 25 )
JUDGMENT :
SATISH CHANDRA SHARMA, J.
1. Leave granted.
2. The present appeals arise out of the judgment and order dated 14.02.2024 passed by the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi (hereinafter referred to as the “High Court”) in W.P.(C) No. 8173 of 2020, whereby the Division Bench dismissed the writ petition preferred by the Appellant and upheld the penalty of removal from service imposed upon him, and the order dated 12.07.2024 passed in Review Petition No. 114 of 2024, whereby the Appellant’s prayer for review of the said judgment was declined.
BRIEF FACTS
3. The facts necessary for adjudication of the present appeals are as follows:
(i) The Appellant was appointed as a Constable (General Duty) in the Central Industrial Security Force (hereinafter referred to as the “CISF”) in the year 2012. He was, at the relevant time, posted at the CISF Unit, Uranium Corporation of India Limited (UCIL), Jaduguda. The Appellant was married to one Smt. Shivani on 18.01.2015. According to the Appellant, his wife suffered serious medical complications during her pregnancy in late October 2017, culminating in a miscarriage and a major surgical procedure on 1 November 2017.
(ii) The Appellant proceeded on casual leave from 18.10.2017 to 07.11.2017 to attend to his wife, who was unwell on account of complications during pregnancy. On 31.10.2017, her condition deteriorated and she was hospitalised. According to the Appellant, his wife suffered her fourth miscarriage and underwent surgery on 01.11.2017, following which she was referred to another hospital. In these circumstances, the Appellant sought an extension of leave, which was granted until 03.12.2017, with an intimation that no further extension would be allowed. The Appellant further contends that, on 27.11.2017, his wife was again admitted to hospital, where she underwent a further major surgical procedure.
(iii) However, the Appellant rejoined duty at his Unit on 03.12.2017. Upon rejoining, he applied for a further twelve days of casual leave with effect from 05.12.2017 in order to care for his wife. On 04.12.2017, the Appellant met the Assistant Commandant and produced his wife’s hospital admission slip and other medical documents. According to the Appellant, the documents were considered insufficient and his request for further leave was declined.
(iv) On 05.12.2017, it is alleged that the Appellant telephoned the Commandant in connection with his leave, whereupon he was directed to report to the office on 06.12.2017 with all the documents. On 06.12.2017, the Appellant, stating that he was under acute mental stress on account of his wife’s condition, tendered his resignation through the grievance portal. The said resignation came to be closed, and the Appellant was thereafter informed, on the same day, that he had been granted twelve days of leave with effect from 06.12.2017. During this period, on 08.12.2017, the Senior Commandant, NAPS Narora, visited the Appellant’s residence at Kastala, Meerut, recorded his statement and examined the medical records pertaining to his wife, who was discharged from hospital on that very day.
(v) The Appellant resumed duty on 17.12.2017 and was thereafter transferred to the CISF Unit, Heavy Water Plant (HWP), Manuguru, Telangana, where he joined on 18.01.2018. On the very day of his joining, he was served with a Memorandum of Charge dated 18.01.2018, proposing to hold an inquiry against him under Rule 36 of the CISF Rules, 2001, on the following three charges:
- “Charge-I: Force No. 120717743 Constable/GD Sumit Kumar, H.W.P. Manuguru, while posted in the previous unit, UCIL, Jaduguda, on 05.12.2017, called the Commandant, UCIL, Jaduguda on his mobile in connection with the leave, upon which the commandant ordered him to come to the office on 06.12.2017 with all the documents. On 06.12.2017, the force member did not appear in the grievance room before the commandant and refused to come and the force member submitted a conditional resignation from the service and tri