SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2025 Supreme(AP) 62

IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH AT AMARAVATI 
B.V.L.N. CHAKRAVARTHI, J.
Ch. Pushpa Machilipatnam Krisna & Ors. - Appellants
Versus
Medical SPNTD Machilipatnam Krishna - Respondent
Second Appeal No. 1198 of 2001
Decided On : 10-03-2025

Important Points

A license does not create property rights and can be revoked, thus a suit for injunction by a licensee is untenable without necessary parties.

Subject

Civil Law - Property Law

Act Referred

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : S.100
EASEMENTS ACT : S.52, S.60

Headnote

(A) Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 - Section 100 - Easements Act - Section 52 - Second Appeal challenging dismissal of suit for permanent injunction against defendant - Plaintiff failed to establish entitlement to injunction as a mere licensee without property rights - Court found suit dismissed for non-joinder of necessary parties. (Paras 1-16)

(B) License - Definition and nature of rights - A license does not create an interest in the property and can be revoked at any time by the grantor. (Paras 13-15)

Facts of the case:
The plaintiff sought a permanent injunction against the defendant from interfering with the canteen's operation, asserting ownership based on a license granted by the District Collector. The defendant claimed the plaintiff violated conditions of the license and issued a notice to vacate.

Findings of Court:
The appellate court found the plaintiff's case lacked merit as he was merely a licensee and the suit was bad for non-joinder of the State as a necessary party.

Issues: Whether the notice was illegal and if the suit could be dismissed for non-joinder of necessary parties.

Ratio Decidendi: The court ruled that a license does not confer property rights and can be revoked, emphasizing that the suit was improperly filed without necessary parties included.

Result: Second Appeal dismissed.

JUDGMENT :

This Second Appeal, under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, is filed by the unsuccessful appellant/plaintiff assailing the decree and judgment, dated 28.09.2001, of the learned I Addl. District Judge, Machilipatnam, Krishna District, passed in A.S.No.119 of 1993.

02. The 2nd appellant/plaintiff filed O.S.150/1990 on the file of learned I Addl.Junior Civil Judge’s Court, Machilpatnam, against the respondent/defendant seeking the relief of permanent injunction, restraining the defendant and his men from interfering with the peaceful possession and enjoyment of the canteen by the plaintiff and also for implementing the orders dated 02.02.1988 in Rc.No.SPL/G-1/88. The learned trial Court vide judgment and decree dated 03.08.1993 decreed the suit. The respondent/defendant filed appeal in A.S.119/1993 on the file of learned I Addl.District Court, Machilpatnam, challenging the judgment and decree of the learned trial Court.

03. By the said decree and judgment, the learned I Addl.District Judge, Machilipatnam, allowed the first appeal with costs throughout, and reversed the decree and judgment, dated 03.08.1993 of the learned 1st Addl.Junior Civil Judge, Machilipatnam, passed in O.S.No.150 of1990 and dismissed the suit.

04. Heard Sri V.S.R.Anjaneyulu, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the Appellants/Plaintiff and Sri K.L.N.Swamy, learned counsel for Respondent/Defendant. I have perused the material on record.

05. The 1st appellant is the plaintiff and the appellants No.1 to 5 are the legal representatives of the deceased-plaintiff. The respondent is the defendant. The parties in this Second Appeal shall hereinafter be referred to as arraigned in the Original Suit, for convenience and clarity.

06. The case of the plaintiff as is borne out by the material on record, in brief, is that the plaintiff filed the suit against the defendant for declaration that the notice dated 28.06.1990 is illegal and for permanent injunction restraining the defendant and his men from interfering with the peaceful possession and enjoyment of canteen by the plaintiff and also in implementing the order dated 02.02.1988 in Rc.No.SPL/G-1/88.

It is further contended that the plaintiff is owner of the temporary canteen erected in the premises of Government Head Quarters Hospital, Machilipatnam. The plaintiff filed a petition before the District Collector, Krishna, permitting him to run a hotel in the hospital premises and Collector forwarded the application to the Superintendent, Govt. Hospital, Machilipatnam, for consideration and on the advice of District Collector, the application was put in general body meeting of hospital and approved the same. The Superintendent addressed a letter to plaintiff permitting him to construct a temporary shed with his own costs and also to run the canteen for hospital staff and also for attendants on patients with some conditions. The plaintiff constructed a thatched canteen and started business. While so, the defendant issued a notice to the plaintiff on 28.06.1990 to vacate the canteen.

07. The case of the defendant is that the defendant’s office addressed a letter to the District Court in Rc.981/G-1/82 dated 12.10.82 stating that he may permit the plaintiff to erect a shed for running the canteen business with some conditions. On that Collector sent order to the plaintiff. On the basis of order of the Collector, the defendant permitted the plaintiff to run canteen on the same conditions. The plaintiff made application to the defendant to construct a shed on the vacant site adjacent to maternity ward to run canteen for the convenience of the patients. Then the defendant permitted the plaintiff to run the same vide letter dated 22.02.1988. The defendant received representation from hospital staff members that the plaintiff selling eatables in unhygienic condition. On that defendant issued notice to the plaintiff on 28.06.1990 to vacate the hospital premises and prior to notice, the defendant orally advised

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top