SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2017 Supreme(Bom) 904

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY BENCH AT NAGPUR
A.S. CHANDURKAR, J.
Shankarrao Amrutrao Kale – APPELLANT
VERSUS
Raghunath Jagoji Shirpurkar – RESPONDENT
SECOND APPEAL NO.148 OF 2012
Decided On : 12-07-2017

Important Points

The defendant's admission of receiving the suit property in partition made him competent to transfer the property, and the compromise of the suit filed by the other family members of the defendant against him was not binding on the plaintiff.

Subject

Property Law - Specific Performance

Act Referred

BOMBAY PROHIBITION ACT : .
EVIDENCE ACT : S.137

Headnote

specific performance - Property Dispute - 1936 Exhibit-36, 17-9-1997 Exhibit-26 - Smt. Dipo v. Wassan Singh and others AIR 1983 Supreme Court 846, Rohit Chauhan v. Surinder Singh and Ors. AIR 2013 SC 3225, Ashwinkumar Manilal Shah and others v. Chhotabhai Jethabai Patel and others AIR 2001 Gujarat 90, Balmukand v. Kamla Wati and others AIR 1964 SC 1385, Dharmarao Sidhappa Shetgar v. Gopal Shriniwas Shirsikar and Ors AIR 2006 Bombay 228, Chikkam Koteswara Rao v. Chikkam Subbarao and others AIR 1971 Supreme Court 1542, Sameersingh Sureshsingh Suryawanshi v. Savita Sameersingh Suryawanshi 2008(1) Mh.L.J. 13, Uttam v Saubhag Singh and others (2016) 4 Supreme Court Cases 68 - The court discussed the ownership of the suit property, competence of the defendant to enter into the agreement and alienate the suit property, and the binding nature of the compromise of the suit filed by the other family members of the defendant against him. The court relied on various legal provisions and interpretations to confirm the decree for specific performance.

Fact of the Case:

The plaintiff filed a suit for specific performance as the defendant avoided executing the sale deed for the suit property. The defendant denied the agreement, claiming the property was ancestral and his family members had a share in it.

Finding of the Court:

The court found the agreement to be proved, the plaintiff ready to perform, and the defendant competent to alienate the property. The appellate court affirmed the trial court's decision.

Issues: Ownership of the suit property, competence of the defendant to enter into the agreement and alienate the suit property, and the binding nature of the compromise of the suit filed by the other family members of the defendant against him.

Ratio Decidendi: The court held that the defendant's admission of receiving the suit property in partition made him competent to transfer the property. The compromise of the suit filed by the other family members of the defendant against him was not binding on the plaintiff.

Final Decision: The substantial question of law was answered against the appellant, and the decree for specific performance was confirmed. The second appeal was dismissed with no order as to costs. The execution of the decree for specific performance was stayed for a period of eight weeks.

Advocates Appeared:
For the Appellant :Shri P. R. Agrawal, Advocate
for the Respondent:Shri N. R. Saboo, Advocate

JUDGMENT :

1. The present second appeal has been heard on the following substantial question of law:

Whether findings of both the courts below that the suit land in the hands of the defendant was his self acquired property although it has been brought on record that the property was originally owned by his ancestors and it was received by him in partition is correct? If yes, whether a decree for specific performance in respect of the suit property in which the other members of the joint family have shares, could have been passed ?

2. The appellant is the original defendant who is aggrieved by the decree for specific performance passed by the trial Court which decree has been affirmed by the appellate Court. It is the case of the respondent – plaintiff that the appellant – defendant was the owner of field Survey No.36/3 – 36/1 admeasuring 2 Hectares 30R. On 17-9-1997, the defendant agreed to sell 1 Hectare 21 R land to the plaintiff for a total consideration of Rs.1,05,000/-. The amount of Rs.60,000/- was paid as part consideration and it was agreed that the sale deed will be executed by 10-6-1998. Though the plaintiff was ready and willing to perform his part of the agreement, the defendant avoided to execute the sale deed. Hence, the suit for specific performance came to be filed on 24-7-1998.

3. The defendant in his written statement denied the agreement. According to him, the document in question was a forged document and as the plaintiff had borrowed sum of Rs.l0,000/- from the defendant said document was got executed. It was further pleaded that the suit property was ancestral property and his other family members had share therein. It was also pleaded that the defendant was addicted to various vices.

4. The trial Court on consideration of the evidence on record held the agreement to be duly proved. It further held that the plaintiff was ready to perform his part of the agreement. It was also held that the defendant was competent to alienate the suit property. The appellate Court after reconsidering the evidence on record dismissed the appeal filed by the defendant.

5. Shri P. R. Agrawal, learned Counsel for the appellant submitted that as per the document at Exhibit36 dated 29-2-1936, the appellant's grandfather had purchased the suit property. The appellant had succeeded to the same after the death of his father and therefore, all members of his family had a share in the same. According to him, the defendant alone did not have any right to enter into said agreement as the other coparceners of his branch had a share therein. In that regard he placed reliance on the decision in Smt. Dipo v. Wassan Singh and others AIR 1983 Supreme Court 846, Rohit Chauhan v. Surinder Singh and Ors. AIR 2013 SC 3225, Ashwinkumar Manilal Shah and others v. Chhotabhai Jethabai Patel and others AIR 2001 Gujarat 90, Balmukand v. Kamla Wati and others AIR 1964 SC 1385 and Dharmarao Sidhappa Shetgar v. Gopal Shriniwas Shirsikar and Ors AIR 2006 Bombay 228. He submitted that the finding recorded against issue No.4 by the trial Court and confirmed by the appellate Court was incorrect. He then submitted that the plaintiff without making any necessary enquiries and only on the basis of 7/12 extract dated 12-6-1998 – Exhibit-27 entered into the agreement. The defense that the transaction was a money lending transaction was fortified by this fact. It was then submitted that there was no evidence with regard to legal necessity on the part of the defendant to alienate the suit property. According to the learned Counsel only on the basis of the stray admission in the cross-examination that the defendant had received the suit property in partition his case had been disbelieved. According to him, such stray admission could not have been relied upon. He relied on the decision in Chikkam Koteswara Rao v. Chikkam Subbarao and others AIR 1971 Supreme Court 1542 and judgment of learned Single Judge in Sameersingh Sureshsingh Suryawanshi v. Savita Sameersingh Suryawan










1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top