SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2025 Supreme(Bom) 1622

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
A.S. GADKARI, NEELA GOKHALE, JJ.
The State of Maharashtra - Appellant
Vs.
Sajjad Ahmed Abdul Aziz Mugal @Pathan - Respondent
Criminal Appeal No.678 of 2014, Criminal Appeal No.491 of 2015 With Criminal Revision Application (St) No.10473 of 2022 With Interim Application No.2904 of 2022 In Criminal Revision Application (St) No.10473 of 2022
Decided On : 10-11-2025

Important Points

The judgment reaffirms that a conviction based on circumstantial evidence requires a complete chain of evidence that excludes all reasonable hypotheses of innocence, establishing the accused's culpability beyond reasonable doubt.

Subject

Criminal Law - Murder and Sexual Assault

Act Referred

INDIAN PENAL CODE : S.302, S.354, S.376, S.449, S.511
BOMBAY POLICE ACT : S.135, S.37(1)(a)
EVIDENCE ACT : S.106, S.27
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE : S.313, S.464

Headnote

(A) Indian Penal Code, 1860 - Sections 302, 354, 449 - Bombay Police Act, 1951 - Section 37(1)(a) - Conviction for murder, sexual assault and trespass - Prosecuted based on circumstantial evidence, including DNA matches, injuries, and extrajudicial confessions. (Paras 1, 36)

(B) Circumstantial Evidence - Must establish conclusive and complete chain, leaving no reasonable doubt of innocence; established against the accused through last seen theory and direct testimony. (Paras 11, 16)

(C) Motive - Established through witnesses testifying to prior grievances and behaviors, confirming intent behind actions leading to the murder. (Paras 14, 15)

(D) Final Conclusion - The guilt of the accused was proven beyond a reasonable doubt, with evidence of a brutal murder established and justifying the life sentence imposed. (Paras 37, 39)

Advocates:
Advocate Appeared:
For the Parties :Mr. Manoj S. Mohite, Senior Advocate (Spl.P.P.) a/w Ms. Priyanka Chavan and Ms. Ilsa Shaikh, Dr. Yug Mohit Chaudhry a/w Gaurav Bhawnani and Mr. Anush Shetty i/by Mr. Khan Abdul Wahab, Mr. Abhishek Yende a/w Mr. Rishikesh Y. Dube, Mr. Mahesh Tawade, ACP, Traffic South Division, Mr. Nitin N. Kumbhar, P.I., Unit-4, Crime Branch, Mumbai, Mr. Sanjay B. Nikam, P.I., Unit-4, Crime Branch, Mumbai

Table of Content
1. factual background of the case (Para 3)
2. arguments presented by both parties (Para 5 , 6)

JUDGMENT:

( Per Dr.Neela Gokhale, J. )

For the convenience of the exposition, this judgment is divided into the following parts: -

INDEX

I. FACTUAL MATRIX …................................................…..………. 5

II. SUBMISSIONS OF THE PARTIES …………..................………. 13

A. Submissions on behalf of the Appellant…..................…..………. 13

B. Decisions relied upon by the learned counsel for the Appellant... 25

C. Submissions on behalf of the Respondent-State.………...………. 28

D. Decisions relied upon by the learned counsel for the Respondent…………………………………………………………….. 41

E. Submissions on behalf of Revision Applicant…..………………… 42

III. POINTS FOR DETERMINATION………...................……..… 44

IV. ANALYSIS………..…………………....……….………...………... 45

A. Law laid down in cases involving evidence of circumstantial nature….45

B. The evidence on record indicting Sajjad………......……………….. 49

C. On motive ……….….……………………...……………….…………… 50

D. Sajjad’s presence at the spot of the crime & Law on the Last Seen theory………………………………………………………………..………. 53

E. Seizure of Articles; chain of custody / absence of wax seal .….………. 59

F. On CA Report regarding DNA ...………………………………….…... 62

G. On recovery of weapon………………………………………….……... 62

H. On recovery of other articles…………………………………….…….. 63

I. Extrajudicial confession…………………………………………….……. 66

J. Contradictory statements given by Sajjad and unexplained injuries on his person…………………………....…………………….……………………. 71

K. On CCTV footage / fingerprint & footprints……………………….... 73

L. Postmortem Report…………………………...………….………….….. 74

M. On applicability of Section 464 Cr.PC……………………………….. 74

V. FINAL CONCLUSION ………………………..………………….. 75

1. The Appellants and the Revision Applicant in the present matter assail the Judgment and Order dated 7th July, 2014 passed by the learned Addl. Sessions Judge, City Civil & Sessions Court, Greater Bombay in Sessions Case No.738/2012. By the said judgment, the Appellant-convict (“Sajjad”) stands convicted for offenses punishable under Sections 302 , 354 and 449 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (for short IPC) and under Section 37 (1) (a) read with Section 135 of the Bombay Police Act, 1951. For the offense punishable under Section 302 of the IPC, Sajjad is sentenced to suffer rigorous imprisonment for life, to mean imprisonment for the remainder of his natural life; for the offense punishable under Section 354 of the IPC, he is sentenced to suffer rigorous imprisonment for 5 years with a fine of Rs.3,000/- and in default to suffer rigorous imprisonment of 6 months; and for the offense punishable under Section 37(1) (a) read with Section 135 of Bombay Police Act, 1951, he is sentenced to suffer simple imprisonment of 1 year with fine of Rs.5,000/- in default of which to suffer simple imprisonment for 2 months. All substantive sentences of imprisonment are directed to run consecutively.

2. The State of Maharashtra in Criminal Appeal No.678/2014 and the Revision Applicant, the father of the deceased victim, in Criminal Revision Application (St) No.10473/2022, seek enhancement of the sentence to capital punishment. The Appellant in Criminal Appeal No.491/2015 is the sole convict assailing his conviction. Since the Appeals/Revision Application assail the same Judgment and Order, all are being disposed together by this common Judgment and Order.

I. FACTUAL MATRIX:

3. The facts of the case giving rise to filing of Appeals can be summarized as under:

i) A young lady Advocate namely Pallavi Purkayastha (victim/deceased) was sharing a rented flat No.1601, ‘B’ wing, 16th Floor, Himalayan Height Building, Bhakti Park, Wadala (E), Mumbai with her friend Avik Alok Sengupta (informant). They were to marry. Both of them were law graduates. Pallavi was working in a company as a legal Manager. Her work timings were from 11:00 a.m. to 05:00 p.m. Avik was employed in a law firm and his work timings were not fixed. He usually left home in the morning




1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top