2020 Supreme(Pat) 751
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
CHAKRADHARI SHARAN SINGH, J.
C.W.J.C. No. 5618 of 2020
(27.4.2020)
M/s SCI India Ltd. – Petitioners
vs.
State of Bihar & Ors. – Respondents
For the Petitioners: M/s P.K. Shahi, Sr. Adv., Vikas Kumar.
For the Respondents: Mr. Vikash Kumar.
Headnote:
Constitution of India – Article 226 – Petition for direction to State to issue license in prescribed form-25 for production of alcohol based Hand Sanitizer which is essential to combat highly contagious Covid-19 Virus – Petitioner claims to be a Company having infrastructure, fully equipped to manufacture alcohol based Hand Sanitizer and has made application to Drug Controller, State of Bihar to issue licence for manufacture of alcohol based hand sanitizer in last week of March 2020 – Subsequent to submission of his application, physical verification of manufacturing unit is said to have been conducted by Drug Inspector, Banka who, it is stated has made recommendation on 09.04.2020 for issuance of requisite licence – Said recommendation has been sent to State Drug Controller cum Chief Licensing Authority but till date no decision has been taken in this regard – Application disposed of with direction that decision to be taken on petitioner's application and his subsequent representation. (Paras 3 and 6)
Chakradhari Sharan Singh, J. – It is in the aftermath of the outbreak of COVID-19 pandemic, 21 days’ nationwide lockdown has been declared, in the midst of which filing of the present application under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, has been accepted by this Court through e-mail under the orders of Hon’ble the Chief Justice and it has been posted before me for hearing through video conference. Several defects have been pointed out by the Stamp Reporter, most of which relate to non-compliance of the filing procedure laid down under the Patna High Court Rules. It has been undertaken on behalf of the petitioner that such defects shall be removed once normalcy is restored.
The petitioner is seeking following reliefs: –
“(i) For direction to respondent authorities to issue license in prescribed form- 25 for production of alcohol based Hand Sanitizer, which is essential to combat the highly contagious Covid-19 Virus particularly when similarly situated M/s Globus Spirits Limited Company (Distillery Company) has been given license for manufacture of Hand Sanitizer and denial of license to the petitioner is putting the life of citizen of Bihar at stake and also infringing the valuable rights of petitioner company.
(ii) For direction to respondent authorities to allot Ethanol/ENA to the petitioner for manufacturing of Hand Sanitizer to fulfill the public demand as well as government requirements in tackling COVID-19 pandemic.”
2. I have heard Mr. P.K. Sahi, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner and Mr. Vikash Kumar for the State of Bihar.
3. It can be easily noticed from what has been averred in the writ application that the petitioner claims to be a Company having infrastructure, fully equipped to manufacture alcohol based Hand Sanitizer and has made an application to the Drug Controller, State of Bihar to issue licence for manufacture of alcohol based hand sanitizer in the last week of March 2020. Subsequent to submission of his application, physical verification of the manufacturing unit is said to have been conducted by the Drug Inspector, Banka who, it is stated has made recommendation on 09.04.2020 for issuance of requisite licence. The said recommendation has been sent to the State Drug Controller cum Chief Licensing Authority but till date no decision has been taken in this regard.
4. Mr. Shahi, learned Senior Counsel submits that an exhaustive representation has been made before the Principal Secretary, Department of Health, Government of Bihar on 11.04.2020 in this regard but nothing tangible has been done so far. He argues that the Company manufactures raw material i.e. ENA, which is an essential ingredient for manufacturing alcohol based hand sanitizer. He has submitted that in similar circumstances, one M/s Globus Spirits Limited Company has been given such privilege, denying similar treatment to the petitioner in violation of Article 14 of the Constitution of India. He has further submitted that seeking similar relief, a writ application giving rise to CWJC No. 5608 of 2020 (M/s Fantasy Drugs Private Limited vs. The State of Bihar and others) was filed before this Court, which has been disposed of by an order of this Court dated 18.04.2020 asking the respondents to dispose of the representation within stipulated time.
5. Mr. Vikash Kumar, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the State of Bihar, on the other hand, has submitted that all cases of similar nature shall be considered on 29.04.2020 by a Committee whereafter a final decision shall be taken. He also submits that the petitioner’s case shall also be considered on 29.04.2020.
6. Considering the facts and circumstances as noted above and the submissions made on behalf of the parties, this application is disposed of with a direction that let a decision be taken on the petitioner’s application and his subsequent representation as noted above, in the light of the aforementioned stand taken on behalf of the State of Bihar.
7. Since there is a lockdown, the Court