SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
KHATIM REZA, J.
First Appeal No. 140 of 2013
(16.5.2024)
Smt. Leela Devi (deceased) & Anr. ... Appellants
vs.
Lal Bahadur Singh & Ors. ... Respondents

Act Referred

HINDU LAW : .

Headnote

Hindu Law – Partition – Appeal by unsuccessful plaintiff – When a partition suit is filed, defendant would be in a position to advance a plea that there is no unity of title on the basis of earlier partition by way of memorandum of partition of year 1966 – Defendants/respondents have failed to prove earlier partition in family – Appellant is daughter of a coparcener of joint Hindu family – Appellant being daughter is entitled to share by survivorship – There is unity of title and unity of possession over schedule lands – Property/lands would devolve upon plaintiffs-appellant and defendants/respondents in equal share – Judgment and decree passed in Title Partition Suit set aside and suit decreed – Appeal allowed. (Paras 56, 57, 59 to 62)

Advocates appeared:
For the Appellants : M/s Ranjan Kumar Dubey, Kumar Gaurav, Shashank Kashyap.
For the Resp. No. 1 : M/s T.N. Maitin, Sr. Adv., Rajeev Kumar Sinha.
For the Resp. Nos. 2, : M/s Ganpati
8 & 13 Trivedi, Sr. Adv. Subroteshwr De, Bishwanath Choudhary, Ritik Shah.
For the Intervenor-Resp. : M/s Surendra Kishore Thakur, Y. Madhavi.

Khatim Reza, J. – Heard Mr. Ranjan Kumar Dubey, learned counsel for the appellant, Mr. T. N. Matin, learned senior advocate assisted by Rajeev Kumar Sinha for respondent no. 1 and Mr. Ganpati Trivedi, learned senior advocate assisted by Subroteshwar De for respondent nos. 2, 8 and 13.

2. The present appeal has been preferred against the judgment and decree dated 08.04.2013 passed by learned Sub Judge-VIII, Patna in Title Partition Suit No. 213 of 2001 whereby the learned trial court has dismissed the suit on contest against the plaintiffs and ex parte against the non-appearing defendants.

3. Plaintiff nos. 1 and 2 are the original (plaintiff no. 1- appellant no. 1 died) appellants and original defendant nos. 1 to 17 are the respondents. Rest are substituted heirs of the defendants and newly added respondents during the pendency of the appeal.

4. The plaintiffs/appellant filed the aforesaid Title Partition Suit for preliminary decree for partition of half share of the plaintiffs in the suit properties detailed in Schedule-2 of the plaint in favour of the plaintiffs and against the principle defendants and by appointment of a Survey Knowing Pleader Commissioner, a separate Takhta of the plaintiffs’ share be carved out and on preparation of the final decree, the plaintiffs be put in possession over the allotted separate Takhta through the process of court, and also for temporary injunction against the principle defendants and cost of the suit.

5. As per the case of the plaintiffs, the suit land is the ancestral property of the plaintiffs and principle defendants. It is pleaded that one Matukdhari Mahto had a son, namely, Chhaterdhari Singh, who had two sons, namely, Kishun Singh and Ratul Singh. Kishun Singh had a son Bhattu Singh. Bhattu Singh had two sons, namely, Hira Singh and Moti Singh. Moti Singh died issueless in jointness of the family. Hira Singh had two sons, namely, Sita Ram Singh and Prabhu Singh. The said Prabhu Singh died on 20.09.2000 leaving behind his widow Leela Devi and a daughter, namely, Bimla Kumari, who are plaintiff nos. 1 and 2 / appellant nos. 1 and 2 respectively.

6. It is further pleaded that Sita Ram Singh died in the years 1997 leaving behind his two sons, namely, Lal Bahadur Singh and Krishna Singh, defendant nos. 1 and 2, and three daughters, namely, Dhanwanti Devi, Lila Devi and Pratima Devi, who are defendant nos. 10, 11 and 12. Defendant nos. 3 to 7 are the sons of defendant no. 1, namely, Lal Bahadur Singh and defendant no. 8 and 9 are the sons of defendant no. 2, namely, Krishna Singh. It is further contended that Kishun Singh and Ratul Singh, the two sons of Chhaterdhari Singh, constituted a joint hindu Mitakshra family of which Ratul Singh was Karta and manager of the family. During cadestral survey operation, Ratul Singh died issueless leaving behind his widow Punia Devi. Though Ratul Singh had died in jointness with Sri Kishun Singh but in order to console Punia Devi, the widow of Ratul Singh and also to get her feel secured got her name separately recorded over some lands of the joint family in the cadestral survey khatiyan. The land recorded in her name appertains to the land of Khata No. 11 and 47 are measuring 4.71 acres. The name of Kishun Singh was recorded over rest land of the joint family appertaining to Khata No. 3, 10 and 14. The name of Kishun Singh and Most. Punia Devi were separately recorded in survey khatiyan but the cultivation and management of all the lands were done jointly under the supervision and management of said Kishun Singh and his descendants. Punia Devi lived with her Devar Kishun Singh. The entire land of Khata No. 3, 10, 11, 14 and 47 after the death of Ratul Singh, remained in cultivating possession of Kishun Singh.

7. It is further case of the plaintiffs that Kishun Singh survived by his only son, namely, Bhattu Singh, who was survived by his two sons, namely, Hira Singh and Moti Singh. Moti Singh died issueless in jointness. On the principle of survivership, Hi

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top