SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2022 Supreme(Cal) 1241

IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Tapabrata Chakraborty, Partha Sarathi Chatterjee, JJ.
Gouri Chakraborty Alias Malakar - Appellant
Versus
Jyotsna Mazumdar & Anr. - Respondents
FA No. 2 of 2022, CAN 3 of 2022
Decided On : 12-12-2022

Act Referred

CONTRACT ACT : S.55, S.63
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE : S.144(2)
SPECIFIC RELIEF ACT : S.16(c)

Headnote

specific performance - contract - Indian Contract Act, 1872, Section 55 - Specific Relief Act, 1963, Section 16(c) - time not essence of contract - readiness and willingness to perform - [specific performance] - [contract] - [Indian Contract Act, 1872, Section 55, Specific Relief Act, 1963, Section 16(c)] - The court discussed the essence of time in a contract, the requirement of readiness and willingness to perform, and the legal provisions under the Indian Contract Act and the Specific Relief Act. The court emphasized that time was not the essence of the contract and that the plaintiff failed to prove her readiness and willingness to perform her part of the contract, leading to the decision in favor of the defendant.

Fact of the Case:

The plaintiff entered into an agreement for sale with the defendant for a property. The plaintiff alleged that the defendant did not supply the necessary documents and failed to perform her part of the contract. The defendant contended that the plaintiff was not ready and willing to perform her part of the contract.

Finding of the Court:

The court found that time was not the essence of the contract and the plaintiff failed to prove her readiness and willingness to perform her part of the contract. As a result, the court set aside the judgment and decree, directing the defendant to pay back the advance money to the plaintiff.

Issues: Essence of time in the contract, readiness and willingness to perform

Ratio Decidendi: The court emphasized that time was not the essence of the contract and that the plaintiff failed to prove her readiness and willingness to perform her part of the contract.

Final Decision: The appeal succeeded, and the judgment and decree were set aside. The defendant was directed to pay back the advance money to the plaintiff.

Advocates appeared:
Pinaki Ranjan Mitra, Advocate, Jaydip Basu, Advocate, S. Mukhopadhyay, Advocate, Haradhan Banerjee, Advocate, A. Pain, Advocate, Subhrangshu Dutt, Advocate,
Nilmoni Das, Advocate, Monidipa Pal Roy, Advocate, Tanmoy Bhattacharyya, Advocate

JUDGMENT

Partha Sarathi Chatterjee, J. - This appeal is directed against the judgment and decree dated 30.3.2019 passed by the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, 3rd Court, Howrah in Title Suit No. 159 of 2009 whereby the learned Court below decreed the suit being a suit for specific performance of contract.

2. Facts projected in the plaint, in brief, are that the defendant no.1/ appellant herein, namely, Smt. Gouri Chakraborty (hereinafter referred to as Gouri) happened to be the owner and occupier of the suit property. She acquired the property by way of gift from the Government of West Bengal on 1.7.1994 under the Refugee Rehabilitation Scheme and on 23.2.2008 she entered into an agreement for sale with the plaintiff/respondent no.1, namely, Smt. Jyotsna Mazumdar (hereinafter referred to as Jyotsna) to sell out the property at a consideration money of Rs. 12 lakhs and at the time of execution of such agreement for sale, Jyotsna paid Rs. 3 lakhs.

3. In the plaint, it was further pleaded that in the agreement, it was stipulated that Gouri would hand over photo copies of the documents relating to title of the suit property to Jyotsna within a week from the date of execution of the agreement but Gouri did not supply any document to Jyotsna and as such she could not verify the title of Gouri in respect of the suit property.

4. It was also claimed that ultimately at the end of 2008, Gouri supplied the documents and then Jyotsna conducted one search and being satisfied with the title of Gouri in respect of the suit property, she asked Gouri to fix up a date for execution and registration of deed of sale but Gouri did not respond to such request and on 25.2.2009, Jyotsna met with Gouri with a request to perform her part of contract but in vain.

5. It was further pleaded that on 20.10.2009, the defendant no.2/ respondent no.2, namely, Sri. Ajit Das (hereinafter referred to as Ajit) being an agent of Gouri took some masons and labourers on the suit property and started to make construction of boundary wall and on that date Jyotsna somehow resisted Ajit from making such construction and Jyotsna was forced to file an application under Section 144(2) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, which was registered as M.P. Case no. 1946 of 2009, before the Court of the learned Sub Divisional Magistrate (Executive) at Howrah.

6. It was also specifically averred that Jyotsna was ready and willing to perform her part of contract but Gouri was not willing to perform her part of contract. Hence, the suit.

7. Gouri resisted the suit by filing written statement wherein it was, inter alia, contended that suit is bad for mis-joinder of party and Ajit being unknown to Jyotsna and having no right, title and interest in the suit property was not a necessary party to the suit and suit was barred by limitation and the agreement dated 23.2.2008 was a void document and such agreement was not enforceable in law.

8. Ajit neither did enter his appearance nor did contest the suit by filing written statement or adducing evidence.

9. Record reveals that to substantiate her claim, Jyotsna deposed as PW-1 and one Bibhas Chandra Majumder deposed as PW-2 respectively and Jyotsna tendered some documents being the agreement for sale dated 23.2.2008, her income tax return for the financial years, 2008-09, 2009-2010, 2015-16 & 2016-17, balance sheet of her physiotherapy centre and four bank passbooks which were marked as Ext.1 to 5.

10. On the other hand, to negate the claim, Gouri adduced her oral accounts and was examined as DW-1 and she submitted some documents being her letter dated 13.5.2008 along with its postal receipt, A/D card, envelop and bank pass book which were marked as Ext. A to E.

11. As has been stated earlier, the learned Court below upon scrutiny of pleadings and upon appreciation of evidence of either of the parties, decreed the suit and hence, Gouri has impugned the judgment and decree, inter alia, on the grounds that the learned Court erred in holding that the G

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top