IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA CIRCUIT BENCH PORT BLAIR
BISWAJIT BASU, KRISHNA RAO, JJ.
The Chief Secretary and Others – Appellants
Versus
Satyendra Singh – Respondent
MAT Nos. 9, 10 of 2022, IA No. CAN/1 of 2023
Decided On : 28-04-2023
Constitution of India, 1950 – Article 226 –Appeal - Regularization of service - Single Judge has directed appellants to keep 15 posts vacant until disposal of writ petition or until further orders of Court -Held, Respondents/writ petitioners are working and there is already an order of injunction and appellants submits that they are not going to disturb respondents/writ petitioners – Court is of view that impugned order passed by learned Single Judge needs to be modified to extent that instead of keeping 15 posts vacant, appellants shall continue with recruitment process but appointment of 15 candidates in post of Junior Engineer and one post of Surveyor shall abide by result of WPA/39/2022 and WPA/40/2022 – Appellants are also directed in order of appointment of selected candidates, it should be specifically mentioned that their appointment shall be abide by result of WPA/39/2022 with respect to Junior Engineers and WPA/40/2022 with respect to Surveyor – CAN/1/2023 disposed of.
JUDGMENT :
KRISHNA RAO, J.
1. Both the appeals have been taken up for analogous hearing by consent of the parties as common issues are involved.
2. This appeal is directed against the interim order passed by the learned Single Judge in WPA No. 39 of 2022 (Smt B. Chandra Kala and Others vs. The Chief Secretary, A&N Administration and Others) with WPA No. 40 of 2022 (Shri Satyendra Singh vs. The Chief Secretary and Others) dated 24th August, 2022 wherein the learned Single Judge has directed the appellants herein to keep 15 posts vacant until disposal of the writ petition or until further orders of the Court whichever is earlier.
3. The interim order is in connection with the post of Junior Engineer. In the same order, learned Judge further directed that order passed in CAN/2/2022 shall be governed in WPA/40/2022 and the Administration is directed to keep one post of Surveyor vacant until disposal of the writ petition or until further order of the court whichever is earlier.
4. The respondents/writ petitioners have filed the writ petition No. 39 of 2022 praying for the following reliefs.
(b) A writ in the nature of mandamus directing the concernd authorities to grant equal pay for equal work of the ptitoners who are working at par with regular Junior Engineers of Zilla Parishad, PRI, Andaman & Nicobar Administration.
(c) A writ in the nature of mandamus prohibiting the concerned respondents from discontinuing the services of the petitioners as Junior Engineers in the Zilla Parishad, PRI, Andaman & Nicobar Administration till their services are regularised against the vacant sanctioned posts of Junior Engineers.
(d) A writ of and in the nature of Certiorari commanding the respondents to certify and transmit the papers relating to the instant case before this Hon’ble Court so that conscionable justice may be done by quashing any decision and/or action to discontinue the services of the petitioners.
(e) Rule NISI in terms of prayer (a) to (d) as above.
(f) An interim order be passed directing status quo of the service of the petitioners as Junior Engineers in the Zilla Parishad under PRI, Andaman & Nicobar Administration, till disposal of the writ application.
(g) Such further order or orders and/or direction or directions be passed as to Your Lordship may deem fit or proper.”
5. The writ petitioner in WPA/40/2022 prayed for regularisation of his service in the post of Surveyor and has prayed for similar relief.
6. Initially when the writ petition was moved on April 26, 2022, learned Single Judge had directed the parties to exchange their affidavits and also directed that the respondents/writ petitioners’ services shall not be disturbed till 31st July, 2022 or until further orders.
7. During pendency of the writ petition, the Andaman Public Works Department ( for short “APWD”) had issued vacancy notice for recruitment in APWD to Group ‘B’ (NG) vacant posts of Architectural Assistant, Assistant (Arch Dept.), Planning Assistant, Junior Engineer (Civil), Junior Engineer (Electrical & Mechanical), and Group ‘C’ vacant posts of Draughtsman-Grade-III(Civil), Draughtsman-Grade-III( Electrical & Mechanical) and surveyor proposed to be filled up in the APWD by conducting open recruitment examination.
8. From the said vacancy notice, 85 posts of Junior Engineer (Civil), 12 posts of Junior Engineer (Electrical & Mechanical) and 10 posts of surveyor are to be filled up including other posts which are not subject matter of this proceedings.
9. The respondents/writ petitioners in MAT/10/2022 claiming for their regularisation to the post of Junior Engineer and the respondent/writ petitioner in MAT/9/2022 is claiming for the post of Surveyor and accordingly, after the publication of vacanc
The main legal point established in the judgment is that temporary employees cannot claim regularisation once their appointment period expires, and erroneous regularisation of other employees does no....
The regularisation of temporary employees is a policy decision and cannot be mandated by the court.
The government cannot alter established seniority rights or conditions of service without due process and must adhere to principles of natural justice.
The court affirmed that employees continuing post-2016 have a right to regularization, and termination orders must be based on valid grounds.
The court affirmed that previous employment claimed by a Swechhasevi Sikshya Sahayak was invalid due to prior judicial orders deeming the recruitment process null and void, thus rejecting claims for ....
The discretion for granting interim mandatory injunction should be exercised in rare cases and not in a routine manner. The grant of interim mandatory injunction requires the highest degree of satisf....
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.