SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

1949 Supreme(Cal) 308

CALCUTTA HIGH COURT
Bengal Coal Co. Ltd. - Appellant
Versus
Balmukunda Goenka - Respondent
Appeal from Original Decree No. 86 of 1943
Decided On : 08-11-1949

Headnote

Mortgage Suit - Recovery of Property - [Bengal Coal Co., Ltd.] - [Recovery of khash possession of a certain premises in the town of Raniganj] - [Order XXX, Rule 1, Code of Civil Procedure] - The court discussed the description of the mortgaged property, the boundaries, the area, the rental, and the structures standing on the land. The court held that the decree passed in the mortgage suit was not void and non-existent in the eye of law, and the Plaintiffs acquired title to the property in suit by their purchase at the sale held in execution of the same. The court also found that the Plaintiffs purchased the whole of C.S. dag No. 4736 with the structures standing on it and established their title to the same.

Fact of the Case:

The suit was for recovery of khash possession of a certain premises in the town of Raniganj on declaration of the Plaintiff-Respondents' title thereto. The property was mortgaged and later sold in execution of a mortgage decree. The Defendants claimed that the property purchased by the Plaintiffs was entirely different from the property purchased by the Defendant No. 1.

Finding of the Court:

The court found that the decree passed in the mortgage suit was not void and non-existent in the eye of law, and the Plaintiffs acquired title to the property in suit by their purchase at the sale held in execution of the same. The court also found that the Plaintiffs purchased the whole of C.S. dag No. 4736 with the structures standing on it and established their title to the same.

Issues: The issues included the identification of the property purchased by the Plaintiffs and the Defendant No. 1, the description of the mortgaged property, and the boundaries, area, rental, and structures standing on the land.

Ratio Decidendi: The court applied the canon of construction that if the description by boundaries is precise and accurate, it prevails over the description by area. The court also considered the intention of the parties to the mortgage document and the schedule to the sale certificate in determining the extent of the property purchased by the Plaintiffs.

Final Decision: The appeal was dismissed with costs to the Plaintiffs Respondents.

JUDGMENT

P.N. Mitra, J. - This is an appeal on behalf of Defendant No. 1, the Bengal Coal Co., Ltd., in a suit for recovery of khash possession of a certain premises in the town of Raniganj on declaration of the Plaintiff-Respondents' title thereto.

2. It appears that one Kadambini Baurini, who was wife of one (sic) Bauri, took a lease 1 cotta 2 chh. of homestead land (sic) the Defendant No. 1 at an annual rental of Re. 1-11 as., by executing a registered kabuliyat in its favour on March 9, 1891 he land was described as lying within certain boundaries and here was a stipulation that, if she was found to be in possession (sic) more lands than that given in the schedule or if the lands ere found to be in excess on survey, she would be bound to pay aparate rent therefor. They built their dwelling house on the (sic) land. Later on, they borrowed some money from one (sic) Chand Marwari and mortgaged the land and dwelling (sic) to him. Unable to pay off the same, they, on March 14, (sic), sold to him by a registered kabala the said land and welling-house, which they called their bastu bati, the consideration being recited to be the dues on the mortgage and a sum of Section 100 in cash. They said they had altogether got four cottas land at Girjaparha in the town of Raniganj, out of which (sic) cottas constituted this bastu bati, which they were possessing on paying an annual rental of Rs. 1-11 to the Bengal Coal Co., Ltd. and which they described in the schedule to the kabala follows:

SCHEDULE OF BOUNDARIES.

To the west of the house purchased by Mahananda Datta, to the south of the (sic) wall of the railway barrack, to the north of the pucca road, to the it of the patit land--within these boundaries, I sell bastu bati, comprising two (sic) of land and pucca building consisting of two rooms.

3. On Mangal Chand's death, the property was inherited by his a Gokul Chand Marwari. In 1917, a jamabandi was made by (sic) Defendant No. 1. The land in the possession of Gokul and or Gokul Das, as he is called therein, was found to be (sic) cottas 14 chataks in area, an excess of two cottas chataks over the original area and the rental was fixed at Rs. 5. Thereafter, Gokul Chand died and the property devolved on his minor son Sriballabh. His mother Teji Bai got herself appointed as his guardian by the learned District Judge (sic) Burdwan and she, on behalf of her minor son, who was described as proprietor of the firm Puran Mai Mangal Chand executed, (sic) June 27, 1925, a mortgage in respect of the property describe in the schedule to the mortgage deed in favour of the fin named Shiu Karan Das Balmukunda. There is no dispute the Shiu Karan Das Balmukunda is the name and style under which the Plaintiffs were then carrying on business, but one of the controversies between the parties in the present suit centre round the question whether Shiu Karan Das Balmukunda was firm in the strict sense of the term, i.e., to say, a (sic) partnership, or was the name of the joint family business of the Plaintiffs. Another controversy relates to the question whether the entirety of the holding, which was the subject-matter of the jamabandi of 1917, together with the structures standing thereof or only a part of it was mortgaged by this mortgage deed (sic) June 27, 1925. The manner in which the mortgaged proper was described in the schedule to the mortgage deed has give rise to this controversy, but, before entering into the details it, the narrative of the events leading up to the present litigation may be completed. On August 7, 1930, a suit was brought enforce the mortgage, the Plaintiff being described as "A (sic) of the name of Shiu Karan Das Balmukunda of (sic) "Colliery" etc. It was Mortgage Suit No. 189 of 1930 of the Court of the Subordinate Judge at Asansol. The prelimina mortgage decree was passed ex parte on February 3, 1931 and (sic) final decree, also ex-parte, was passed on February 25, (sic). In execution of the decree in Mortgage Execution Case No. 93

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top