2017 Supreme(Del) 2054
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
SANJIV KHANNA, NAVIN CHAWLA, JJ.
SHRI NARENDER NATH - Appellant
Versus
SMT KRISHNA GUPTA & ORS. - Respondents
FAO(OS) 217 of 2013 & CMs 20033 of 2015, 38722 of 2016
Decided On : 06-07-2017
Important Points
Subject
Civil Law - Partition
Act Referred
DELHI HIGH COURT ACT : S.10
HINDU SUCCESSION ACT : S.4, S.8, S.19
LIMITATION ACT : Art.106
Headnote
Result – Appeal dismissed.
For the Appellant : Ms. Malavika Rajkotia, Mr.Ranjay N., Ms.Arpita Rai, Mr.Vaibhav Vats, Advs.
For the Respondent: Mr.Sudhanshu Batra, Sr. Adv. with Mr.H.D.Talwani, Mr. S.N.Choudhary, Advs
1. The present intra court appeal under Order XLIII Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 read with Section 10 of the Delhi High Court Act, 1968 impugns order dated 11th February, 2013 passed in IA No.7915/2011 filed by the appellant (defendant no.2 in the suit) in CS(OS) No.663/2011.
2. The impugned order also disposed of application No.7857/2011 filed by Ram Chander Nath, HUF, defendant no.4 in the said suit. The said defendant has not preferred any appeal.
3. Respondent nos.1 and 2 Smt.Krishna Gupta and Ms. Madhu Agarwal are the two plaintiffs who have filed CS(OS) No.663/2011 seeking partition, possession, rendition of accounts, permanent and mandatory injunction in respect of properties of Rajinder Nath and Co. HUF, defendant nos.1 and Ram Chander Nath, HUF.
4. The following table gives the relationship between the parties to the present appeal and the suit:-
| SH. SHAM NATH S/O LATE SH. BABU RAM (DIED ON 17-JULY-1978) | ||||||||
|
|
|
| Smt. Pisto Devi (Wife) (Died on 14-11-1992) |
|
| |||
| Sh. Ram Chander Nath (Son) (Died on 01-04-2002) |
| Sh. Rajinder Nath (Son) (Died on 24-08-1981) | Sh. Surinder Nath (Son) (Died on 02-06-1996) | |||||
|
| Smt. Maya Devi (Wife) (Died on 15-02-2010) | Smt. Kamla Devi (wife) (Died on 04-12-2009) | Veena Nath (Wife) | |||||
| Sh. Ashok K. Nath (Son) |
|
| Sh. Anuj Nath (Son) |
| Sh.Sanuj Nath (Son) | |||
| Sri Krishna Gupta (Daughter) (Plaintiff 1) |
| Smt. Madhu Agarwal (Daughter) (Plaintiff 2) |
| Smt. Sushma Sakhuja (Daughter) (Defendant 3) | Sh. Narender Nath (Son) (Defendant 2) | |||
5. The plaint claims and asserts that pursuant to the amendment to the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 by way of Hindu Succession Amendment Act, 2005, the plaintiff being daughters have acquired a right, title or interest in the Joint Hindu Family properties and are entitled to seek and pray for partition etc.
6. The appellant’s contention is that the judgment of the Supreme Court in Prakash & Ors. vs. Phulavati & Ors., (2016) 2 SCC 36, opines and holds that the aforesaid amendment is not retrospective and would not apply. Father of the respondent nos.1 and 2 i.e. the plaintiffs and the coparcener had expired on 24th August, 1981, which is before the aforesaid amendment. To this extent, the plea of the appellant may be correct. Equally the claim and cause of action pleaded in the plaint, is not restricted to the amendment vide Hindu Succession Amendment Act, 2005. Relevant in this regard would be averments made in paragraph 13 of the plaint, which read as under:-
“13. That Sh.Rajinder Nath died intestate on 24.08.1981 leaving behind his widow Smt.Kamla Devi, both the plaintiffs and defendants No.2 & 3 as his class I legal heirs. Therefore, the said legal heirs including Smt.Kamla Devi succeeded to and inherited all the individual assets of Sh.Rajinder Nath to the extent of 1/5th share for each of them in the said individual assets. The interest of Sh.Rajinder Nath in the joint family property to the extent of his 1/5th share in the assets of Rajinder Nath & Co. HUF was also inherited by the said class I legal heirs to the extent of 1/25th share for each of them. Subsequently Smt. Kamla Devi also died intestate on 04.12.2009 and all her individual assets as well as her 1/25th share in the assets of the Rajinder Nath & Co. HUF also devolved by succession and were inherited in equal share by her surviving Class-I legal heirs i.e. the aforesaid three daughters and the son Sh.Narender Nath.” Thus, the first and the second respondents have asserted their claim on “deemed partition” principle on death of their father Rajinder Nath in 1981. It is pleaded that he had died intestate and, therefore, the two respondents are entitled to 1/25th share each in the assets of Rajinder Nath & Co. HUF being Class–I legal heirs of their father. Claim or right is made also to assets or the share of Kamla De