IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Rajiv Shakdher, Amit Bansal, JJ.
Sanjay Kumar Baranwal - Appellant
Versus
Bhavna Kumari - Respondent
MAT.APP.(F.C.) 87 of 2019 & C.M. No. APPL. 13356 of 2019, C.M. APP. 407 of 2020, C.M. APP. 3144 of 2023, CM APPL. 42129 of 2023, CM APP. 50290 of 2023, CM APP. 50354 of 2023, CM APP. 50361 of 2023, CM APP. 50363 of 2023
Decided On : 28-03-2024
HMA - Interim Maintenance - Section 24 of Hindu Marriage Act, 1956 - [Section 24 of HMA] - The court discussed the application of Section 24 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1956, which provides for interim maintenance to either spouse during the pendency of any proceeding under the Act. The court considered the disposable income of the husband and the needs of the wife and children in determining the amount of maintenance. The court also took into account the change in circumstances, such as the daughter attaining majority and starting to earn, and the husband's alleged reduction in salary, in modifying the interim maintenance amount.
Fact of the Case:
The parties got married in 2000 and had two children. Disputes arose in 2018, leading to the husband filing for divorce. The wife sought interim maintenance under Section 24 of HMA, which was granted by the Family Court. Both parties appealed the decision.
Finding of the Court:
The court found that the elder daughter had started earning and thus, no maintenance was required for her. It also found that the husband's salary had not significantly reduced and that he was financially secure. The court modified the interim maintenance amount to Rs.44,000 per month with effect from July 2023.
Issues: The issues included the determination of interim maintenance under Section 24 of HMA, the change in circumstances affecting the maintenance amount, and the financial status of the parties.
Ratio Decidendi: The court's decision was based on the interpretation of Section 24 of HMA, the assessment of the husband's disposable income, and the consideration of the change in circumstances, such as the daughter's earnings and the husband's alleged reduction in salary.
Final Decision: The court modified the interim maintenance amount to Rs.44,000 per month with effect from July 2023 and directed the husband to clear any arrears of maintenance within four weeks. The Family Court was also directed to expedite the decision on the divorce petition.
JUDGMENT
Amit Bansal, J. - Both the appeals arise out of the same impugned order.
2. MAT.APP. (F.C.) 87/2019, has been filed by Mr Sanjay Kumar Baranwal (`Husband') seeking setting aside/modification of the impugned order dated 29th January, 2019, passed by the learned Judge, Family Courts, Dwarka, New Delhi (`Family Court') whereby the application filed by the Mrs Bhavna Kumari (`Wife') under Section 24 of Hindu Marriage Act, 1956 (`HMA') was disposed of, directing the Husband to pay a cumulative sum of Rs.66,000/-per month (Rs.22,000/-each to the Wife and the two daughters) as pendente lite maintenance, until the disposal of the divorce petition filed by the Husband under Sections 13(1)(ia) of the HMA.
3. MAT.APP. (F.C.) 159/2019, has been filed by the Wife seeking enhancement of the interim maintenance from Rs.66,000/-per month to a sum of Rs.1,25,000/-per month.
4. Briefly stated, the facts of the case are set out hereinafter. The parties got married on 8th March 2000, as per Hindu rites and ceremonies. Two children were born from the said wedlock on 13th March 2001 and 15th April 2006 respectively. Disputes arose between the parties in March 2018, which resulted in multiple rounds of litigation.
5. The present petition arises from a petition filed by the Husband seeking dissolution of marriage under Section 13(1)(ia) of the HMA, before the Family Court. During the pendency of the divorce petition, the Wife moved an application under Section 24 of HMA, seeking interim maintenance at the rate of Rs.1,25,000/-per month.
6. By way of the impugned order, the Family Court assessed the monthly disposable income of the Husband in the range of Rs.Rs.1,10,000/-per month and directed the Husband to pay a cumulative sum of Rs.66,000/-per month as interim maintenance, Rs.22,000/-each, to the Wife and the two daughters. The operative portion of the order passed by the Family Court has been set out below:
"18 The petitioner has no other liability except to maintain himself as well as his wife and both the children. Thus, entire disposable income of the petitioner of Rs.1,10,000 is required to be divided into 5 equal shares. Out of which one share is required to be given to respondent/wife Bhavna Kumari, one share to his daughter Ms. Sanhita Kumari, one share to his son Master (SIC) Shreya Sargam, one share to the petitioner and one additional share to the petitioner for his day to day needs and expenses. Thus, respondent is entitled to receive a total sum of Rs.66,000/- per month towards pendente lite maintenance from the petitioner.
19 In view of the above facts and circumstances, the application filed by the respondent is allowed. The petitioner is directed to pay a sum of Rs.66,000/- per month as pendente lite maintenance to the respondent from the date of filing of application till the disposal of petition.
The petitioner shall make the payment of arrear of maintenance within a period of three months from today. Any amount paid by the petitioner to the respondent as maintenance under the order of any court or otherwise shall be adjusted against the arrears. The application is accordingly disposed of."
7. Assailing the impugned order passed by the Family Court, both parties have approached this Court by way of the present appeals.
8. In the appeal filed by the Husband, the predecessor bench passed a detailed order dated 9th May, 2019, directing the Husband to pay a sum of Rs.66,000/- per month to the Wife including the school fees of the children and also directed him to clear arrears of maintenance awarded by the Family Court within 6 weeks. Further, the parties were referred to mediation. However, the mediation was not successful.
9. Subsequently, the Husband filed an application, C.M. No. APPL.3144/2023, seeking modification of the impugned order based on change in circumstances.
10. Broadly, the Husband seeks modification of the impugned order on the following grounds:
I. The elder daughter has attained majority in the year 2019. She has start
The main legal point established in the judgment is the application of Section 24 of HMA for the determination of interim maintenance, considering the parties' financial circumstances and any change ....
(1) Enhancement of interim maintenance – Family Court does not become functus officio after withdrawal of divorce petition and it can decide applications filed under Sections 24 and 26 of HMA, 1955 e....
The wife is entitled to an enhancement of maintenance based on the husband's income and the wife's financial situation. The court emphasizes the need for timely disposal of maintenance applications a....
Interim maintenance – Sustenance of a woman does not and cannot mean mere survival – A woman, who is constrained to leave matrimonial house should not be allowed to feel that she has fallen from grac....
The main legal point established in the judgment is the application of Section 24 of the Hindu Marriage Act and the principle that maintenance should not be less than 25% of the husband's monthly sal....
Interim maintenance—There should be grant of interim maintenance not only to see equal standard of maintenance of life by both wife and husband but also to ensure wife maintains a minimum standard of....
The court emphasized that the interim maintenance should be adequate, fair, and reasonable, and consistent with the standard of living of the aggrieved person. The court also highlighted the presumpt....
The court established that a husband's obligation to maintain his wife and children is paramount, and only statutory deductions from income are permissible in determining maintenance amounts.
An earning wife is not barred from claiming interim maintenance under Section 24 of the HMA; the court must assess whether her income suffices for her to maintain a standard of living equivalent to t....
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.