SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img



IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI
Ajit Prakash Shah, S. Muralidhar, JJ.
Office of the Chief Post Master - Appellant
Versus
Living Media India Ltd. - Respondent
LPA No. 418 of 2007
Decided On : 11-09-2009




Act Referred

POST OFFICE ACT : S.9
POST OFFICE RULES : R.30

JUDGMENT

S. Muralidhar, J.

LPA No.418 of 2007

1. The first-mentioned appeal LPA No. 418 of 2007 is by the Office of the Chief Post Master General and is directed against a judgment dated 28.03.2007 passed by the learned single Judge allowing the respondents' WP(C) No. 22679-80/2005. The aforesaid mentioned writ petition was filed by the respondents challenging the communication dated 08.11.2005 of the of the appellant whereby the respondents were informed that the booklet containing the advertisement of Toyota Motor Corporation in the form of a calendar, inserted in the Reader's Digest issue of December 2005 was neither a supplement nor part and parcel of the publication and therefore, the request for mailing of that issue on concessional rates cannot be acceded to. This was followed by another letter to the same effect on 21.11.2005. It may be mentioned here that Respondent No.1 is the publisher of Reader's Digest and is publishing it under a licence from The Raeder's Digest Association Inc. in the USA since October 2003. Prior thereto it was being published in India by the R.D.I. Print and Publishing Ltd.

2. The reasons given by the appellant for the denial of concessional rate was that "the said booklet has been bound and printed separately and merely stapled to the Reader's Digest". Secondly, "the booklet did not conform to the conditions prescribed in the department's letter No. 22.15/2000 PO (Part-II) dated 09.10.2001".

3. The conditions in the letter dated 09.10.2001 were that for bringing out a multi-page Toyota advertisement in the December 2001 issue of Reader's Digest, the respondents had to ensure the following :

(i) The advertisement had to be printed and bound along with other advertisement and articles in the magazine.

(ii) The advertisement had to be numbered in running numerical sequence and will also have the name of the magazine and issue month printed in a prominent position.

(iii) The extended cover would also be included in the total number of pages so that it will be conformity with the requirement of a registered newspaper.

4. The learned single Judge relied upon the earlier decision in Competition Success Review v. Union of India, 106 (2003) DLT 469 in which the provisions of Section 9 of the Indian Post Office Act, 1898 as well as Clause 139 of the Posts Office Guide, Part-I had been examined. The circulars dated 19.05.1999 and 25/28.06.1999 issued by the Postal Department with regard to the grant of concessional rates to magazines which included advertisements, were also discussed. As regards the first circular dated 19.05.1999, it was held that only where the pages constituting the advertisement are not accounted for in the pagination of the publication as a whole, the concessional rate would be unavailable. As regards the second circular dated 25/28.6.1999, it was held that it was not necessary that each of the pages containing the advertisement were also to be numbered as long so long as the pages were accounted for in the overall numbering of pages of the magazine.

5. On the facts of the present case, it was held that the impugned advertisement in the Reader's Digest issue of December 2005 was consecutively numbered. Both in the first and last pages it was prominently indicated that the advertisement was part and parcel of the issue. It was accordingly held that the impugned letters dated 8.11.2005 and 21.11.2005 were required to be set aside. The writ petition was allowed.

6. We have heard Mr. P.P. Malhotra, learned Additional Solicitor General, on behalf of the appellant and Mr. Rajiv Nayyar, learned senior counsel on behalf of the respondents. It is submitted by Mr. Malhotra that the Toyota Calendar 2006 was not an integral part of the main magazine and, therefore, not in conformity with Section 9(3) of the Indian Post Office Act (Act) and the Indian Post Office Rules, 1933 ("Rules'). It was submitted that the advertisement was in the form of calendar which could be pulled out a

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top