SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Judicial Analysis Court Copy Headnote Facts Arguments Court observation
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

1987 Supreme(Guj) 15

Gujarat High Court
Judgename :I.C.BHATT
Karnalsingh - Appellant
Versus
State of Gujarat - Respondent
S.CRI.A. 1274 of 1986
Decided On : 03/25/1987

Advocates Appeared: K.B.ANANDJIVALA, N.C.TRIVEDI, S.P.DAVE

Headnote:

Criminal Procedure Code 1973 - Rajasthan Sales Tax Act, 1954 - Jurisdiction - Checkpost staff - Case of prosecution is that petitioners are working as Sales Tax Officers in Anti-Evasion Branch in Sales Tax Department of State of Rajasthan - It was alleged that there was large-scale evasion of Sales Tax at situate near in Rajasthan on Road and that staff had joined hands with transporters and merchants of Rajasthan and trucks were entering in Gujarat State illegally from aforesaid check post. By communication Commercial Tax Department, Petitioners were given instructions to proceed to immediately and to anti-evasion activities in that area and also check up from Gujarat side and particularly to see that trucks entering Gujarat from these check-posts are checked - In view of this state of affairs on petitioners had gone to said place for the aforesaid purpose – Held, As second contention raised by Counsel for petitioners is concerned - It appears that there is no sufficient evidence to support say of complainant and from facts on record it appears that complaint has been filed as a counter-blast against action taken by petitioners - Petitioners had made report with regard to checking on itself and though complaint is made to appear as it was in fact filed after four days and criminal complaint was registered on This raises suspicion with regard to bona fides of complainant It may be stated that on notices were served - Owner of truck and staff personnel at were suspended - Therefore, in all probabilities Complaint filed by complainant appears to be a counter-blast to action taken by petitioners, as stated above - Petition allowed.

I. C. BHATT, J.

( 1 ) THIS Application has been filed by the petitioners for dismissing the complaint on the ground that there is no sanction under S. 197 of the Criminal P. C. The petitioners were the public servants as defined in the Rajasthan Sales Tax Act, 1954 and therefore, no prosecution can be initiated against the petitioners without the sanction of the Government of Rajasthan.

( 2 ) THE case of the prosecution is that petitioners 1 and 2 are working as Sales Tax Officers in the Anti-Evasion Branch in the Sales Tax Department of State of Rajasthan. It was alleged that there was large-scale evasion of Sales Tax at the Mukhampura Checkpost situate near Sachor, in Rajasthan, on Sachor-Tharad Road and that the checkpost staff had joined hands with the transporters and merchants of Rajasthan and the trucks were entering in Gujarat State illegally from the aforesaid checkpost. By communication dt. 19-11-1982 of the Commercial Tax Department, the petitioners were given instructions to proceed to Jaipur immediately and to organise anti-evasion activities in that area and also check up Maukhampura/abu Road Checkpost from Gujarat side and particularly to see that the trucks entering Gujarat from these check-posts are checked. In view of this state of affairs, on 25th Nov. 1982 the petitioners had gone to the said place for the aforesaid purpose. It is alleged that the petitioners found that one Truck having No. GTX 8317 coming from Maukhampura driven by one Dahyabhai Bhil containing 80 bags of matira seeds and 15 bags of jeera and it was found that no taxes were paid and it was not accompanied with proper and necessary documents. The driver was questioned and his statement was recorded by one member of the petitioners party. It is stated by the petitioner that the R. T. O. papers were taken away from the driver and it is stated that the petitioner 2 went to Maukhampura Checkpost to verify the contents of the statements of the driver and it was found that the driver had not deposited the papers at that checkpost and it was further alleged that the staff of Maukhampura checkpost was conniving with the drivers of the trucks in evasion of taxes and making down wrong entries showing that no goods were carried in the vehicle. They all returned in the jeep placing a guard on the truck. Thereafter, when they returned to the site of checking, they found that the truck had gone away with the driver. Ultimately, Sales Tax Notice was served to the owner of the truck and necessary report was submitted to the Commissioner, Commercial Taxes Anti-evasion, Rajasthan.

( 3 ) IT is submitted by the petitioners that a false complaint has been filed against them by Ramlal to whom Sales Tax Notice was served, as a counter-blast for the action taken by the petitioners and an attempt has been made to bring the case within the jurisdiction of State of Gujarat. It has been further submitted that on the same day i. e. 25-11- 1982, at about 2. 00 a. m the report regarding this checking was made. It has been further submitted that though the complaint has been shown as dt 26-11-1982, it had in fact gone to the court after about four days i. e. on 29-11-1982 and it was only a counter-blast of the action taken by the petitioners against the complainant The Criminal case was registered on 29-11-1982. The petitioners filed Application Ex. 49 in Criminal Case No. 437/82 for dismissing the complaint, before the Judicial Magistrate, F. C. , Tharad, under S. 197, Cr. P. C. , which came to be rejected. Against the said order of the Judicial Magistrate, F. C. , Criminal Revision Application No. 55/85 came to be preferred before the Sessions court, Banaskantha, and the learned Sessions Judge has also rejected the Revision Application. The petitioners have, therefore, filed this Special Criminal Application before this court.

( 4 ) LEARNED Counsel for the petitioners has raised the following contentions in this Application : (1) Without sanction under S. 197 of the Cr.







Click Here to Read the rest of this document
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top