2019 Supreme(Ker) 858
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
MARY JOSEPH, J.
Saju alias Sabu S/o Varghese – Appellant
Versus
St. Mary's Church Umminikkunnu, Pothanickadu – Respondent
A.S. No. 294 of 2002
Decided On : 28-11-2019
Important Points
The Advocate Commissioner was directed to prepare a Voters list incorporating all male and female parishioners who have completed 21 years of age irrespective of any factual affiliations in a context where conflicting interests on the governance of the church and its institutions were there and when most of the Parishioners had adopted the 1934 Constitution after having decided to scrap 1933 Constitution on their firm feeling that it will not suit for the administration of the church and other institutions.
Subject
Religious Organization Governance - Church Administration
Act Referred
Headnote
Constitution of India- Article 12- As per the constitution of 1934 (Article 7), all men who confess and receive holly qurbana atleast once an year and who have completed the age of 21 years may be the members of the parish assembly. As per Article 12 of the Constitution, the Vicar is the person authorised to convene a meeting of parish assembly members to conduct election. Article 14 shows that if the Vicar does not convene a meeting at the request of any party entitled, the Diocesan Metropolitan can be petitioned and his decision shall be implemented.
Statement of facts:
The appeal is preferred against the decree and judgment dated 25.06.2002 of the 1st Additional District Court, Ernakulam in O.S. No. 40/2000. The plaintiffs in the suit are the appellants and defendants are the respondents. The 2nd respondent died during the pendency of the appeal. The 3rd respondent was substituted by new Vicar. Therefore, legal heirs of 2nd respondent and the new Vicar were brought on record as additional respondents 4 to 6 vide order dated 10.07.2014 in I.A. No. 2351/2013.
Finding of the court:
As per the constitution of 1934 (Article 7), all men who confess and receive holly qurbana atleast once an year and who have completed the age of 21 years may be the members of the parish assembly. As per Article 12 of the Constitution, the Vicar is the person authorised to convene a meeting of parish assembly members to conduct election. Article 14 shows that if the Vicar does not convene a meeting at the request of any party entitled, the Diocesan Metropolitan can be petitioned and his decision shall be implemented. The relief sought is to direct the 2nd defendant to hold election in accordance with the voters list prepared by the Advocate Commissioner in O.S. No. 18/1977 which incorporates all male and female parishioners who have attained 21 years of age. This direction, if granted, will be in opposition to the provisions of 1934 Constitution.
Result: Dismissed.
Advocate Appeared:
For the Appellants : Sri. N. Sukumaran, Sri. Saji Varghese Kakkathottathil, Sri. Latheesh Sebastian, Sri. S. Shyam.
For the Respondents: Sri. Biju Abraham, Sri. B.G. Bhaskar.
JUDGMENT :
MARY JOSEPH, J.
1. The appeal is preferred against the decree and judgment dated 25.06.2002 of the 1st Additional District Court, Ernakulam in O.S. No. 40/2000. The plaintiffs in the suit are the appellants and defendants are the respondents. The 2nd respondent died during the pendency of the appeal. The 3rd respondent was substituted by new Vicar. Therefore, legal heirs of 2nd respondent and the new Vicar were brought on record as additional respondents 4 to 6 vide order dated 10.07.2014 in I.A. No. 2351/2013. The Original Suit was filed seeking reliefs as follows:
“(a) Removal of 2nd defendant from the office as Trustee (Kaikar) of the Church and to put the Church, its institutions and properties and all assets in the new Kaikars and Managing Committee elected by holding elections after preparing up to date voters list based on the basis of the one prepared by the Advocate Commissioner in O.S. No. 18 of 1977 of the 1st Addl. District Court, Ernakulam.
(b) Ordering the 2nd defendant to render accounts of the income and expenses of the Church from the date of his assuming the Management of the Church, pursuant to the decree in O.S. No. 18 of 1977 of the 1st Additional District Court, Ernakulam.
(c) Restraining the 2nd defendant from alienating any of the properties of the Church or committing waste or damage to such properties or making any change to their existing conditions.
(d) Cost of the Plaintiff.
(e) Such other relief or reliefs interim or otherwise which is sought for and this Honourable Court deems just and necessary.”
2. The suit was dismissed by the judgment under challenge and the aggrieved plaintiffs are now before this Court in the appeal suit on hand. Sri. N. Sukumaran, the learned Senior Counsel has contended that Ext.A7, a common judgment was passed in O.S. No. 4/1986, 206/1977 and 20/1994 on 29.07.1996 by the 1st Additional District Judge, Ernakulam (Special Court for Malankara Church cases) against the patriarch faction to which the plaintiffs belong and on dismissal of the appeal preferred from Ext.A7 by this Court and a Special Leave Petition filed against, by the Apex Court, it has become final. During the pendency of Ext.A7, Church was closed at the intervention of Executive Magistrate. Consequent to the closure, two factions had made alternative arrangements for meeting their religious needs. During the pendency of suits which led to Ext.A7 judgment, Church was made available for the two factions to conduct separate masses in turn. An Advocate Commissioner was appointed to conduct election of the administrative committee, to manage the assets of the Church. A voters list was prepared by the Advocate Commissioner as Ext.A5 and an election was conducted on its basis. The elected committee was in administration till the 2nd defendant and others assumed charge of the church on the strength of Ext.A7 judgment. Defendants 2 and 3 and others failed to administer the affairs of the Church or conduct valid elections on the expiry of their term of one year and the said circumstances necessitated the filing of the present suit seeking the reliefs as aforestated.
3. Before the trial court the plaintiffs and the defendants tendered oral evidence respectively as PW-1 and DW-1. Exts.A1 to A12 and Exts.B1 to B13 were marked. The trial court failed to appreciate the evidence in its proper perspective and thereby issues 2, 3 and 4 among the six issues raised were answered against the plaintiffs and that culminated in the dismissal of the suit. According to the learned counsel, the defendants fail to raise a plea that the suit was bad for non-joinder of necessary parties to the suit. According to him, in the said background, the trial court ought not to have raised non-joinder of necessary parties as an issue and dismissed the suit for that reason. It is further contended by the learned counsel that the trial court has proceeded on the wrong assumption that two factions namely Catholic and Patriarch, were there and the