2025 Supreme(Ker) 2980
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
SATHISH NINAN, P. KRISHNA KUMAR, JJ.
Venugopal K. Veloth, S/o. Leela – Appellant
Versus
Mahilamani, D/o. Parvathi and Ors. – Respondents
R.F.A. No.11 of 2017
Decided On : 07-11-2025
Important Points
Subject
Property Law - Partition
Headnote
(B) The analysis confirmed that the property belongs to multiple co-sharers and established mutual acknowledgement of rights among parties. (Paras 14, 15)
Facts of the case:
The ruling considered claims of exclusive rights over a property in a partition suit where the defendant argued for exclusivity based on conversion of rights and historical family arrangements stemming from a prior partition deed and sale agreements.
Findings of Court:
The appeal failed as the court upheld the trial court’s decision that the property right claims were unfounded and supported a partition among rightful co-owners.
Issues: The main issues revolved around the legitimacy of claimed exclusive rights over the property and its partitionability.
Ratio Decidendi: The court determined that usufructory claims do not establish exclusive property rights, emphasizing strict adherence to family law concerning shared belongings and their partition rights.
Result: Appeal dismissed.
For the Appellant : Sri. Mahesh V. Ramakrishnan.
For the Respondents: Shri. B. Krishnan, Shri. R. Parthasarathy.
| Table of Content |
|---|
| 1. challenge to the preliminary decree. (Para 2 , 3 , 4) |
| 2. points for consideration in the appeal. (Para 6 , 7) |
| 3. analysis of claims to exclusive rights. (Para 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 , 14) |
| 4. conclusion on partitioning the property. (Para 15) |
JUDGMENT :
Sathish Ninan, J.
The preliminary decree in a suit for partition is under challenge by the first defendant.
2. The plaint schedule consists of two items of properties. With regard to the partibility and shares of plaint item No.2 there is no dispute. In this appeal we are concerned only with the plaint item No.1 (hereinafter referred to as “the property”).
3. The property originally belonged to one Kadungon, the predecessor-in-interest of the parties under Ext.B1 Partition Deed of the year 1911. Thereafter on 30.08.2011 he executed Ext.A2 Will, bequeathing the property to his wife-Narayani, children and grand children. The plaintiffs seek for partition and separate possession of their 5/6 shares out of the property.
4. Defendants 1 to 3 contended that the property is not partible. It was contended that Narayani, the wife of Kadungon had given the property on 'melpattam' to her son-in-law, Anandan (husband of her daughter Lakshmi), and while so enjoying, she executed Ext.B3 document dated 25.04.1938, conferring on him the right to sink a well and construct a house in a portion of the property. Later, on 23.01.1943, Anandan conveyed the entire property to his wife Lakshmi under Ext.B4 Sale Deed dated 23.01.1943. Under Ext.B5 Sale Deed dated 06.05.1972, Lakshmi conveyed the property to the first defendant. Thus the first defendant claims exclusive right over the property.
5. The trial court negatived the claim of exclusive right by the first defendant, and passed a preliminary decree for partition.
6. We have heard Sri.Mahesh V. Ramakrishnan, the learned counsel for the appellant and Sri.B.Krishnan, the learned counsel for the contesting respondents.
7. The points that arise for consideration in this appeal are :-
(i) Has the first defendant obtained exclusive right over the property?
(ii) Is the property partible?
(iii) Does the decree and judgment of the trial court warrant any interference?
8. It is not in dispute that if the exclusive right claimed by the first defendant is not proved, the property is liable to be partitioned among the parties. It is also not in dispute that the property is a Tarwad/Tavazhi property. The claim for exclusive right of the first respondent is founded on the following:-
(i) A 'melpattam' right over the property granted by Narayani to her son-in-law Anandan (husband of her daughter Lakshmi).
(ii) Ext.B3 document permitting Anandan to sink a well and construct a house in a portion of the property.
(iii) Ext.B4 conveyance of the property by Anandan to his wife Lakshmi tracing right to Melpattam and Ext.B3.
(iv) Ext.B5 conveyance of the property by Lakshmi to the first defendant.
We proceed to analyse each of the above transactions.
9. Firstly coming to the Melpattam right of Anandan, the grant of such right earlier is acknowledged in Ext.B3 document. ‘Melpattam’ is only a right to take usufructs from the trees in the property. It does not create interest over the land. In Krishnan Nair & anr. v. Abdu [AIR 1965 Ker. 39 (F.B)], this Court held, “A melpattom (literally, a lease of what is above the surface) is a lease of trees with no interest in the land, ordinarily enuring for one year- see Sundara Iyer’s, Malabar and Aliyasanthana Law, pages 290 and 453 and C. Ramachandra Aiyar’s, A Manual of Malabar Law, page 42.”
