2025 Supreme(Ker) 2991
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
RAJA VIJAYARAGHAVAN V, K. V. JAYAKUMAR, JJ.
State Of Kerala, Represented By The State Public Prosecutor,High Court Of Kerala – Appellant
Versus
Subramanian Namboothiri s/o. Vasudevan namboothiri – Respondent
CRL.A NO. 696 OF 2018
Decided on : 30-10-2025
Important Points
Subject
Criminal Law - Child Abuse and Domestic Violence
Act Referred
INDIAN PENAL CODE : S.300, S.302, S.307, S.321, S.323, S.324, S.34
JUVENILE JUSTICE CARE AND PROTECTION OF CHILDREN ACT : S.23
Headnote
(B) Criminal Law - Burden of proof - Intent to kill must be established; injuries sustained were sufficient to establish murder; the culpability of the accused substantiated by both documentary and testimonial evidence. (Paras 96-99)
Facts of the case:
The prosecution alleged horrific abuse inflicted upon two minor children by their father and stepmother, resulting in the death of one child due to prolonged torture, lack of medical care, and malnourishment. The surviving child testified to the neglect and violence they endured. (Paras 2-8)
Findings of Court:
The court found overwhelming evidence of the defendants’ guilt in the death of the victim child, leading to a reversal of acquittal and a new conviction under harsher statutes due to misreading of evidence by the trial court. (Paras 92-111)
Issues: Whether the trial court correctly assessed the evidence to conclude no intention to kill existed; significance of medical evidence documenting the seriousness of injuries was assessed. (Paras 94-95)
Ratio Decidendi: The appellate court emphasized the necessity for a detailed reevaluation of evidence leading to the reversal of acquittal, stressing the established intent and egregious conduct within the familial relationship. (Paras 112-113)
Result: Criminal Appeal allowed; convictions under lesser sections affirmed; previous acquittal for murder reversed; respondents sentenced to life imprisonment. (Paras 120-127)
The legal judgment provided involves a case of severe child abuse resulting in the death of a minor, with the court ultimately holding the accused guilty of murder under Section 302 IPC (!) (!) . The court's analysis emphasizes that the evidence, including medical and circumstantial, clearly establishes that the accused inflicted injuries sufficient to cause death in the ordinary course of nature, demonstrating a shared intention and a brutal course of conduct (!) (!) (!) (!) (!) (!) (!) (!) .
The court criticizes the lower trial court for failing to properly evaluate the medical evidence and for misreading the evidence of witnesses, which led to an erroneous conclusion that the accused lacked the intention to cause death (!) (!) . It underscores that the injuries inflicted, such as blunt trauma and scald injuries, were sufficient to cause death and that the prolonged torture and neglect were integral to the cause of death (!) (!) (!) (!) .
Furthermore, the judgment clarifies that under the law, the intention to cause death is not always necessary for a conviction under Section 302 IPC if the injuries inflicted are sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death and were inflicted with knowledge of their likely consequence (!) (!) . The evidence shows that the injuries, especially injury No.16, were fresh and fatal, and that the injuries were inflicted in a manner indicating a common intention and a brutal, sustained assault (!) (!) .
The court also discusses the proper approach to appellate review of an acquittal, emphasizing that the appellate court has the power to review and reappreciate the evidence but should do so only when there are compelling and substantial reasons, such as the trial court's approach being manifestly unreasonable or illegal (!) (!) (!) .
In sentencing, the court considers the principles governing the imposition of the death penalty versus life imprisonment, noting that the case does not qualify as "the rarest of rare" for death sentence, and therefore, the accused are to be sentenced to life imprisonment (!) (!) (!) . The court confirms the conviction under Section 302 r/w 34 IPC and sentences the accused to life imprisonment along with a fine, with the fine amount to be paid as compensation to the victim's family (!) (!) (!) .
In conclusion, the court overturns the acquittal for the charge under Section 302 IPC, affirms the conviction, and emphasizes that the evidence demonstrates a heinous, prolonged, and deliberate course of conduct leading to the child's death, which warrants a conviction for murder with appropriate sentencing (!) (!) .
For the Appellant : ADV PUBLIC PROSECUTOR: ADV.NEEMA T V
For the Respondent: ADV SHRI.P.VENUGOPAL
| Table of Content |
|---|
| 1. facts of extreme child cruelty. (Para 2 , 3 , 4 , 5) |
| 2. prosecution argues against acquittal. (Para 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 , 23) |
| 3. court's examination of evidence and cruelty. (Para 68 , 70 , 81 , 82 , 84 , 87) |
| 4. legal standards for proving murder. (Para 97 , 108 , 110) |
| 5. final sentencing and conclusions. (Para 113 , 116 , 120 , 127) |
JUDGMENT :
K. V. Jayakumar, J.
1. Impugning the judgment of the learned Special Judge for the Trial of Offences against Children (Additional Sessions Judge-I), Kozhikode, the State of Kerala preferred this Criminal Appeal under Section 378 (1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
Brief facts :-
2. In this matter, the prosecution depicts a true picture of a heinous, barbarous and demonic torture by the father and stepmother on their little children.
3. One Subramanian Namboodiri (the 1st respondent herein) is a resident of Calicut, Kerala. His first marriage was solemnized with Sreeja Antharjanam. In that wedlock, two children were born, namely; Arun S. Namboodiri (PW1) and Adhithi S. Namboodiri (victim/ deceased). Later, Sreeja Antharjanam died in a road traffic accident.
4. Subsequently, the said Subramanian Namboodiri was married to the 2nd accused (Ramla Begum @ Devaki Antharjanam) in the year 2011.
5. The prosecution narrative is that, after the second marriage of the 1st accused (Subramanian Namboodiri) with Ramla Begum @ Devaki Antharjanam (2nd accused), they started to torture PW1 (Arun S. Namboodiri) and the victim/deceased (Adhithi S. Namboodiri) for a prolonged period. Ultimately, the continuous ill treatment, cruelty and torture, both physical and mental, has led to the death of Adhithi S. Namboodiri.
The prosecution case
6. The prosecution case, in brief, is that, the accused/respondents were residing in a house named ‘Lakshmi’ bearing door No.1/4283 of Kozhikode Corporation. While so, between 26.06.2012 and 29.04.2013, in furtherance of their common intention to cause the death of PW1 and the deceased, the children of the first accused born in his first wedlock, the accused subjected them to cruelty by beating them with hands and sticks, kicking them, not providing them with adequate food, compelling them to perform tiresome tasks, pouring boiled water on the private parts of Adhithi S. Namboodiri, and refusing to provide medical treatment to the deceased. The prosecution further alleges that at the time of the incident, PW1, the son was aged 10 years and the victim girl was aged 5½ years and was a student of Class I. The prosecution further alleges that due to the inhuman treatment of the accused, the girl succumbed to injuries on 29.04.2013.
The registration of FIR and investigation
7. On 30.04.2013, PW2 (Sreejith E.), the uncle of the deceased lodged Ext.P1 FIS before the Nadakkavu Police Station, Kozhikode. On the basis of Ext.P1 FIS, PW28 (Ramanan K.N.), the Sub Inspector of Police registered Ext.P24 FIR. On that day itself, PW29 (Santhosh P.K.), the Circle Inspector of Police, took up the investigation. He arrested the accused after preparing Ext.P25 arrest memo and thereafter, he recorded the confession statement of the 1st accused. On the basis of the disclosure statement of the 1st accused, and as led by him, PW29 recovered the wooden reaper (MO1) from the kitchen of his rented house.
8. On 02.05.2013, the Investigating Officer visited the place of occurrence and prepared Ext.P3 scene mahazar. He also seized the car used for taking the child to the hospital, as per Ext.P8 mahazar. He caused the scene of occurrence to be examined by PW17 (Mini D.), Scientific Assistant and collected samples of blood.
9. The Investigating Officer has also seized Ext.P7 rent agreement and Ext.P19 ownership certificate. During the investigation, he recorded 164 statement of PW1, Arun S. Namboodiri. He questioned all the material witnesses, recorded their statements, completed the investigation and laid the charge sheet before the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-IV, Kozhikode. The learned