Back
2014 Supreme(Raj) 443
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE RAJASTHAN AT JAIPUR
SUNIL AMBWANI & VEERENDR SINGH SIRADHANA, JJ.
Atar Singh Gurjar & Others – Petitioners
Versus
State of Rajasthan & Others – Respondents
Civil Writ Petition Nos. 10107, 10108, 10211, 10236, 10475, 10036, 10038, 10039, 10040, 10041, 10042, 10043, 10044, 10045, 10046, 10047, 10048, 10049, 10050, 10051, 10052, 10053, 10070, 10071, 10072, 10073, 10074, 10075, 10078, 10079, 10080, 10081, 10082, 10084, 10085, 10086, 10087, 10088, 10089, 10090, 10091, 10094, 10095, 10096, 10097, 10098, 10099, 10100, 10101, 10102, 10103, 10104, 10105, 10106, 10109, 10209, 10210, 10212, 10213, 10214, 10215, 10216, 10217, 10218, 10219, 10220, 10221, 10222, 10223, 10224, 10225, 10226, 10227, 10228, 10229, 10230, 10231, 10232, 10233, 10234, 10235, 10237, 10238, 10239, 10240, 10241, 10242, 10243, 10244, 10245, 10247, 10248, 10249, 10250, 10251, 10252, 10253, 10254, 10256, 10257, 10258, 10259, 10260, 10261, 10262, 10263, 10264, 10265, 10266, 10267, 10268, 10269, 10270, 10272, 10273, 10274, 10275, 10276, 10277, 10278, 10279, 10280, 10282, 10283, 10284, 10285, 10286, 10287, 10288, 10289, 10290, 10291, 10292, 10293, 10294, 10315, 10316, 10318, 10320, 10321, 10322, 10323, 10324, 10325, 10326, 10327, 10328, 10329, 10330, 10331, 10332, 10334, 10335, 10336, 10337, 10338, 10339, 10340, 10341, 10342, 10343, 10344, 10345, 10346, 10347, 10348, 10349, 10350, 10351, 10352, 10353, 10354, 10355, 10356, 10357, 10358, 10359, 10360, 10361, 10362, 10363, 10364, 10365, 10366, 10367, 10368, 10369, 10370, 10371, 10372, 10373, 10374, 10375, 10377, 10378, 10380, 10381, 10383, 10384, 10385, 10386, 10387, 10388, 10389, 10390, 10391, 10392, 10393, 10394, 10395, 10396, 10399, 10400, 10401, 10402, 10403, 10404, 10405, 10406, 10407, 10410, 10411, 10412, 10413, 10414, 10415, 10416, 10417, 10418, 10419, 10420, 10421, 10422, 10423, 10424, 10425, 10426, 10427, 10428, 10429, 10430, 10431, 10432, 10433, 10434, 10435, 10436, 10437, 10438, 10439, 10440, 10441, 10442, 10443, 10444, 10445, 10446, 10447, 10448, 10449, 10450, 10451, 10452, 10454, 10455, 10456, 10457, 10458, 10459, 10460, 10461, 10462, 10463, 10465, 10466, 10467, 10468, 10469, 10470, 10471, 10472, 10473, 10474, 10476, 10477, 10478, 10479, 10480, 10481, 10482, 10483, 10484, 10494, 10495, 10496, 10501, 10503, 10504, 10505, 10506, 10507, 10508, 10509, 10510, 10511, 10512, 10513, 10514, 10515, 10516, 10517, 10518, 10519, 10520, 10521, 10522, 10523, 10524, 10525, 10526, 10527, 10528, 10529, 10530, 10531, 10532, 10544, 10545, 10546, 10547, 10548, 10549, 10550, 10551, 10555, 10558, 10559, 10560, 10561, 10563, 10564, 10565, 10566, 10567, 10568, 10569, 10570, 10571, 10572, 10573, 10574, 10575, 10576, 10577, 10578 , 10579, 10580, 10581, 10582, 10583, 10584, 10585, 10586, 10587, 10588, 10589, 10590, 10591, 10592, 10593, 10594, 10595, 10596, 10597, 10598, 10599, 10600, 10601, 10602, 11024, 11574, 11597, 11598, 11601, 11603, 11605, 11612, 11615, 11616, 11617, 11619, 11620, 11621, 11622, 11624, 11625, 11626, 11665, 11666, 11667, 11669, 11670, 11672, 11673, 11674, 11675, 11683, 11684, 11685, 11686, 11687, 11688, 11689, 11690, 11691, 11718, 11785, 11786, 11790, 11799, 11801, 11802, 11803, 11804, 11805, 11806, 11807, 11808, 11809, 11810, 11811, 11812, 11813, 11816, 11817, 11818, 11824, 11826, 11837, 11838, 11839, 11841, 12023, 12029, 12059, 12061, 12062, 12063, 12064, 12067, 12068, 12070, 12071, 12072, 12084, 12085, 12086, 12087, 12088, 12089, 12090, 12091, 12092, 12093, 12094, 12096, 12097, 12098, 12099, 12103, 12104, 12128, 12129, 12130, 12131, 12132, 12133, 12134, 12135, 12136, 12137, 12138, 12139, 12140, 12141, 12142, 12256, 12258, 12262, 12265, 12354, 12355, 12356, 12357, 12358, 12359, 12360, 12361, 12362, 12363, 12364, 12365, 12366, 12367, 12368, 12369, 12370, 12371, 12372, 12373, 12374, 12375, 12376, 12377, 12378, 12379, 12402, 12403, 12404, 12405, 12406, 12407, 12408, 12409, 12410, 12411, 12412, 12413, 12429, 12430, 12431, 12432, 12433, 12434, 12435, 12436, 12437, 12438, 12439, 12440, 12441, 12442, 12443, 12444, 12445, 12447, 12448, 12449, 12450, 12451, 12452, 12453, 12479, 12480, 12481, 12482, 12483, 12484, 12485, 12486, 12487, 12488, 12489, 12490, 12491, 12492, 12493, 12494, 12495, 12496, 12497, 12498, 12499, 12500, 12501, 12502, 12503, 12504, 12505, 12506, 12507, 12508, 12509, 12510, 12532, 12657, 12658, 12659, 12660, 12661, 12662, 12663, 12664, 12665, 12776, 12784, 12786, 12787, 12788, 12793, 12795, 12796, 12797, 12798, 12799, 12800, 12802, 12804, 12805, 12806, 12807, 12809, 12810, 12811, 12812, 12814, 12816, 12817, 12819, 12820, 12823, 12824, 12826, 12827, 12828, 12829, 12832, 12833, 12921, 12922, 12925, 12926, 13106, 13318, 13933, 13934, 13937, 13938, 13946, 13949, 13952, 13954, 13957, 13958, 13961, 13964, 13971, 13972, 13980, 13981,13987, 13988, 13993, 13994, 13999, 14001, 14005, 14006, 14009, 14010, 14013, 14014, 14017, 14018,14021, 14022, 14025, 14026, 14029, 14030, 14033, 14034, 14037, 14038, 14041, 14042, 14045, 14046, 14049, 14050, 14053, 14054, 14057, 14058, 14061, 14062, 14065, 14066 14069, 14070, 14073, 14074, 14077, 14078, 14081, 14082, 14085, 14086, 14089, 14090, 14093, 14094, 14097, 14098, 14101, 14102, 14105, 14106, 14109, 14110, 14113, 14114, 14117, 14118, 14121, 14122, 14125, 14126, 14129, 14130, 14133, 14134, 14137, 14138, 14141, 14142, 14145, 14146, 14149, 14150, 14153, 14154, 14157, 14158, 14161, 14162, 12830, 12831, 12834, 12835, 12923, 12924, 13034, 13084, 13556, 13899, 13935, 13936, 13941, 13944, 13950, 13951, 13955, 13956, 13959, 13960, 13969, 13970, 13978, 13979, 13984, 13986, 13990, 13992, 13996, 13998, 14002, 14004, 14007, 14008, 14011, 14012, 14015, 14016, 14019, 14020, 14023, 14024, 14027, 14028, 14031, 14032, 14035, 14036, 14039, 14040, 14043, 14044, 14047, 14048, 14051, 14052, 14055, 14056, 14059, 14060, 14063, 14064, 14067, 14068, 14071, 14072, 14075, 14076, 14079, 14080, 14083, 14084, 14087, 14088, 14091, 14092, 14095, 14096, 14099, 14100, 14103, 14104, 14107, 14108, 14111, 14112, 14115, 14116, 14119, 14120, 14123, 14124, 14127, 14128, 14131, 14132, 14135, 14136, 14139, 14140, 14143, 14144, 14147, 14148, 14151, 14152, 14155, 14156, 14159, 14160, 14163, 14164, 14165, 14166, 14167, 14168, 14169, 14189, 14264, 14330, 14520, 14522, 14537, 14538, 14540, 15946, 18378, 18384, 18428, 18843, 9772, 9773, 9776, 9798, 9816, 9817, 9821, 9843, 9844, 9848, 9849, 9850, 9896, 9897, 9898, 9899, 9900, 9901, 9902, 9903, 9904, 9905, 9906, 9907, 9908, 9909, 9910, 9911, 9915, 9916, 9917, 9918, 9919, 9920, 9921, 9922, 10603, 10604, 10605, 10606, 10607, 10608, 10609, 10610, 10611, 10612, 10613, 10614, 10615, 10616, 10617, 10618, 10619, 10620, 10621, 10622, 10623, 10624, 10625, 10626, 10627, 10628, 10629, 10630, 10631, 10632, 10633, 10634, 10635, 10636, 10637, 10638, 10639, 10640, 10641, 10642, 10643, 10644, 10645, 10646, 10647, 10648, 10649, 10650, 10651, 10653, 10654, 10692, 10693, 10699, 10701, 10702, 10703, 10704, 10705, 10706, 10707, 10708, 10709, 10710, 10711, 10712, 10713, 10714, 10715, 10716, 10717, 10718, 10719, 10720, 10721, 10722, 10723, 10724, 10725, 10726, 10727, 10728, 10729, 10730, 10731, 10732, 10737, 10738, 10739, 10740, 10741, 10742, 10744, 10745, 10746, 10747, 10748, 10749, 10750, 10751, 10752, 10753, 10754, 10755, 10756, 10757, 10758, 10759, 10760, 10761, 10762, 10763, 10764, 10765, 10766, 10767, 10768, 10769, 10770, 10771, 10772, 10773, 10774, 10775, 10776, 10777, 10778, 10779, 10780, 10781, 10782,10783,10784,10790, 10791, 10792, 10793, 10794, 10795, 10796, 10797, 10798, 10799, 10800, 10801, 10802, 10803, 10804, 10805, 10806, 10807, 10808, 10809, 10810, 10811, 10812, 10813, 10814, 10815, 10816, 10817, 10818, 10819, 10820, 10821, 10822, 10823, 10824, 10825, 10826, 10828, 10829, 10830, 10831, 10832, 10833, 10834, 10835, 10836, 10837, 10838, 10839, 10842, 10843, 10844, 10845, 10846, 10847, 10848, 10849, 10850, 10851, 10852, 10853, 10854, 10855, 10856, 10857, 10858, 10859, 10860, 10861, 10862, 10863, 10864, 10865, 10866, 10867, 10868, 10869, 10870, 10871, 10872, 10873, 10874, 10875, 10876, 10877, 10878, 10879, 10880, 10881, 10882, 10883, 10884, 10885, 10886, 10887, 10888, 10889, 10896, 10898, 10899, 10900, 10904, 10905, 10906, 10907, 10908, 10909, 10910, 10913, 10914, 10915, 10916, 10917, 10918, 10920, 10921, 10922, 10923, 10924, 10925, 10926, 10927, 10928, 10929, 10930, 10931, 10932, 10933, 10934, 10935, 10936, 10937, 10939, 10940, 10941, 10943, 10944, 10945, 10946, 10947, 10948, 10949, 10951, 10953, 10955, 10956, 10957, 10958, 10959, 10968, 10969, 10970, 10971, 10972, 10973, 10974, 10975, 10976, 10977, 10978, 10979, 10980, 10982, 10983, 10984, 10985, 10986, 10987, 10996, 10998, 10999, 11000, 11001, 11002, 11003, 11004, 11005, 11006, 11007, 11008, 11010, 11011, 11012, 11013, 11014, 11015, 11016, 11017, 11018, 11019, 11020, 11021, 11022, 11023, 11025, 11026, 11027, 11028, 11029, 11030, 11031, 11032, 11033, 11034, 11035, 11036, 11037, 11038, 11039, 11040, 11041, 11042, 11043, 11044, 11045, 11046, 11047, 11048, 11049, 11050, 11051, 11052, 11053, 11054, 11055, 11056, 11057, 11058, 11059, 11060, 11061, 11062, 11063, 11064, 11065, 11066, 11067, 11068, 11070, 11075, 11080, 11081, 11082, 11083, 11084, 11085, 11086, 11087, 11088, 11089, 11090, 11091, 11092, 11093, 11094, 11095, 11096, 11097, 11098, 11100, 11101, 11102, 11103, 11104, 11105, 11106, 11107, 11108, 11109, 11110, 11111, 11122, 11123, 11124, 11125, 11126, 11127, 11128, 11129, 11132, 11133, 11134, 11135, 11136, 11138, 11139, 11140, 11141, 11142, 11143, 11144, 11145, 11146, 11147, 11148, 11149, 11150, 11151, 11152, 11153, 11154, 11155, 11156, 11157, 11158, 11159, 11160, 11161, 11162, 11163, 11164, 11165, 11166, 11167, 11168, 11169, 11170, 11171, 11172, 11173, 11174, 11175, 11176, 11177, 11178, 11179, 11180, 11181, 11182, 11183, 11184, 11185, 11186, 11187, 11188, 11189, 11191, 11192, 11193, 11194, 11195, 11196, 11197, 11198, 11199, 11200, 11201, 11202, 11203, 11204, 11205, 11206, 11207, 11208, 11209, 11210, 11211, 11212, 11213, 11220, 11221, 11222, 11223, 11224, 11225, 11226, 11227, 11228, 11229, 11230, 11231, 11232, 11233, 11234, 11236, 11237, 11238, 11251, 11252, 11253, 11254, 11255, 11256, 11259, 11260, 11261, 11262, 11263, 11264, 11268, 11269, 11270, 11271, 11272, 11273, 11274, 11275, 11276, 11277, 11278, 11280, 11281, 11282, 11283, 11284, 11285, 11286, 11287, 11288, 11289, 11290, 11291, 11292, 11293, 11294, 11295, 11296, 11297, 11298, 11299, 11300, 11301, 11302, 11303, 11304, 11305, 11306, 11307, 11308, 11309, 11310, 11315, 11316, 11317, 11318, 11319, 11320, 11321, 11322, 11323, 11324, 11325, 11326, 11327, 11328, 11329, 11330, 11331, 11332, 11333, 11334, 11335, 11336, 11337, 11338, 11339, 11340, 11341, 11342, 11343, 11344, 11345, 11346, 11347, 11348, 11349, 11350, 11351, 11352, 11353, 11354, 11355, 11356, 11357, 11358, 11359, 11360, 11361, 11362, 11363, 11364, 11365, 11366, 11367, 11368, 11369, 11370, 11371, 11372, 11373, 11374, 11375, 11376, 11377, 11378, 11379, 11380, 11381, 11382, 11383, 11384, 11385, 11386, 11387, 11388, 11389, 11390, 11391, 11392, 11393, 11395, 11396, 11397, 11398, 11399, 11400, 11401, 11402, 11410, 11411, 11412, 11413, 11414, 11415, 11416, 11417, 11418, 11419, 11420, 11421, 11422, 11423, 11424, 11425, 11426, 11427, 11428, 11429, 11430, 11431, 11432, 11433, 11434, 11435, 11436, 11437, 11438, 11439, 11440, 11441, 11442, 11443, 11444, 11445, 11446, 11447, 11448, 11449, 11450, 11451, 11452, 11453, 11454, 11455, 11456, 11457, 11458, 11459, 11460, 11461, 11462, 11463, 11464, 11465, 11466, 11467, 11468, 11469, 11470, 11471, 11472, 11473, 11474, 11475, 11476, 11477, 11479, 11480, 11481, 11482, 11483, 11484, 11485, 11486, 11487, 11488, 11489, 11490, 11491, 11492, 11493, 11494, 11495, 11496, 11497, 11498, 11499, 11500, 11501, 11502, 11503, 11504, 11505, 11506, 11507, 11508, 11509, 11510, 11511, 11513, 11514, 11515, 11516, 11517, 11518, 11519, 11521, 11522, 11523, 11524, 11525, 11526, 11527, 11528, 11529, 11530, 11531, 11532, 11533, 11534, 11535, 11536, 11537, 11538, 11539, 11540, 11541, 11542, 11543, 11544, 11545, 11546, 11547, 11548, 11549, 11551, 11552, 11553, 11554, 11555, 11556, 11557, 11558, 11559, 11560, 11561, 11562, 11563, 11564, 11565, 11566, 11567, 11568, 11569, 11570, 11571, 11572, 11573, 11576, 11581, 11582, 11583, 11584, 11585, 11586, 11588, 11589, 11592, 11593 of 2013 and 3189 of 2014
Decided On : 26.11.2014
Ms. Naina Saraf, Mr. Gaurav Sharma, Mr. Govind Choudhary, Mr. Tanveer Ahmed, Mr. Iliyas Khan, Mr. Govind Gupta, Mr. Govind Sharma, Mr. H.P. Bairwa, Mr. H.R. Kumawat, Mr. Hans Kumar Sharma, Mr. Hans Raj Kuldeep, Mr. Hanuman Choudhary, Mr. Hari Kishan Sharma, Mr. A.R. Meena, MR. Hari Prasad Jangid, MR. Harsh Saini, MR. Hem Singh Rathore, MR. Hemant Kumar Sharma, MR. Hoshyer Singh, MR. Imran Khan, MR. Intjar Ali, MR. Ishwar Jain, MR. J.P. Gargey, Mr. Jai Kishan Yogi, Mr. J.R. Tantia, Mr. Jitendra Kumar Sharma, Mr. K.K. Binda, Mr. K.L. Meena, Mr. K.S. Faujdar, MR. K.C. Sharma, Mr. K.C. Surela, Mr. K.K. Sahu, Mr. Kailash Choudhary, Mr. Kailash Sharma, Mr. Kamal Kumar Mathur, Mr. Kamal Singh Loha, Mr. Kamlesh Kumar Sahu, Mr. Kapil Gupta, Mr. Keshav Agarwal, Mr. Krishna Sharma, Mr. Krishna Swami, Mr. Kuldeep Aswal, Mr. Kuldeep Sharma, Mr. Lalit Sharma, Mr. Laxmi Kant Sharma, Mr. Lokesh Parihar, Mr. Lokesh Sharma, Mr. M. Aslwam, Mr. M.F. Baig, Mr. Bhupendra Pareek, Mr. Bhuvnesh Sharma, Mr. Bijendra Kumar Yadav, Mr. Brij Sharma, Mr. Brijesh Bhardwaj, Mr. C.J. Chopra, Mr. C.K. Jain, Mr. C.P.Sharma, Mr. C.S. Meena, Mr. C.M. Verma, Mr. Chain Singh Rathore, Mr. Champeshwar Goyal, Mr. D.C. Gupta, Mr. D.D. Khendelwal, Mr. D.P. Sharma, Dr. S.S. Rathore, Mr. D.S. Bagodia, Mr. D.S. Dhariwal, Mr. D.K. Dixit, Dr. Pushpendra Pal Singh, Dr. Saugath Roy, Mr. D.S. Kurka, MR. Dilip Singh Jalod, Mr. Deepak Pareek; Mr. Devendra Kumar Bhardwaj, MR. Devi Sahay Sharma, Mr. Devi Singh Choudhary, MR. Dharmendra Barala, Mr. Dileep Sinsinwar; MR. Dinesh Kumar Garg, Dr. P.C. Jain, Mr. F.R. Meena, MR. G.L. Sharma, Mr. G.K. Bhardwaj, Mr. G.K. Sharma, Mr. Gajendra Sharma, Mr. Ganesh Chaturvedi, Mr. Ganesh Kumar Sharma, Mr. Ghanshyam Shama, Mr. Girraj Prasad, MR. Gopal Gupta, Mr. A.A. Rathore, Mr. Ashish Sharma, Mr. Atish Jain, MR. Abdul Rahim Khan, Mr. Ajay Gupta, MR. Ajay Kumar Taneja, Mr. Ajay Rajawat, Mr. Ajay Singh, Mr. Ajeet Kumar Sharma, Ms. Akanksha Saxena, Mr. Akbar Khan, Mr. Akhil Simlote, Mr. Alam Bhardwaj, Mr. Alladeen Khan, Mr. Amit Kumar Jain, Mr. Amit Singh Shekhawat, Mr. Amrit Prasad Sharma, Mr. Anand Sharma, Mr. Anil Jain, Mr. Anil Kumar Sharma, Mr. Anil Vaishnav, Ms. Anita Khandalwal, Mr. Ankur Rastogi, Mr. Ankur Srivastav, Mr. Anshuman Saxena, Mr. Anup Agarwal, Mr. Anup Dhand, Mr. Sandeep Kumar Meena, Mr. Jagdish Nagar, Mr. Anurag Shukla, Mr. Arun Singh Shekhawat, Mr. Arvind Chawla, Mr. Arvind Kumar Arora, Mr. Arvind Sharma, Mr. Asgar Khan, Mr. Ashivindra Gautam, Mr. Ashok Bansal, Mr. Ashok Singh Shekhawat, Mr. Ashok Yadav, Mr. Atul Kumar Jain, Mr. B.D. Prakash Saini, Mr. B.C. Chirania, Mr. Ravi Chirania, Mr. B.M. Sharma, Mr. B.P. Sharma, Mr. Bal Kishan Saini, Mr. Balveer Singh Beniwal, Mr. Banwari Lal Saini, Mr. Banwari Sharma, Mr. Bharat Singh, Mr. Ravi Meena, Mr. Ravi Shankar Sharma, Ms. Rekha Arora, Mr. Rohit Sharma, Mr. Rohitashwa Kajla, Mr. S.D. Sharma, Mr. S. Gaharana, Mr. S.S. Hora, Mr. S.K. Saxena, Mr. S.L. Kumawat, Mr. S.M. Meena, Mr. S.N. Meena, Mr. S.N. Soorwal, Mr. S.R. Choudhary, Mr. S.S. Hasan, MR. S.K. Pareek, MR. S. Kalvania, MR. Shailendra Balwada, Mr. Samay Singh, MR. Smeer Shama, Mr. Sanchit Tamra, MR. Sandeep Bhagwati, MR. Sandeep Garssa, MR. Sanjay Buri, MR. Sanjay Mehla, MR. Sanjay Sharma, MR. Santosh Singh Shekhawat, MR. Santosh Srivastav, MR. Sarad Tanwar, MR. Satendra Kumar Sharma, MR. Satish Khandelwal, MR. Satyapal Poshwal, MR. Shashi Sharma, Mr. S.S.Shekhawat, Mr. Shrey Gaharana, MR. Shribhan Gurjar, Ms. Shruti Pareek; MR. Sitaram Samota, Smt. Shashi Choudhary, MR. Sobhit Vyas, MR. Subhash Bairwa, MR. Subhash Sharma, MR. Sudesh Kumar Pareek, MR. Sudarshan Ladda, MR. Sudhindra Kumawat, MR. Surendra Kolari, Mr. Sultan Singh Kuri, Ms. Suman Sharma, MR. Sumer Singh, MR. Sumit Bishnoi, Mr. Sumit Choudhary, MR. Sumit Jain, MR. P.N. Paliwal, MR. Pradeep Mathur, MR. Pradeep Singh, MR. Prahlad Sharma, MR. Prashant Kumar, MR. Praveen Sharma, MR. Prem Chand Dewanda, MR. Puman Chand Sharma, MR. Puran Chand Verma, MR. Pyarelal, MR. R.A. Khan, MR. R.B. Sharma Ganthola, MR. R.D. Meena, MR. R.D. Singh Naruka, MR. R.K. Gouttam with Mr. G.S. Gouttam, MR. R.D. Sharma, MR. R.H. Bhardwaj, MR. R.K. Saini, MR. R.S. Sharma, MR. Raghunandan Sharma, MR. Rahmat Khan, MR. Raj Kumar Kasana, MR. Raj Kumar Sharma, MR. Raja Ram Choudhary, MR. Rajeev Sogarwal, MR. Rajeev Vashishtha, MR. Rajendra Prasad Sharma, MR. Rajendra Sharma, MR. Rajendra Soni, MR. Rajesh Bhamboo, MR. Rajesh Chandel, MR. Rajesh Chaturvedi, MR. Rajesh Mootha, MR. Rajesh Parasar, MR. Rajesh Sharma with Mr. Mahendra Pareek, MR. Raj Kumar Goyal, MR. Rajveer Sharma, MR. Rakesh Arora, MR. Rakesh Paliwal, MR. Ram Babu Sharma, MR. Ram Kapil, MR. Ram Pratap Saini, MR. Ram Rakh Sharma, Ms. Rashmi Jain, MR. M.K. Tiwari, MR. M. Bhardwaj, MR. M.I. Abbasi, Mr. M.K. Chaturvedi, MR. M.K. Goyal, Ms. Suman Sharma, MR. Mahendra Shah, Mr. Vigyan Shah, MR. Mahendra Sharma, MR. Mahendra Singh Gurjar, MR. Mamraj Jat, MR. Manish Sharma, MR. Manoj Awasti, MR. Manoj K. Sharma, MR. Manoj Singh Raghav, Ms. Meenu Verma, MR. Mohan Choudhary with Mr. Vimlesh Choudhary, MR. Moharpal Singh Meena, MR. M.S. Gothwal, MR. Mukesh Kumar Goyal, MR. Mukesh Puniya, MR. Mukesh Sharma, MR. Manish Bhardwaj, MR. N.K. Saini, MR. N.K. Singhal, MR. Narendra Saini, MR. Narendra Singh Handa, MR. Naresh Gupta, Mr. Narpat Singh, MR. Naval Singh Sikarwar, MR. Naveen Bhuwan, MR. Neeraj Joshi, Ms. Nidhi Khendlwal, Mr. Nikhilesh Katara, MR. Niraj Joshi, MR. Nitesh Kumar Garg, Mr. Nitish Bhagri, Ms. Nitu Dave, Mr. O.P. Jhajhria, Mr. O.P. Sharma, Mr. Omveer Singh Saini, Mr. P.K. Sharma, Mr. P.K. Dhakad, MR. P. Mali, MR. Pankaj Agarwal, MR. Pankaj Sharma, Ms. Pradeep Lata Mathur, MR. Pradeep Malik, Mr. Pradeep Kalwania, MR. Pawan Kumar Sharma, MR. Sumit Khandwal, MR. Sunil Kumar Singodia, MR. Sunil Kumar Jain, MR. Sunil Kumar Saini, MR. Surendra Mal, MR. Suresh Dhenwal, MR. Suresh Kumar, MR. Suresh Kumar Pareek, MR. Suresh Singh, MR. Swaraj Panwar, Ms. Sweta Pareek Roy, MR. T.C. Sharma, MR. T.L. Pandey, MR. Takat Singh, MR. Tarun Jain, MR. Om Shankar Pandey, MR. Umesh Vyas, MR. V. Kabra, MR. V.S. Fojdar, MR. Vibhor Sharma, MR. Vidhut Gupta, Mr. Vijay Choudhary, MR. Vijay Pathak, MR. Vijendra Kumar Yadav, Mr. Vikash Jakhar, Mr. Viliyam Pathak, MR. Vinay Panday, MR. Vinayak Joshi, Mr. Vinod Goyal, Mr. Vinod Kumar Sharma, Mr. Vinod Sharma, MR. Vivek Choudhary, MR. Vivek Goyal, MR. Y.K. Sharma, Mr. Yogendra Jain, MR. Yogesh Singhal, MR. Yunus Khan for the Petitioners.
Mr. Dharamveer Tholia, AAG with MR. Rajan Prajapati, MR. Anurag Choudhary, MR. Vikram Singh, MR. Sumit Choudhary, Mr. Varun Choudhary and MR. Himanshu Tholia for the Respondents.
The classification under the Rules of 2013 for counting the experience for giving weightage is confined to those employees who are employed in connection with school education and are directly under the control and supervision of the State Government.
Headnote:
The Rajasthan Education Assistant Services Rules, 2013 (Rules of 2013) provide weightage for experience gained in any Government School/Government Educational Projects viz. Lok Jumbish Pariyojana/Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan/District Primary Education Programme/Rajiv Gandhi Pathshala/Shiksha Karmi Board and Madarsa listed under the Madarsa Board. The petitioners, who were employed in various other categories of employments, such as Preraks/Nodal Prerak, Mobile Teachers, Computer Instructors, Caregivers, Resource Teachers, Vidhyarthi Mitra, Aanganwari Workers, Girl Child Motivators, and Teachers in private recognized institutions, challenged the Rules of 2013, claiming discrimination for excluding their experience for weightage and age relaxation in recruitment to the post of Education Assistant. The Court held that the classification under the Rules of 2013 for counting the experience for giving weightage is confined to those employees who are employed in connection with school education and are directly under the control and supervision of the State Government. The Court found that the petitioners' employments were not directly connected with school education nor were they working under the control and supervision of the State Government. Therefore, the Court dismissed the petitions, holding that the Rules of 2013 do not cause any discrimination.
Fact of the Case:
The petitioners, who were employed in various categories of employments, such as Preraks/Nodal Prerak, Mobile Teachers, Computer Instructors, Caregivers, Resource Teachers, Vidhyarthi Mitra, Aanganwari Workers, Girl Child Motivators, and Teachers in private recognized institutions, challenged the Rajasthan Education Assistant Services Rules, 2013 (Rules of 2013), claiming discrimination for excluding their experience for weightage and age relaxation in recruitment to the post of Education Assistant.
Finding of the Court:
The Court held that the classification under the Rules of 2013 for counting the experience for giving weightage is confined to those employees who are employed in connection with school education and are directly under the control and supervision of the State Government. The Court found that the petitioners' employments were not directly connected with school education nor were they working under the control and supervision of the State Government. Therefore, the Court dismissed the petitions, holding that the Rules of 2013 do not cause any discrimination.
Issues: 1. Whether the Rules of 2013 discriminate against the petitioners by excluding their experience for weightage and age relaxation in recruitment to the post of Education Assistant? 2. Whether the petitioners' employments are directly connected with school education and are under the control and supervision of the State Government?
Ratio Decidendi: The Court held that the classification under the Rules of 2013 for counting the experience for giving weightage is confined to those employees who are employed in connection with school education and are directly under the control and supervision of the State Government. The Court found that the petitioners' employments were not directly connected with school education nor were they working under the control and supervision of the State Government. Therefore, the Court dismissed the petitions, holding that the Rules of 2013 do not cause any discrimination.
Final Decision: The Court dismissed the petitions, holding that the Rules of 2013 do not cause any discrimination.
1. We have heard learned counsel appearing for the petitioners
2. In this batch of writ petitions, heard at length, the petitioners have prayed to declare the Rules 15 and 25 of the Rajasthan Education Assistant Services Rules, 2013 (for short, “the Rules of 2013”) ultra vires to the extent that it does not include the experience of petitioners working as Prerak/Nodal Prerak and in other category of employment on daily wages, contract or in temporary employment, for the purposes of providing weightage in awarding the bonus marks and age relaxation in recruitment to the post of Education Assistant vide advertisement issued on 30.5.2013, for direct recruitment on 33,689 posts of Education Assistants published by the Director, Primary Education, Rajasthan.
3. The petitioners in other writ petitions, heard together, have also claimed the similar reliefs in respect of alleged discrimination met out to them in excluding their experience for weightage in the selections, of variety of employments, namely, Mobile Teachers in the Schools run by Bharti Telecom under the Sarva Shikha Abhiyan, Computer Instructors in different Schools and Colleges in pursuance of the Policy of the State of Rajasthan to impart computer education in the Schools through the private Companies engaged to provide Computer Instructors alongwith computers on a fixed amount under the Integrated Scheme for Computer Education and ITC, Caregivers and Resource Teachers for physically challenged children under the Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan, Vidhyarthi Mitra under the Vidhyarthi Mitra Scheme, Lower Division Clerks/DPEP, Aanganwari Workers serving under Mahila Bal Vikas Yojna, Girl Child Motivators and Teachers appointed in private recognized institutions by Vidhyalaya Samities under the Non-formal Education Programme, employees serving in Kasturba Gandhi Residential Balika Vidhyalaya established under the Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan Scheme, Motivators in the Labour Schools run by the State Government, Prabodhak and the Teachers serving under the Lok Jumbish Programme of the State Government. All these categories of employees engaged in the Schools and institutions for facilitation of education of children in various Schemes have challenged their exclusion in the recruitment on 33,689 posts of Education Assistant under the Rules of 2013, for which an advertisement was published inviting applications on-line on 30.5.2013 by the office of the Director, Primary Education, Rajasthan, Bikaner.
4. In all these cases, apart from challenge on the ground of discrimination with the aforesaid category employment in various Schemes, the petitioners have also prayed for directions to give them the age relaxation and to give weightage in award of bonus marks equal to the categories of employments under Section 2(k) of the Rules of 2013 defining “experience” and providing for weightage for the experience gained in any Government School/Government Educational Projects viz. Lok Jumbish Pariyojana/Sarva Shiksha Abhiyan/District Primary Education Programme/Rajiv Gandhi Pathshala/Shiksha Karmi Board and Madarsa listed under the Madarsa Board. The petitioners have also alleged discrimination with those employees, whose experience is to be otherwise counted for the purposes of giving bonus marks, as also exclusion on the ground that they were recruited on contract and in some cases through the Placement Agencies.
5. In exercise of the powers conferred by the proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution of India, the Governor of Rajasthan made the Rules of 2013 regulating recruitment to the posts in, and the conditions of service of persons appointed as Education Assistants. By a Notification dated 28.5.2013 issued by the Department of Personnel (A-Gr.II), Government of Rajasthan, Jaipur, the said Rules were notified to come into force with immediate effect. The 'Appointing Authority' under Rul
