2019 Supreme(HP) 796
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT SHIMLA
Jyotsna Rewal Dua, J.
Master Anmol Sharma Through His Mother - Appellant
Vs.
Vikrant Seth And Another - Respondent
Regular Second Appeal No. 495 of 2007
Decided On : 06-09-2019
Act Referred
HIMACHAL PRADESH URBAN RENT CONTROL ACT : S.14
HINDU SUCCESSION ACT : S.8, S.6
Headnote
COPARCENARY PROPERTY - SUIT PROPERTY - SALE - VALIDITY - COPARCENARY NATURE OF PROPERTY CEASED TO EXIST - SUCCESSION OPENED UNDER HINDU SUCCESSION ACT, 1956 - PROPERTY BECAME SELF-ACQUIRED PROPERTY - NO EMBARGO ON ALIENATION - AGREEMENT TO SELL AND SALE DEED EXECUTED IN ACCORDANCE WITH LAW - NO LEGAL NECESSITY TO EXECUTE DOCUMENTS - SUIT PROPERTY NOT COPARCENARY ON DATE OF EXECUTION OF AGREEMENT TO SELL AND SALE DEED - NO EMBARGO ON DEFENDANT TO EXECUTE DOCUMENTS IN FAVOUR OF PURCHASER - SUBSTANTIAL QUESTION OF LAW ANSWERED AGAINST APPELLANT.
Fact of the Case:
Plaintiff, son of defendant No.2, filed a suit for declaration that suit property was coparcenary and thus could not have been sold by defendant No.2 in favour of defendant No.1; it was further the contention of the minor son, aged around 3 months at that time that the suit property had been sold without there being any legal necessity. Decree for declaration was sought by him to the effect that sale-deed dated 18.10.2001 is illegal, inoperative, null and void and without there being any legal necessity; praying for further direction to defendant No.1 to hand-over the peaceful possession of the suit property to the plaintiff. In the alternative, it was asserted that plaintiff has right of redemption of the suit property and for this purpose he is ready and willing to pay the sale consideration of Rs.1 lac to defendant No.1 and he be declared as exclusive owner for sale consideration of Rs.1,00,000/-. Consequential decree, for permanent prohibitory injunction was also prayed for. Both learned Courts below have held against the plaintiff.
Finding of the Court:
The suit property had lost its status of coparcenary property on 05.06.1985, when mutation No.136 in respect of the property in question was attested in favour of Kamla Devi and defendant No.2 Suresh Kumar (wife and son of Mukti Nath @ Mohan Lal Sharma). This mutation remained as it was, without there being any challenge to it from any quarter, including Mukti Nath @ Mohan Lal Sharma. Therefore, it can safely be concluded that on the date of execution of agreement to sell, i.e. 09.03.1994, the suit property was not coparcenary. There was no embargo upon defendant No.2 Suresh Kumar to alienate and encumber the suit property in any manner. In any case, on the date of handing over the possession of suit property to defendant No.1, i.e. 14.10.2001, and on the date of execution of sale deed, i.e. on 18.10.2001, there was no embargo upon defendant No.2 to execute these documents in favour of defendant No.1.
Issues: Whether the suit property was a coparcenary property in the eyes of law and whether 1987 SC 558 and 2007 (2) SLC 56 were rightly applied by the Courts below? Whether the rejection of the application under Order 6 Rule 17 is proper and the order dated 24.07.2007 is sustainable in law in view of the grounds taken in the memo of appeal?
Ratio Decidendi: The coparcenary nature of suit property ceased to exist in 1984. Law laid down in Uttam's case (supra), becomes applicable to the property.
Final Decision: Appeal dismissed.
I.S. Chandel, Adv., Bhupender Gupta, Adv., Janesh Gupta, Adv.
JUDGMENT :
Jyotsna Rewal Dua, J.
Plaintiff being unsuccessful before learned Courts below in establishing that suit property was coparcenary and therefore, sale of same effected by his father (defendant No.2 Suresh Kumar) in favour of defendant No.1 was null and void, preferred present Regular Second Appeal.
2. This appeal was admitted on 26.11.2007, on the following substantial questions of law:-
"i).Whether the suit property was a coparcenary property in the eyes of law and whether 1987 SC 558 and 2007 (2) SLC 56 were rightly applied by the Courts below?
(ii). Whether the rejection of the application under Order 6 Rule 17 is proper and the order dated 24.07.2007 is sustainable in law in view of the grounds taken in the memo of appeal?"
I have heard Mr. I.S. Chandel, learned counsel for the appellant and Mr. Bhupender Gupta, learned senior counsel, for respondent No.1, and carefully gone through the record.
3. Question of Law No.1.
3(i). To answer this question of law, simplified facts spanning from the year 1954, alongwith discussion thereupon, are:-
Pedigree table of Bajira Mal is drawn hereinafter for sake of convenience:-
| Bajira Mal | ||
| Yog Raj (son) | Mukti Nath @ Mohan Lal Sharma (son) | Gian Chand (son) |
|
| Suresh Kumar (son) defendant no.2) (who sold land to defendant No.1) |
|
|
| Anmol (son) (Plaintiff) |
|
3(ii). Suit property, alongwith various other properties, was held by Bajira Mal, who constituted a Joint Hindu Family with his three sons. Bajira Mal died. Though his exact date of death is not available on record, however, mutation of inheritance after his death was entered on 31.12.1954 and attested on 24.04.1955 (Ext.P-20). Bajira Mal died before coming into force of Hindu Succession Act, 1956, therefore, succession in this case had opened before 1956. The succession, thus, had to be in accordance with old Hindu Law and not in accordance with Hindu Succession Act, 1956. The status of property in the hands of successors of Bajira Mal, i.e. his three sons Yog Raj, Mukti Nath @ Mohan Lal Sharma and Gian Chand, remained coparcenary.
3(iii). Jamabandies for the years 1956-57 (Ext.P-8), 1960-61 (Ext.P-9), 1964-65 (Ext.P-10), 1967-68 (Ext.P-11), 1972-73 (Ext.P-12), recorded the possession of three brothers over the property of their father late Bajira Mal.
3(iv). Mukti Nath @ Mohan Lal Sharma (grand father of plaintiff) was missing since January, 1966. This fact is recorded in the family partition (Ext.PW-2/1), effected between three brothers on 27.10.1972. The shares of three brothers were separated and suit property came to the share of Mukti Nath @ Mohan Lal Sharma (grand father of plaintiff), who was missing. Property was, therefore, actually possessed by his wife Kamla Devi and son Suresh Kumar (defendant No.2), aged about 8 years at that time.
3(v). Before going further into the facts, it is apt to notice the contention raised by Mr. Bhupender Gupta, learned senior counsel for respondent No.1 (purchaser of suit property), to the effect that after the family partition of property of Bajira Mal in 1972, the coparcenary nature of the property ceased to exist as the property was succeeded by three brothers in terms of Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956. Learned senior counsel, on this basis, further contended that the suit property, which in family partition came to Mukti Nath @ Mohan Lal Sharma, had thus lost the status of coparcenary property. Learned senior counsel for respondent No.1, relied upon , titled Uttam versus Saubhag Singh, (2016) 4 SCC 68 and , titled Commissioner of Wealth Tax, Kanpur and Others versus Chander Sen and Others, (1986) 3 SCC 567 , titled Bhanwar Singh versus Puran and Others, (2008) 3 SCC 87; titled Yudhishter versus Ashok Kumar, (1987) 1 SCC 204; & titled Ruli Ram (deceased) through L.R. and others versus Amar Singh, (1994) AIR H.P. 102 to contend that after the f