1996 Supreme(Ori) 133
High Court Of Orissa
D. M. PATNAIK
GITANJALI MISHRA - Appellant
Versus
GANGADHAR UPADHYAY - Respondent
First Appeal 194 Of 1983
Decided On : 09/02/1996
Important Points
Subject
Hindu Law - COPARCENARY PROPERTY - ALIENATION
Act Referred
Headnote
HINDU LAW - COPARCENARY PROPERTY - ALIENATION - VALIDITY - PROPERTY ACQUIRED BY FATHER BEFORE BIRTH OF SONS - SELF-ACQUIRED PROPERTY - TRANSFER VALID - PROPERTY ACQUIRED AFTER BIRTH OF SONS - COPARCENARY PROPERTY - TRANSFER VALID ONLY FOR LEGAL NECESSITY OR PROTECTION OF INTEREST OF MINORS - BURDEN OF PROOF ON ALIENEE.
Fact of the Case:
Plaintiffs, wife and children of defendant No. 7, filed a suit for confirmation of possession or delivery of vacant possession of the suit land. Defendant No. 7 had purchased the land in his own right and possessed it. Later, he entered into a partnership business and to protect the property from being attached by creditors, he executed a sham sale deed in favor of his father-in-law, defendant No. 1. After the death of his father, defendant No. 1 transferred a portion of the land to defendants 3 to 6.
Finding of the Court:
The lower court dismissed the suit, holding that the sale deed was valid and that the plaintiffs had no right, title, or interest in the suit land. On appeal, the High Court set aside the finding that plaintiff No. 1 was not competent to maintain the suit as the next friend of the minor plaintiffs and upheld the finding that the sale deed was valid.
Issues: 1. Whether plaintiff No. 1 was competent to maintain the suit as the next friend of the minor plaintiffs. 2. Whether the sale deed executed in favor of defendant No. 1's father was a valid one. 3. Whether the property in question was joint family property or the self-acquired property of defendant No. 7. 4. Whether the transfer of interest of the minors in the property was valid.
Ratio Decidendi: 1. The court held that plaintiff No. 1 was competent to maintain the suit as the next friend of the minor plaintiffs, as the father guardian had not taken up the cause of the minors whose interest in the property had been affected by the sale by defendant No. 7. 2. The court upheld the finding of the lower court that the sale deed was valid, as there was valid passing of consideration and the transaction could not be held to be a sham transaction. 3. The court held that the property in question was the self-acquired property of defendant No. 7, as he was the sole member of the family at the time of its acquisition and the plaintiffs were not yet born. 4. The court held that the transfer of interest of the minors in the property was invalid, as it was not for legal necessity or protection of the interest of the minors and the burden of proof was on the alienees to prove the existence of such legal necessity or otherwise.
Final Decision: The appeal was partly allowed. The plaintiffs' claim of title in respect of Ac. 0. 60 decimals of land was dismissed, and the case was remanded to the lower court for trial of the issue of whether the sale deed in respect of Ac. 0. 40 decimals of land was executed by defendant No. 7 for legal necessity and if so, whether it conveyed a valid title in favor of the transferees.
B.C.Maharana, B.Pal, BRAJA MOHAN PATNAIK, G.C.SVAIN, P.N.MOHAPATRA
D. M. PATNAIK, J.
( 1 ) THE plaintiffs are appellants before this Court. They challenge the judgment and the decree of the Subordinate Judge, Puri dismissing their suit for confirmation of possession or in the alternative for delivery of vacant possession and for other reliefs. The parties will be addressed as plaintiffs and defendants in this appeal as in the original suit for the sake of convenience. Plaintiff No. 1 is the wife of defendant No. 7 and plaintiffs 2 and 3 are their children.
( 2 ) PLAINTIFFS' case is, the suit land measures Ac. 1. 00, appertaining to Khata No. 275/29, Plot No. 696, situated in Ward No. 3 Holding No. 10 in Puri municipality. This originally belonged to the father of defendant No. 7 who had purchased and possessed the same in his own right, title and interest and after his death, defendant No. 7 possessed the same. Defendant No. 7 on his own entered into a partnership business with one Purna Chandra Mohapatra for manufacture of Homoeopathic drugs and to sustain the business, the partnership incurred loans from different sources. In order to protect the property from being attached at the instance of the creditors, Defendant No. 7 entered into a sham transaction with Rama Chandra Upadhyay, father of defendant No. 1 in respect of the suit properties and accordingly, a registered sale deed was executed on 15-1175 for a consideration of Rs. 35,000/- though in fact no consideration passed nor possession of the property delivered under the deed. After the death of his father, defendant No. 1 transferred a portion of the suit land in favour of defendants 3 to 6 and after knowing this, when the plaintiff's requested defendant No. 7, the latter did not take any step to save the property and deliberately avoided do so. When this conduct of defendant No. 7 went against the interest of the plaintiffs, they instituted the above suit for the reliefs already mentioned above.
( 3 ) DEFENDANT No. 1 and defendant Nos. 3 to 6 filed separate written statements. While denying the material facts pleaded in the plaint, they took pleas of low valuation of the suit, absence of cause of action, the suit being barred by limitation etc. So far as transaction in question is concerned, it was pleaded that there was passing of consideration. Hence consequently title passed in favour of the father of defendant No. 1 Delivery of possession also was given. It was further pleaded that after the transaction the defendant No. l's father possessed the same and this was evidenced by mutation of the land in question in his favour as well as payment of land revenue, taxes etc. by the defendants.
( 4 ) THE lower Court framed the following issues :1. Has the the plaintiffs any cause of action?2. Is the suit maintainable as framed?3. Have the plaintiffs locus standi to file the suit? Is plaintiff No. 1 competent to bring the suit representing the minor plaintiffs 2 and 3?4. Is this suit barred by limitation?5. Is the suit properly valued?6. Is the court-fee paid adequate?7. Whether the sale in favour of father of defendant No. 1 genuine or sham and whether title, interest, possession and the consideration money have passed under the sale deed?8. Have the plaintiffs right, title, interest and possession in respect of the suit land?9. Have the defendant Nos. 3 to 6 right, title, interest and possession over the suit land?10. To what relief, if any, the plaintiffs are entitled?
( 5 ) MR. Pal learned counsel for the appellants did not challenge the findings under the issues mentioned above except the findings of the lower court that plaintiff No. 1 was not competent to maintain the suit as the next friend; and the sale deed executed in favour of father of defendant No. 1 was a valid one. In addition, he submitted that defendant No. 7 was not competent to alienate interest of the plaintiffs 2 and 3 who as on the date of transfer i. e. 15-11-1975 were members of the family and the three constituted Hindu coparcenery and therefore, the sale wa