SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2018 Supreme(J&K) 212

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU AND KASHMIR AT SRINAGAR
M.K. Hanjura, J.
Mehraj-ud-din Wani – Petitioner
Vs.
JK State Coop. Bank Ltd. – Respondent
OWP No. 464 of 2012
Decided On : 14-05-2018

Important Points

The main legal point established in the judgment is the limited scope of interference under Article 227 and Section 104, emphasizing that it should not be used as a substitute for appellate or revisional jurisdiction. The court also highlighted the principles governing the exercise of power under Article 227 and Section 104, emphasizing that it should be sparingly exercised and not to upset findings of fact, which fall within the domain of an appellate court.

Subject

Property Law - Property Dispute

Act Referred

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : S.115, S.2
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA : Art.227, Art.227(2), Art.227(3), Art.226, Art.32
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE : S.100, S.435, S.439, S.96, S.100
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA ACT : S.224, S.107
HIGH COURTS ACT : S.15
JAMMU AND KASHMIR CONSTITUTION OF INDIA : S.104, S.104(2), S.96(a), S.96(b), S.96(c), S.96(d), S.96(e), S.96(f)

Headnote

JUDGMENT : petition - Property Dispute - Section 104 of the Jammu and Kashmir State Constitution - 104 - 227 - Summary of the acts and sections referenced and discussed by the court: The court discussed the provisions of Section 104 of the Jammu and Kashmir State Constitution, which is pari materia to Article 227 of the Constitution of India. The court emphasized the limited scope of interference under Article 227 and Section 104, highlighting that it should not be used as a substitute for appellate or revisional jurisdiction. The court also referred to various judicial pronouncements to establish the principles governing the exercise of power under Article 227 and Section 104, emphasizing that it should be sparingly exercised and not to upset findings of fact, which fall within the domain of an appellate court.

Fact of the Case:

The petitioner sought to set aside the judgment and orders passed by lower courts in a property dispute. The petitioner claimed possession of certain premises in a building for over 27 years, while the respondents alleged the petitioner to be a trespasser and claimed lawful occupation of the premises.

Finding of the Court:

The court held that the petition under Section 104 of the Jammu and Kashmir State Constitution was essentially an appeal in disguise and did not warrant interference. The court emphasized the limited scope of interference under Article 227 and Section 104, highlighting that it should not be used as a substitute for appellate or revisional jurisdiction. The court dismissed the petition, stating that the impugned orders did not warrant interference by exercise of extraordinary or supervisory jurisdiction.

Issues: The main issue was the petitioner's claim of possession of certain premises in a building against the respondents' allegation of trespass and lawful occupation.

Ratio Decidendi: The court emphasized the limited scope of interference under Article 227 and Section 104, highlighting that it should not be used as a substitute for appellate or revisional jurisdiction. The court also referred to various judicial pronouncements to establish the principles governing the exercise of power under Article 227 and Section 104, emphasizing that it should be sparingly exercised and not to upset findings of fact, which fall within the domain of an appellate court.

Final Decision: The court dismissed the petition, stating that the impugned orders did not warrant interference by exercise of extraordinary or supervisory jurisdiction. The court also vacated any interim direction.

Advocates Appeared:
For the Petitioner:Mr. G.A. Lone, Advocate.
For the Respondent:Mr. B.A Dar. Sr. AAG., Mr. Moomin Khan, Advocate.

JUDGMENT :

1. By the medium of this petition, filed under Section 104 of the Jammu and Kashmir State Constitution, the petitioner has sought the indulgence of this Court in setting aside the judgment dated 31.03.2012, passed by the learned Addl. District Judge, Srinagar, dismissing the appeal Nos. 15 & 16 of 2012 and the order dated 17.11.2011, passed by the Court of the learned First Addl. Munsiff, Srinagar, in case titled Zahoor Ahmad and Another v. Mehra-ud-Din and the order dated 29.11.2011, passed by the Court of the learned First Subordinate Civil Judge, Srinagar in case titled Mehraj-ud-Din v. Zahoor Ahmad and Others.

2. The facts culled out from the petition of the petitioner are that the petitioner is in possession of entire first and 2nd floors and a room, along with an open space measuring 2ft x 9.6ft in area located in the building situated at Amira Kadal, Lal Chowk, Srinagar. The parcels of the aforesaid building is in possession of the petitioner for more than 27 years.

3. It is further stated by the petitioner that the plaintiffs/respondent Nos. 3 & 4 filed a suit for permanent injunction in the Court of the learned Principal District Judge, Srinagar, to desist him from interfering with the shop on the front side of the same building in the ground floor having the carpet area of 839 sqft, which shop was claimed to have been obtained by them on lease from J&K Central Bank Ltd. Srinagar. The said suit came to be transferred by the Court of the learned Principal District Judge, Srinagar, to the Court of learned First Additional Munsiff, Srinagar, who passed an order of interim injunction in the suit against the petitioner. The plaintiffs/respondent Nos. 3 & 4 herein, on the basis of that injunction order, started interference into the room, the bathroom and the latrine block and in the open space which has been in the possession of the petitioner for more than two decades. The petitioner filed an application for vacation of the interim order passed in the suit in ex-parte on 07.06.2011 but the trial Court refused to vacate the same. The plaintiffs/respondent Nos. 3 & 4 herein have taken advantage of the order passed by the trial Court and demolished the wall, which separated the shop claimed to have been obtained on lease by them and the room which was in possession of the petitioner in the ground floor. Thus, the room was illegally annexed with the shop. The plaintiffs/respondents, it is further stated, also opened two doors of their shop towards the open space with a view to prefer a claim of user over the open space.

4. It is further stated that the petitioner filed two appeals against the order of the learned Addl. Munsiff, Srinagar and Sub Judge, Munsiff Magistrate, Srinagar, in the appellate Court. However, the appellate Court surpassed his jurisdiction while dismissing the appeals filed by the petitioner by holding that user of the plaintiffs/respondent Nos. 3 & 4 over the open space cannot be excluded.

5. In the objections, the plaintiffs/respondent Nos. 3 & 4 have resisted and controverted the petition of the petitioner on the grounds, inter alia, that the petitioner is a Rank Trespasser and has illegally occupied some rooms/space in the 1st and 2nd floor of the suit building. That being so, a trespasser cannot, in law, have a right to file a suit or writ against a true owner or any one claiming for and on his behalf. The petitioner is laying claim to have occupation of some space in the 1st and 2nd floor on the strength of some Deed of Declaration purported to have been executed in his favour by some President, State Central Labour Union, in the year 1986, which Deed is just a scratch of paper having no legal sanctity attached to it for multiple legal reasons including the one as to whether the President, State Central Labour Union was having any competence and power to draw the said document in any capacity, when he was not the owner of the building. Secondly, what is the locus of the petitioner in holding th

























































1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top