IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
PRADEEP KUMAR SRIVASTAVA, J.
Srimati Vinita Devi & Ors. - Petitioners
Versus
Sanjay Kumar & Ors. - Respondents
C.M.P. No. 438 of 2023
Decided On : 11-08-2023
Civil Procedure Code, 1908 – Order 6 rule 17 – Civil Miscellaneous Petition – Sale Deed – Amendment – Framing of issues – Stage of proceeding – Point for Determination – Held, Although, rejoinder to said application was filed by defendants subsequent to framing of issues and ultimately application was disposed off vide order – Therefore, it cannot be said that proposed amendment was sought after commencement of trial, so as to attract proviso attached to order 6 rule 17 of CPC – It is indispensable duty of trial courts to discuss and record objective findings with sound reasons, while dealing with an application under order VI Rule 17 of th3e Code of Civil Procedure – Twin test must always be kept in mind that amendment sought are necessary to effective and proper adjudication of lis between parties and does not cause irreparable injustice to other side – Object of amendment of pleadings is to protect rights of parties and not to punish for their mistakes in pleadings – It should be borne in mind that law of procedure is made to sub-serve cause of justice as a lubricant and not as a resistant in course of proceedings – Petition allowed.
JUDGMENT :
The instant civil miscellaneous petition has been preferred by petitioners/plaintiffs for quashing the impugned order dated 03.02.2023 passed in Title Suit No.64 of 2021 by Civil Judge (S.D.) VII, Hazaribagh, whereby and whereunder the application dated 17.11.2022(Annexure-4) filed under order 6 rule 17 of CPC on behalf of plaintiffs has been dismissed.
2. plaintiffs/petitioners have instituted Title Suit No.64 of 2021 claiming relief(s) for declaration of right, title interest over the suit property which the defendants forcibly occupied and illegally dispossessed the plaintiffs and also for recovery of possession coupled with injunction restraining the defendants from raising any construction over the suit land.
3. According to the plaintiffs, the suit property pertaining to Khata No.25, plot No.121 area 8 decimals of land situated in village Masirpirhi District Hazaribagh was purchased by plaintiff No.1 from one Smt. Sudama Sinha wife of Ramjatan Singh through registered sale deed dated 12.11.2018 for valuable consideration amount of Rs.8 lakhs(Rs. Eight lakhs).
4. It is alleged that the vendor of the plaintiffs Smt. Sudama Sinha has purchased the said land from one Smt. Rita Lal wife of Pramodh Bihari Lal vide registered Sale Deed No. 15336 dated 18.10.2000. After purchase of the said land, she got mutated the land and correction slip and rent receipt was also issued in her favour along with the land possession certificate issued by Circle Officer, Sadar Bazar Hazaribagh. It is averred that the defendants being men of muscles power forcibly, dispossessed the plaintiffs from the suit land by dividing it into two parts and northern part has been occupied by defendant No.2 and southern part by defendant No.1.
5. The defendant/respondent Nos.1 and 2 appeared in the suit and filed their respective written statement on 30.05.2022 denying claim of plaintiffs over the suit property. It is pleaded that the defendants have purchased 6 decimals of land out of total 8 decimals of land of suit scheduled property through registered Sale Deed No.1354/1319 dated 03.03.2016 and defendant No.2 claimed to have purchased 5 decimals of land forming part of plot No.121 from Smt. Pratima Singh vide registered Sale Deed No.1353/1318 dated 03.03.2016. The defendants have also denied the right, title interest of the vendors of plaintiffs.
6. In order to meet out the points raised in the written statement, the plaintiffs have filed application under order 6 rule 17 of CPC stating that due to inadvertence and over sight, they omitted to state the facts as to how their vendor Ritlan had acquired title and possession over the suit land and as such it become necessary to amend the plaint to clarify and explain by way of amendment to counter the facts raised in the written statement of defendants
Proposed amendment is as follows:-
A. That after para 11 of the plaint sub paras 11(a)(b) and (c) be added as follows:-
11(b) That Satyendra Prasad Sinha died leaving behind two sons namely Sunil Sinha and Sanjay Sinha and a daughter namely Sangita Devi, who came in joint possession upon the said 87 decimal of land besides other land left behind Satyendra Sinha. After death of Satyendra Sinha Sanjay Sinha being need of money for legal necessities of the joint family and with consent of his brother and sister, sold and transferred the said 87 decimal of land in favour of Pramodh Bihar Lal vide registered sale deed dated 14/6/88 for a valuable consideration and put him in possession upon the same. After death of Pramodh Bihar Lal his wife Rita Lal sold and transferred 8 decimal of land out of
Amendment of plaint – If amendment is necessary for deciding real controversy between parties and for arriving at a just conclusion, such amendment could be allowed even at a late stage.
Court ruled that procedural amendment requests should be allowed even after the trial begins, provided they clarify existing claims and do not introduce new issues.
Amendments to pleadings under Order VI Rule 17 of CPC can be permitted even post-delay if they facilitate effective adjudication and do not cause injustice to the opposing party.
The court emphasized the importance of bona fide amendments and a liberal approach to avoid multiplicity of litigations while considering applications for amendment under Order 6 Rule 17 of the CPC.
The Court may allow amendment of pleadings at any stage of the proceedings for just decision of the case and to determine the real questions in controversy between the parties.
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.