SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2009 Supreme(Mad) 516

High Court of Judicature at Madras
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE G. RAJASURIA
K. Chandran
Versus
Siriya Pushpam
C.R.P.(PD).No.862 of 2008 & M.P.No.1 of 2008
Decided on: 11-02-2009

Important Points

The main legal point established is that the court must record reasons for granting ex-parte injunction, as required by Order 39 Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

Subject

Civil Law - Injunctions

Act Referred

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : O.39 R.1, O.39 R.2

Headnote

Injunction - Civil Revision Petition - Order 39 Rule 3 - Summary of Acts and Sections: Order 39 Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure - The court emphasized the requirement to record reasons for granting ex-parte injunction and highlighted that absence of reasons in the order would prove fatal to the order itself.

Fact of the Case:

The plaintiff filed a suit seeking declaration of ownership and permanent injunction. The court granted ex-parte ad-interim injunction in a subsequent application, which the defendant challenged.

Finding of the Court:

The court found that the lower court's order lacked details and reasons for granting the injunction, which was in violation of Order 39 Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

Issues: The main issue was the validity of the ex-parte ad-interim injunction granted by the lower court in the subsequent application filed by the plaintiff.

Ratio Decidendi: The court emphasized the mandatory provision of Order 39 Rule 3, which requires the court to record reasons for granting injunction without notice to the opposite party. It highlighted that absence of reasons in the order would prove fatal to the order itself.

Final Decision: The Civil Revision Petition was allowed, and the order granting ex-parte ad-interim injunction was set aside.

Advocates Appeared:
For the Petitioner:M.L. Ramesh, Advocate.
For the Respondent: ----.

Judgment :-

Inveighing the order dated 23. 2005 passed in I.A.No.79 of 2005 in O.S.No.56 of 2005 by the Additional Subordinate Judge, Chenglepet, this civil revision petition is focussed.

2. Though the respondent was served and her name also is found printed in the cause list, nonetheless there is no representation for the respondent.

3. The long and short of the relevant facts, which are absolutely necessary and germane for the disposal of the civil revision petition, would run thus:-

The respondent, as plaintiff, filed the suit O.S.No.56 of 2006 before the Additional Subordinate Judge, Chengalpet, seeking the following reliefs:

"(a) to declare that the plaintiff is the absolute owner of the B Schedule mentioned property and to grant consequential relief.

(b) to grant permanent injunction restraining the defendant, his men and agents, servants and any person claiming through them from interfering into the peaceful possession and enjoyment of the B Schedule mentioned property by putting up any construction over the same."

While so, she also filed I.A.No.73 of 2005 seeking the following relief:

"to grant an ad-interim injunction restraining the defendant/respondent their men, agents, servants and persons claiming through them from interfering into the peaceful possession and enjoyment of the B schedule mentioned property by put up any construction thereon."

Whereupon the Court passed the following order:-

"Heard the counsel for petitioner. Affidavit with petition and connected records perused. Issue notice to the respondent. Call on 4. 2005."

After sensing that the Court had not granted ex-parte ad-interim injunction, the plaintiff has chosen to file one other application I.A.No.79 of 2005 with the following prayer:

"to pass an ad-interim injunction restraining the defendant, his men and agents servants and any person claiming through them from putting up any construction obstructing the path way of the B Schedule mentioned property by obstructing the passage for ingress and egress."

Whereupon the lower Court ignoring the earlier order of notice in the previous I.A.No.73 of 2005, on the very next day of having ordered notice in the previous I.A.No.73 of 2005, simply granted ex-parte ad-interim injunction as under:

"Hence ad-interim injunction is granted till 4. 2005. Issue notice to respondent. Order 39 Rule 3 to be complied with. Call on 4. 2005."

Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the said order, this civil revision petition is focussed by the defendant on various grounds.

4. The learned counsel for the revision petitioner, placing reliance on the grounds of revision, would develop his argument to the effect the lower Court was not justified in ordering ex-parte at-interim injunction in I.A.No.79 of 2005 after ordering notice in the earlier I.A.No.73 of 2005, which was for injunction relating to the same suit property; there is no reasoned order also; the Honourable Apex Court clearly pointed out that while ordering ex-parte injunction reasons should be found spelt out in the order, as otherwise the order would get vitiated; as such here the order dated 23. 2005 passed in I.A.No.79 of 2005 should be taken as non est in the eye of law.

5. Perused the records, including the order dated 23. 2005 passed in I.A.No.79 of 2005, as extracted supra:

6. The suit itself is for declaration and injunction. While so, on perusal of the records, including the affidavit accompanying the I.A.No.73 of 2005, the lower Court was pleased to order notice, without ordering ex-parte ad-interim injunction. However, quite antithetical to the view taken in I.A.No.73 of 2005, just on the next day itself, the lower Court had taken a diametrically opposite view while considering I.A.No.79 of 2005 filed by the very plaintiff and ordered exparte injunction restraining the defendant from raising construction.

7. No doubt, in the I.A.No.73 of 2005, the prayer as extracted supra is for bare injunction, so as to restrain the defendant from interfering













1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top