2016 Supreme(Mad) 4078
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
RMT. TEEKAA RAMAN, J.
Ponnusamy Nadar - Appellant
Versus
Rajammal - Respondent
S.A. No. 1217 of 1999
Decided On : 23-12-2016
Subject
Property Law - Land and Water Rights
Headnote
Permanent injunction - Sale Deed - Plaint proceeds on the basis that the plaintiff has purchased the right in the suit Well under Sale Deed, and she is irrigating her land by drawing water from the suit Well - As the defendant interfered and tried to draw water from the suit Well for his land, she filed the suit - Held, Findings of the Lower Appellate Court are well considered and well founded and the same do not suffer from any infirmity or illegality and the same are sustainable in law - Accordingly, the substantial question of law No.2 is held against the appellant/defendant and answered in favour of the respondent/plaintiff - Second appeal dismissed
For the Appellant :Mr. T.R. Rajaraman, Advocate
For the Respondent:Mr. T.S.R. Venkataramana, Advocate
Mr. Rmt. Teekaa Raman, J.
1. The defeated defendant is the appellant herein.
2. For the sake of convenience, the parties are referred to as per the ranking before the Trial Court.
3. The plaintiff filed the suit in O.S. No.133 of 1988, before the learned District Munsif, Tenkasi, for the relief of declaration over Item No.I of the suit property i.e., suit Well and for permanent injunction restraining the defendant from drawing water from the suit Well for irrigation of his land in Item No.II of the suit property.
4. The plaint proceeds on the basis that the plaintiff has purchased the right in the suit Well under Ex.A1 Sale Deed, dated 03.03.1987 and she is irrigating her land by drawing water from the suit Well. As the defendant interfered and tried to draw water from the suit Well for his land, she filed the suit.
5. The defendant filed a written statement denying the averments of the plaintiff inter-alia contended that from the common vendor, both of them had purchased the land and therefore, prayed for dismissal of the suit.
6. After contest, the suit O.S.No.133 of 1988, was dismissed by the Trial Court, vide Judgment and Decree, dated 24.01.1995.
7. Aggrieved against the Judgment and Decree, dated 24.01.1995, made in O.S.No.133 of 1988, the plaintiff preferred an appeal, in A.S.No.14 of 1995, before the learned Subordinate Judge, Tenkasi, and before the Lower Appellate Court, she had filed an interlocutory application to receive additional evidence at the appellate stage.
8. By Judgment and Decree, dated 19.09.1996, the appeal preferred by the plaintiff was allowed by the Lower Appellate Court.
9. Aggrieved against the Judgment and Decree, dated 19.09.1996, made in A.S.No.14 of 1995, the defendant has filed the present second appeal.
10. The brief averments of the plaint that are necessary to decide this appeal are as follows:
The plaintiff is in the possession and enjoyment of Item No.I of the suit property having purchased the same from one Annavi Kasilinga Nadar, by a Sale Deed, dated 04.02.1987, and the defendant has no right or title whatsoever in respect of the Item No.1 of the suit property. After the purchase of Item No.I of suit property, the defendant had purchased Item No. II of the suit property from the said Annavi Kasilinga Nadar in a fraudulent manner. Item No.II of the suit property is a heap and in the higher level other than the land level and for the same, there is no irrigation of water right from the suit Well. Neither the said Annavi Kasilinga Nadar nor his predecessor-in-title had never any irrigating right for the Item No. II of the suit property. While so, the common vendor Annavi Kasilinga Nadar has no right to convey right of irrigation from the suit Well to the Item No. II of the suit property. If any Sale Deed is executed, the same would not bind upon the plaintiff. The defendant had issued a legal notice, on 03.02.1988, to the plaintiff's husband and thereupon tried to interfere with the drawing of water to the suit property and the defendant had also scandalously levelled the ground to suit to the water course. Hence, the suit. At the time of filing the suit, the survey number of the land was wrongly mentioned. However, in the report filed by the Advocate Commissioner, the plaintiff's possession and enjoyment of the suit property has been clearly demarcated and identified. The survey number mentioned in the Sale Deed executed in favour of the defendant is also not proper and accordingly, only after the Advocate Commissioner's report, the defendant came to know about the correct survey number.
11. The brief averments of the written statement that are necessary to decide this appeal are as follows:
All the averments made in the plaint are denied and the suit schedule is not in accordance with the report of the Advocate Commissioner. Both the survey number and the boundaries of the suit property are not correct. The plaintiff having purchased some other properties in his name inviting the defendan