SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2018 Supreme(Mad) 2446

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
T. RAVINDRAN, J.
Padmavathi Ammal - Appellant
Versus
Natarajan - Respondents
S.A.No.2096 of 2004
Decided on : 25-07-2018

Act Referred

HINDU SUCCESSION ACT : S.8, S.4, S.19, S.30

Headnote

ancestral property - Property Rights - [Hindu Succession Act 1956, Section 8, Section 4, Section 19, Section 30] - The court discussed the character of the suit properties as ancestral or separate properties of the first defendant. It referenced various legal provisions and interpretations from the Hindu Succession Act 1956 to establish that the properties derived by the first defendant from his father could only be treated as his separate properties and not as the joint family properties of the first defendant and his son. The court also highlighted the effect of Sections 4, 8, 19, and 30 of the Hindu Succession Act 1956 in determining the nature of the suit properties.

Fact of the Case:

The plaintiff laid the suit against the defendants for declaration and permanent injunction, claiming entitlement to the suit properties based on a settlement deed. The defendants contested, arguing that the suit properties were ancestral and challenging the validity of the settlement deed.

Finding of the Court:

The court found that the suit properties were the separate properties of the first defendant, and the settlement deed in favor of the plaintiff was valid. It held that the plaintiff had title to the suit properties as per the settlement deed.

Issues: The main issue was the character of the suit properties as ancestral or separate properties, and the validity of the settlement deed executed by the first defendant in favor of the plaintiff.

Ratio Decidendi: The court relied on the provisions of the Hindu Succession Act 1956, particularly Section 8, and various legal precedents to establish that the suit properties were the separate properties of the first defendant, supporting the validity of the settlement deed.

Final Decision: The Judgment and Decree dated 25.03.2004 were set aside, and the Judgment and Decree dated 07.12.2001 were confirmed. The second appeal was allowed with costs.

Advocates:
Advocate Appeared:
For the Appellant : Mrs.N.Mala
For the Respondent: Mrs.Chitra Sampath Senior Counsel for Mr.R.Sunilumar

JUDGMENT :

1. Challenge in this second appeal is made to the Judgment and Decree dated 25.03.2004 passed in A.S.No.11 of 2004 on the file of the Additional District Judge (Fast Track Court No.I), Tindivanam, reversing the Judgment and Decree dated 07.12.2001 passed in O.S.No.185 of 1997 on the file of the Additional District Munsif Court, Tindivanam.

2. The second appeal has been admitted on the following substantial questions of law:

“(i). Whether the lower appellate Court is right in law in thinking that the suit property partakes the character of ancestral property in the absence of specific proof? And

(ii). Whether the lower appellate Court is right in law in considering the recitals in Ex.B2 the partition deed for deciding about the character of the suit properties?”

3. Considering the scope of the issues between the parties as regards the subject matter lying in a narrow compass, it is unnecessary to dwell into the facts of the case in detail.

4. The plaintiff /appellant has laid the suit against the defendants for declaration and permanent injunction.

5. In brief, according to the plaintiff, she is the second wife of the first defendant and the first defendant, at the request of the plaintiff's parents, in consideration of the marriage and in order to provide security to the plaintiff, had executed the settlement deed in favour of the plaintiff on 17.10.1958 in respect of the suit properties and accordingly, it is stated that the plaintiff had married the first defendant and been in the possession and enjoyment of the suit properties and thus, it is stated that as per the terms of the abovesaid settlement deed, the plaintiff is entitled to enjoy the properties comprised in the settlement deed and after the demise of the plaintiff, the property should be enjoyed by the legal heirs born to the plaintiff and the first defendant and contending that the defendants 4 to 7 are the children of the plaintiff and it is only the defendants 4 to 7, who have the vested reminder in respect of the suit properties and on the other hand, the defendants 2 and 3, the children born to the first defendant through his first wife, according to the plaintiff, they had, with a view to deprive the plaintiff's title and interest in respect of the suit properties, had instituted the suit in O.S.No.716 of 1981 seeking partition and they have not impleaded the plaintiff in the said suit and seem to have obtained the decree in the said suit and thereby, attempting to interfere with the plaintiff's possession and enjoyment of the suit properties and accordingly, it is the case of the plaintiff that she had been necessitated to lay the suit for appropriate reliefs.

6. The defendants 2 & 3, who are the main contestants, had resisted the plaintiff's suit contending that the suit properties are not the separate properties of the first defendant and according to them, the suit properties had been acquired by Kangadhara Mudaliar, the father of the first defendant out of his earnings and the same had been enjoyed as the joint family properties by the first defendant and his brother, Srinivasa Mudaliar and by way of the partition effected in 1956, the suit properties had come to be allotted to the first defendant and thus, it is contended by the defendants 1 & 2 that inasmuch as the suit properties partake the character of the ancestral properties, the first defendant would not be competent to execute the settlement deed in respect of the suit properties in favour of the plaintiff and the said settlement deed has not come into force and by virtue of the settlement deed, the plaintiff had not been in the possession and enjoyment of the suit properties and accordingly, contending that the present suit has been laid only to stall the execution of the decree obtained by the defendants in the partition suit in O.S.No.716 of 1981 and accordingly, sought for the dismissal of the plaintiff's suit.

7. The relationship between the parties is not in dispute.

8. It is found that t















1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top