2026 Supreme(Ori) 558
ORISSA HIGH COURT : CUTTACK
Ananda Chandra Behera, J.
Bhagabati Tarai - Petitioner
Versus
Kalpana Tarai - Opposite Party
CMP No.1273 of 2022
Decided On : 22-01-2026
Important Points
Subject
Civil Law - Property Disputes
Act Referred
CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : O.39 R.1, O.39 R.2, O.43 R.1(r), S.151
Headnote
(B) Principal of prior sale - A prior sale prevails over a subsequent sale even if confirmation of the prior sale occurs after the subsequent sale. (Para 11)
Facts of the case:
The plaintiff filed a suit against the petitioner for rights over certain properties, claiming exclusive possession based on a prior sale. The petitioner challenged the plaintiff's claims, asserting superiority of a later sale deed.
Findings of Court:
The High Court upheld the decisions of the lower courts, which favored the plaintiff based on their claim of prior sale.
Issues: Whether the findings of the lower courts warrant interference under Article 227 of the Constitution.
Ratio Decidendi: The court determined that the prior sale deed held precedence over subsequent transactions and that the findings of lower courts did not reveal errors warranting judicial interference.
Result: CMP dismissed.
For the Petitioner:Mr. S.K. Dash, Senior Advocate Along with Ms. P. Mohanty, Advocate
For the Opposite Party :Mr. S. Mohanty, Advocate
| Table of Content |
|---|
| 1. petition filed under article 227 challenging previous orders. (Para 1 , 2 , 3) |
| 2. defendant's objections to temporary injunction. (Para 4) |
| 3. court's analysis of prior versus subsequent sale deeds. (Para 5 , 10 , 12) |
| 4. interference under article 227 only for clear errors. (Para 9 , 11) |
| 5. cmp dismissed; suit to be expedited. (Para 13 , 14 , 15 , 16) |
JUDGMENT :
ANANDA CHANDRA BEHERA, J.
1. This Civil Misc. Petition under article 227 of the Constitution of India, 1950 has been filed by the petitioner praying for quashing the impugned order dated 20.07.2022 (Annexure-4) passed in I.A. No.66/2022 by the learned Senior Civil Judge, Kujanga and the impugned order dated 31.10.2022 (Annexure-5) passed in F.A.O. No.25 of 2022 by the learned Addl. District Judge, Kujanga.
2. The factual backgrounds of this Civil Misc. Petition, which promoted the petitioner for filing of the same is that, the Opp. Party (Kalpana Tarai) being the sole plaintiff filed a suit vide C.S. No.84/2022 against the petitioner of this CMP (Bhagabati Tarai) arraying her as defendant No.1 along with others in the Court of learned Senior Civil Judge, Kujanga praying for declaration of her right, title, interest and possession over the properties described in Schedule “C” of the plaint and also to declare the R.S.D. No.733 dated 22.04.2006 executed by the defendant No.2 Srikrushna Das in favour of the defendant No.1 (petitioner in this CMP Bhagabati Tarai) as illegal, invalid, void and the same is not binding upon her and to injunct the defendant No.1 (petitioner in this CMP) permanently from interfering in the peaceful possession of the plaintiff over “C” schedule suit properties stating in her plaint in nutshell that, the suit properties along with other properties originally belonged to one Satish Chandra Das. After the death of Satish Chandra Das, the suit properties along with other properties left by him devolved upon his widow wife and his children including her vendor Subhadra Das. After the death of Satish Chandra Das, his all successors including her vendor Subhadra Das partitioned to their all joint properties including the suit properties and in such partition, the suit properties described in Schedule “C” along with some other properties fell in the share of Subhadra Das and accordingly, Subhadra Das became the exclusive owner over the suit properties. The said Subhadra Das (defendant No.5 in the suit vide C.S. No.84/2022) sold her schedule “C” suit properties in her favour i.e. in favour of the plaintiff executing and registering Sale Deed No.731 dated 14.03.2001 after receiving the due consideration amount and delivered possession thereof. As such, since the date of purchase i.e. since 14.03.2001, she (plaintiff) is in exclusive possession over the Schedule “C” suit properties. When the defendant No.1 created disturbances in her possession over the suit properties and claimed claiming her title thereon, then, she (plaintiff-Kalpana Tarai) filed the suit vide C.S. No.84/2022 against the petitioner in this CMP arraying her as defendant No.1 along with others including her vendor Subhadra Das praying for the aforesaid reliefs i.e. declaration and permanent injunction.
3. In the said suit vide C.S. No.84/2022, the plaintiff (Opp. Party in this CMP) filed an I.A. vide I.A. No.66/2022 under Order 39, Rule 1 & 2 read with Section 151 CPC, 1908 against the defendant No.1 (petitioner in this CMP) praying for injuncting her temporarily from coming upon the suit land and from interfering in her peaceful possession and from causing any damage to the standing vegetable crops and from making any type of construction over the same and from changing the nature and character of the same till the final disposal of the suit vide C.S. No.84/2022 stating the above things.
4. Having been noticed from the Court in I.A. No.66/2022, the defendant No.1 thereof (petitioner in this CMP) challenged the same by filing her objection taking her stands that, the suit properti