2019 Supreme(All) 778
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ALLAHABAD
J.J. MUNIR, J.
Munni Lal and Others - Appellant
Versus
Board of Revenue and Others - Respondent
Writ B No. 502 of 1994
Decided On : 17-07-2019
Subject
Substitution of Legal Representatives - Multiple Rival Claims
Act Referred
UTTAR PRADESH ZAMINDARI ABOLITION AND LAND REFORMS ACT : S.209, S.210, S.229(b)
Headnote
Uttar Pradesh Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act – Section 229B and Section 209 – Civil Procedure Code, 1908 – Order XXIII – Rule 3B and 5 – Petition challenging order passed by Board of Revenue in Second Appeal whereby Board ordered that upon death of respondent no.1 to appeal, his daughters substituted in his place, and by same order one respondent no.6 to this petition also permitted to substituted in place of deceased – Whether it is open to Court where more claims than one are set up for substitution in place of deceased party, to permit multiple parties with rival claims or interest to substituted in place of original plaintiff/ respondent/ appellant, or Court obliged to adjudicate issue under Order XXII Rule 5 CPC, and decide in favour of one of them – Held, Two substitution applications of two sets of legal representatives, each claiming in them right to represent estate of deceased defendant, in pending appeal before Board was in question – One of them was a grandson, claiming through a pre-deceased daughter, who propounded a will, whereas other set of claim was from daughters of deceased defendant, who claimed on the basis of intestacy – Board of Revenue by casual order and without least consideration or adherence to provisions of Order XXII Rule 5 CPC, proceeded to allow both sets of applications, and substituted both sets of legal representatives without deciding question at all – Matter remitted to Trial Court for undertaking inquiry limited to purpose of deciding pending applications for substitution as to who was entitled to represent estate of deceased – Order surreptitiously made substitution applications filed by both sets of persons claiming to be legal representatives of deceased defendant allowed this course of action is patently illegal and impugned order passed by Board of Revenue not sustained – Petition allowed – (Paras: 17 to19)
Facts of the case:
Petition challenging order passed by Board of Revenue in Second Appeal whereby Board ordered that upon death of respondent no.1 to appeal, his daughters substituted in his place, and by same order one respondent no.6 to this petition also permitted to substituted in place of deceased – Whether it is open to Court where more claims than one are set up for substitution in place of deceased party, to permit multiple parties with rival claims or interest to substituted in place of original plaintiff/ respondent/ appellant, or Court obliged to adjudicate issue under Order XXII Rule 5 CPC, and decide in favour of one of them.
Findings of the court:
Two substitution applications of two sets of legal representatives, each claiming in them right to represent estate of deceased defendant, in pending appeal before Board was in question – One of them was a grandson, claiming through a pre-deceased daughter, who propounded a will, whereas other set of claim was from daughters of deceased defendant, who claimed on the basis of intestacy – Board of Revenue by casual order and without least consideration or adherence to provisions of Order XXII Rule 5 CPC, proceeded to allow both sets of applications, and substituted both sets of legal representatives without deciding question at all – Matter remitted to Trial Court for undertaking inquiry limited to purpose of deciding pending applications for substitution as to who was entitled to represent estate of deceased – Order surreptitiously made substitution applications filed by both sets of persons claiming to be legal representatives of deceased defendant allowed this course of action is patently illegal and impugned order passed by Board of Revenue not sustained.
Result: Petition allowed
Advocate Appeared:
Triveni Shanker, Adv.
JUDGMENT :
J.J. MUNIR, J.
1. Heard Awadhesh Kumar, learned Advocate holding brief of Sri Triveni Shankar, learned counsel for the petitioners, Sri Rajesh Kumar, learned Standing Counsel appearing on behalf of respondent nos.1 & 2. No one appears for respondent no.3, Gaon Sabha or respondent nos.4, 5 & 6.
2. This writ petition has been filed challenging an order dated 14.12.1993 passed by the Board of Revenue, U.P. at Allahabad in Second Appeal no.44/1976-77, whereby the Board have ordered that upon death of Raja Ram (respondent no.1 to the appeal), his daughters, Smt. Parbatia and Smt. Phulbatia, be substituted in his place, and by the same order one Kariman (respondent no.6 to this petition) has also been permitted to be substituted in place of deceased Raja Ram, in the second appeal aforesaid. Kariman has been permitted to be substituted on the basis of the last will and testament said to have been executed by Raja Ram in favour of Kariman.
3. The question that arises for consideration in this petition is: Whether it is open to a Court where more claims than one are set up for substitution in place of a deceased party, to permit multiple parties with rival claims or interest to be substituted in place of the original plaintiff/ respondent/ appellant, or the Court is obliged to adjudicate the issue under Order XXII Rule 5 CPC, and decide in favour of one of them?
4. The second appeal before the Board arises from a suit under Section 229B and Section 209 of the Uttar Pradesh Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act (for short ''the Act') relating to certain lands situated in Village Nigai, Pargana Agori, Tehsil Robertsganj, District Mirzapur (now district Sonebhadra). The property subject matter of the suit comprises plot nos.1642/0-15-0, 1647/2-4-0, 1648/1-13-0, 1649/5-14-0, 1657/2-0-0, 1658/0-5-0, 1641/2040/3-19-0, totalling seven gata numbers, area 16-10-0. The said property is hereinafter referred to as the ''suit property'. The petitioners are the plaintiffs in the suit, that was instituted by their father against defendants, Raja Ram, the State of U.P. and the Gaon Sabha, seeking a declaration that the suit property wherein name of defendant no.1 to the suit, Raja Ram has been recorded by mistake, be expunged and the first defendant be dispossessed from the suit property by a decree of ejectment.
5. It is the plaint case that the original plaintiff, Ramkesh, father of the petitioners, was sirdar in possession of the suit property. Ramkesh had two brothers, Ram Lakhan and Ram Bilas, both of whom died issueless. As such, Ramkesh was the sole heir, entitled to succeed to the estate of his deceased brothers, Ram Lakhan and Ram Bilas. It is further averred in the plaint that the name of defendant no.1 to the suit, Raja Ram, was wrongly recorded over the suit property. It was also averred in the plaint that at a time when the plaintiff was minor, he gave the suit property to defendant no.1 on a crop sharing basis to cultivate. Thereafter, defendant no.1 withdrew his possession, which was handed over to the plaintiff. The first defendant had no concern with the suit property. Somehow, the Lekhpal illegally got his name recorded in the remarks column, compelling the plaintiff to file the suit.
6. The suit was contested by Raja Ram, the defendant, who is the sixth respondent to this petition, by filing a written statement. He denied the plaint allegations and asserted that he is in possession over the suit property since before the date of vesting. He urged that his right matured, and he had acquired title under Section 210 of the Act. It was also argued that the plaintiff's case of settlement of the suit property on a crop sharing basis was incorrect. The suit was time barred. The plaintiff was not sirdar or in possession of the suit property. It was also pleaded that during record operations, it was defendant no.1, Raja Ram, who was found in possession. The Trial Court dismissed the suit by its judgment and decree of 21st December, 19