JUDGMENT :

(Subhash Vidyarthi J.)

1. Heard Sri Sandeep Dixit, the learned Senior Advocate assisted by Sri Varadraj Shreedutt Ojha Advocate, the learned counsel for the petitioner and Sri Gaurav Mehrotra Advocate assisted by Sri Utsav Misra and Ms. Rani Singh Advocates for the opposite party no. 2 High Court of Judicature at Allahabad.

2. By means of the present Writ Petition, the petitioner has challenged the order dated 02.04.2019 whereby he has been removed from the post of Civil Judge (Junior Division). He has also challenged the annual confidential report for the year 2011-12, the order dated 29.01.2013 passed by the Administrative Judge rejecting the petitioner’s representation against the adverse remarks in his annual confidential report for the year 2011-12 whereby it was proposed that a departmental enquiry be conducted against the petitioner and the recommendations dated 07.12.2016 of a Committee of three Hon’ble Judges of this Court rejecting the petitioner’s representation dated 05.11.2015 against the adverse remarks, as also the resolutions dated 11.01.2017 passed by the Hon’ble Administrative Committee accepting the recommendations of the three member committee and the resolution dated 12.11.2017 passed by the Hon’ble Administrative Committee directing the matter to be placed before the Full Court.

3. Briefly stated, facts of the case are that the petitioner was appointed as a Civil Judge (Junior Division) on 26.05.2006. The petitioner remained posted as Additional Civil Judge (Junior Division) in the outlying Court at Sambhal in District Moradabad and thereafter he was transferred to Mirzapur.

4. On 25.11.2011, while the petitioner was posted as Civil Judge (Junior Division) Sambhal, one Sri. Mahesh Pal Singh Yadav Advocate gave a complaint to the District Judge Moradabad, leveling the following allegations against the petitioner: -

^^ekuuh; tuin U;k;k/kh'k egksn;]

tuin& eqjknkcknA

fo"k; %& U;kf;d vf/kdkjh lEHky Jh jktsUnz izlkn Hkkjrh th dh nks"kiw.kZ dk;Zizk.kh ds lEcU/k esa &

egksn;]

lfou; fuosnu gS fd U;kf;d vf/kdkjh Jh jktsUnz izlkn Hkkjrh egksn; dh dk;Z iz.kkyh ds lEcU/k esa fuEufyf[kr fuosnu djuk gS &

1& ;g fd Jh jktsUnz izlkn Hkkjrh U;kf;d vf/kdkjh egksn; U;k;ky; esa izfrfnu nks cts fnu cSBrs gS vkSj dsoy vtsZUV ekeys tSls& csy fjekaM o nkos dks tks mlh fnu nk;j gksrs gS] ij gh lquokbZ gksrh gS vkSj dksbZ Qkby ij u rks dksbZ lquokbZ gksrh gS] uk gh dksbZ vkns'k gksrk gSA

2& ;g fd mDr lHkh vtekurh; o xEHkhj izd`fr ds vijk/kks esa mDr egksn; lacf/kr i{k ls gelkt gksdj mlh fnu tekur dk vkns'k ns nrs gSA feyus ij [kkfjt dj nsrs gSA

3& ;g fd mDr vf/kdkjh egksn; u;s nkoks esa /kujkf'k ysdj gh LFkxukns'k nsrs gS vU;Fkk flQZ uksfVl gh tkjh djrs gSA

4& ;g fd 156¼3½ lh0vkj0ih0lh0 ds izk0i= dks Lohdkj djus gsrq 2000@& :i;s u nsus ij [kkfjt dj nsrs gSA ,sls gh dksVZ u01 esa ihBklhu jgrs gq;s mDr vf/kdkjh egksn; us izdh.kZ okn la0 58@11 jkefd'kksj cuke jkefuokl izkFkhZ }kjk iSls uk nsus ij izk0i= 15-4-11 dks [kkfjt dj fn;k okngw oknh }kjk mDr vf/kdkjh dh vuqfpr ekax iwjh djus ij mldh QnsZgdke fudky dj nwljh QnsZgdke yxkdj izk0 i= mlh fnu 15-4-11 dks Lohdkj dj fn;k x;kA izek.k Lo:i Nk;kizfr layXu gSA

5& ;g fd mDr Jh jktsUnz izlkn Hkkjrh }kjk U;k;ky; ds lHkh U;kf;d O;oLFkk [kjkc dj jgh gSA dksbZ Hkh dk;Z cxSj iSls fy;s mDr vf/kdkjh egksn; ugh dj jgs gSA okndkfj;ks dk mDr dk;Ziz.kkyh ls fo’okl lekIr gksrk tk jgk gSA mDr vf/kdkjh egksn; dh dk;Ziz.kkyh ls okndkfj;ks dk vfgr gks jgk gSA vkSj U;k;ky; dh xfjek /kwfey gks jgh gS vkSj bZekunkj okndkjh U;k; ls oafpr gks jgs gSA

6& ;g fd Jh jktsUnz izlkn Hkkjrh egksn; tc ls lEHky ls LFkkukUrfjr vk;s gS] Hkz"Vkpkj dks cढ+kok fn;k gSA buds dk;Zdky dks fdlh Hkh ekg dh QkStnkjh fjek.M i=koyh Fkkuk& g;kruxj o lEHky xढ+h dks ryc dj yh tk; rFkk u;s nhokuh oknh okn Hkh ryc dj fy;s tk;A Jheku th ds le{k mDr lHkh rF;ksa dh lPpkbZ lkeus tk;sxhA

U;k;ky; dh lkQ lqFkjh o xfjek cuk;s j[kus ds fy;s vki ls djc) izkFkZuk gS fd mDr Jh jktsUnz izlkn Hkkjrh U;kf;d vf/kdkjh egksn; lEHky nks"kiw.kZ dk;kZs dh tkap