1927 Supreme(All) 285
ALLAHABAD HIGH COURT
ASHWORTH, MUKERJI, JJ.
Lachman Das & Anr. - Appellants
Versus
Ram Prasad & Ors. - Respondents
Decided On : 28-02-1927
JUDGMENT
Mukerji, J. - This is an appeal by two defendants in a mortgage suit, brought by the Respondent No. 1 under the following circumstances. Three persons, viz., Ram Prasad son of Dhuma Mal, his wife Mt. Barfi Kunwar and the appellant Lachman Das executed the bond in suit for a consideration of Rs. 5,200 in favour of the respondent Ram Prasad son of Gulzari Lal. The plaintiff sought to enforce the mortgage and made parties to it not only the mortgagors but also the transferees from them and one Radhe Shiam, a minor son of Ram Prasad son of Dhuma Mal and his wife Mt. Barfi.
2. The defence of Lachman Das was threefold, so far as we are concerned in this appeal. He said that the mortgage was not properly registered and was therefore, not enforceable, that he received no consideration for the mortgage and that he executed it under an undue influence. He further added that he had no interest in the property at the date of the mortgage and, therefore, the mortgage was not enforceable against the property mortgaged. The Appellant No. 2, Mt. Nanhi, appears to be a transferee from Mt. Barfi and her appeal before us repeats the same arguments which we shall presently notice, on behalf of Lachman Das.
3. It appears that one Kalyan Chand was the owner of a considerable amount of cash and moveable property. He made a Will in 1907 in favour of his wife Mt. Champa Kunwar and his daughter's son Lachman Das. He gave by this document a life-interest to Mt. Champa Kunwar and the remainder to Lachman Das. Kalyan Chand and Mt. Champa Kunwar had a daughter Mt. Barfi besides Mt. Kotori, the mother of Lachman Das. Mt. Kotori predeceased her father. Mt. Barfi married Ram Prasad and this Ram Prasad is one of the mortgagors along with Mt. Barfi. By an agreement of 1910 entered into, a date when Lachman Das was still a minor, Mt. Champa Kunwar, Lachman Das and Mt. Barfi agreed that the property in question should go to Mt. Barfi and Lachman Das and Mt. Champa Kunwar should each receive an annuity. We need not consider this agreement as I have already stated it is not binding on Lachman Das. I may add that the property mortgaged was purchased by Mt. Champa Kunwar with the money she received from her husband under the Will and that, therefore, this property partakes of the same character as the cash and moveables bequeathed by Kalyan Chand. The learned Subordinate Judge decreed the suit and we have to consider the several points raised in appeal.
4. The first point urged is that the mortgage is invalid on the ground that its registration is invalid. It appears that Mt. Champa Kunwar purchased by a deed a certain kothri or room belonging to one Radhe Lal. In executing the mortgage-deed in favour of the Respondent No. 1 this kothri or room was included as a property mortgaged. The room is situated in Bareilly, while the mortgaged property, which is a certain entire village of Launda Baheri is situated in the District of Budaun. The argument for the appellants is that the room at Bareilly was purchased with the sole object of including it in the agreement of 1910 and the object was to give jurisdiction to the Sub-Registrar of Bareilly to register the deed. It being granted that the owner Radhe Lal transferred it by a registered deed in favour of Mt. Champa Kunwar, the title to the room did pass to Mt. Champa Kunwar, notwithstanding anything that might have been in the mind of Radhe Lal as to the passing of title. The property in the eye of law belonged to Mt. Champa Kunwar and, therefore, Lachman Das bad the same interest in the property as he had in the cash and moveables bequeathed by his grandfather. Assuming, therefore, that Lachman Das had a title to the village of Launda Baheri he had also a title to the room mortgaged. It follows that the Sub-Registrar of Bareilly had jurisdiction to register the deed. In the case of Mathura Prosad v. Chandra Narayan Chowdhury AIR 1921 PC 8 the property described did exist but the mortgagor had no interest in the prop