S.K. Gangele, J.;—

1. The appellant has filed this appeal against the order dt. 12.11.2009 passed by the learned Single Judge in W.P. No. 2320/2004 (S). By the aforesaid order, learned Single Judge dismissed the writ petition filed by the appellant/petitioner. A charge sheet was served on the appellant vide memo of charge dt. 13.12.1982. Two charges were levelled against him. Charge No. 1 was that he was posted from 20.6.1975 to 30.5.1980 as Industries Extension Officer at Gwalior and during that period he had made recommendation for issuance of registration certificate to M/s. Gangaram Nemichand, Jinsi Nala No. 2, Gwalior. The second charge was that the appellant submitted false information in regard to existence of the unit and due to the aforesaid act, the raw material iron and steel had been supplied to the firm and same was sold in black market. An enquiry was conducted and after enquiry the order of punishment of compulsory retirement was passed on 23.9.1993 against the appellant. He challenged the order of punishment before the State Administrative Tribunal.

2. The Tribunal vide order dt. 20.11.1997 quashed the order of punishment on the ground that no second show cau