SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Judicial Analysis Court Copy Headnote Facts Arguments Court observation
Listen Audio Icon Pause Audio Icon
judgment-img

2022 Supreme(MP) 410

(STATE COOPERATIVE TRIBUNAL)
Shri Chandresh Kumar Khare, Chairman and Shri Arun Mathur, Member
Pragati Grah Nirman Sahkari Sansthan Maryadit, Bhopal v. Smt. Kamla Agnihotry
First Appeal No. 193/2018; against the order dated 6.6.2003 passed by the Deputy Registrar, Cooperative Societies, Bhopal in case No. 64-96/2001; Decided on 1.11.2022.

Advocates:
D.K. Saxena for appellant; Sanjay Vajpai for respondent.

Headnote:

¼1½ lgdkjh l¨lkbVh vfèkfu;e] 1960 ¼eŒçŒ½ & èkkjk 64 & fookn dk vfèkdkj ,oa mldk pykus ;¨X; g¨uk & çR;FkÊ dk ifr] vihykFkÊ laLFkk dk lnL; Fkk & lnL; g¨us ls mls Òw&[kaM vkcafVr fd;k x;k Fkk & mldh e`R;q d¢ i'pkr~ mldh iRuh }kjk Òw&[kaM vkcaVu rFkk laLFkk dh lnL;rk çnku fd, tkus d¢ fy, vkosnu çLrqr fd;k x;k & mls fookn dk vfèkdkj gS & mld¢ }kjk çLrqr fd;k x;k fookn pyus ;¨X; gSA ¼iSjk 3½

¼2½ lgdkjh l¨lkbVh vfèkfu;e] 1960 ¼eŒçŒ½ & èkkjk 26 & lfefr d¢ e`r lnL; d¢ fgr rFkk va'k dk varj.k & çR;FkÊ dk ifr vihykFkÊ laLFkk dk lnL; Fkk & mldh e`R;q g¨ xà & mldk fgr v©j va'k mldh iRuh rFkk fofèkd okfjl¨a d¨ varfjr g¨xkA ¼iSjk 3½

¼3½ lgdkjh l¨lkbVh vfèkfu;e] 1960 ¼eŒçŒ½ & èkkjk 26 & mifofèk 13 & ykxw g¨uk & mifofèk 13 ij vfèkfu;e dh èkkjk 26 vfÒÒkoh g¨xh & mifofèk d¢ micaèk vfèkfu;e d¢ micaèk¨a ij vfÒÒkoh ugha g¨ ldrsA ¼iSjk 3½

¼4½ lgdkjh l¨lkbVh vfèkfu;e] 1960 ¼eŒçŒ½ & èkkjk 64 & fookn e©f[kd rFkk nLrkosth lk{; ls lkfcr & çfroknh dh fdlh nqcZyrk ij fopkj ugha fd;k x;k & gLr{ksi visf{kr ughaA 2018 ¼2½ eŒçŒ ohDyh u¨V~l u¨V 39] 2013 ¼3½ ,e ih ,y ts 6 rFkk 2014 ¼2½ ,e ih ,y ts 214 fufnZ"VA ¼iSjk 3½

¼5½ lgdkjh l¨lkbVh vfèkfu;e] 1960 ¼eŒçŒ½ & èkkjk 26 rFkk 64 & lfefr d¢ lnL; dh e`R;q & mld¢ fgr rFkk va'k d¢ varj.k d¢ lacaèk esa fookn & èkkjk 26 d¢ vèkhu lfefr d¢ lapkyd e.My }kjk fofuf'pr fd;k tkuk visf{kr gS & vk{ksfir vkns'k bl lhek rd :ikarfjrA ¼iSjk 3½

(1) Cooperative Societies Act, 1960 (M.P.) -- S. 64 -- right to dispute and maintainability thereof -- husband of respondent was member of appellant society -- being a member, plot was allotted to him -- after his death, dispute for allotment of plot and grant of membership of society filed by his wife -- she has right to dispute -- dispute filed by her is maintainable. [Para 3]

(2) Cooperative Societies Act, 1960 (M.P.) -- S. 26 -- transfer of interest and share of deceased member of society -- husband of respondent was member of appellant society -- he died -- his interest and share will transfer to his wife and legal heirs. [Para 3]

(3) Cooperative Societies Act, 1960 (M.P.) -- S. 26 – bye-law 13 -- applicability -- provisions of section 26 of Act will prevail over bye-law 13 -- provisions of bye-laws cannot prevail over provisions of Act. [Para 3]

(4) Cooperative Societies Act, 1960 (M.P.) -- S. 64 -- dispute proved by oral and documentary evidence -- no weakness of defendant taken into consideration -- no interference called for. 2018 (II) MPWN 39, 2013 (3) MPLJ 6 and 2014 (2) MPLJ 214 referred to. [Para 3]

(5) Cooperative Societies Act, 1960 (M.P.) -- Ss. 26 and 64 -- death of member of society -- dispute regarding transfer of his interest and share -- required to be decided by Board of Directors of society under section 26 -- impugned order modified to this extent. [Para 3]

vkns'k

1- çdj.k esa fnukad 19-9-2022 d¨ vafre rdZ lqus x, Fks fdUrq vfèkdj.k esa n'kgjk] nhikoyh vodk'k rFkk ekuŒ vè;{k eg¨n; d¢ vodk'k ij jgus d¢ n`f"Vxr çdj.k esa vkt vkns'k ikfjr fd;k tk jgk gSA

vihykFkÊ }kjk ;g çFke vihy mi&iathd] lgdkjh laLFkk,] Ò¨iky }kjk çdj.k Øekad 64&96@2001 esa ikfjr vkns'k fnukad 6-6-2003 ls O;fFkr g¨dj la;qDr iath;d] Ò¨iky laÒkx d¢ le{k is'k çFke vihy Øekad 78&147@2007&08 esa ikfjr vkns'k fnukad 28-8-2018 d¢ ekè;e ls ewyr% çkfIr mijkar eŒçŒ lgdkjh l¨lk;Vh vfèkfu;e 1960 ¼ftls la{ksi esa ^^vfèkfu;e^^ d¢ uke ls lac¨fèkr fd;k tkosxk½ dh èkkjk 78¼1½ varxZr çLrqr dh xà gSA

2- çdj.k d¢ rF; laf{kIrr% bl çdkj gSa fd vihykFkÊ laLFkk vfèkfu;e dh èkkjk 9 varxZr iathÑr ,d x`g fuekZ.k lgdkjh laLFkk gS] ftldk mn~ns'; mld¢ lnL;¨a d¨ Òw[kaM@vkokl miyCèk djk;k tkuk gSA çR;FkÊ d¢ ifr LoŒ Jh d¢ŒihŒ vfXug¨=h vihykFkÊ laLFkk d¢ lnL; g¨uk vfÒdfFkr fd;k tkdj mUgsa laLFkk }kjk mud¢ thoudky esa tek djkà xà jkf'k #i;s 3]500@& d¢ isVs laLFkk dh xzke ckofM+;kdyka fLFkr LokfeRo ,oa vkfèkiR; dh Òwfe [kljk uEcj 49]400 ,dM+ esa ls 4356 oxZQhV dk Òw[kaM vkoafVr fd;k x;k FkkA laLFkk lnL; Jh dsŒihŒ vfXug¨=h dk nsgkolku fnukad 4-7-1998 d¨ g¨us d¢ i'pkr~ mudh iRuh Jherh deyk vfXug¨=h@çR;FkÊ }kjk vfèkfu;e dh èkkjk 64 varxZr ,d fookn iath;d] lgdkjh laLFkk,a eŒçŒ Ò¨iky d¢ le{k fnukad 12-9-2001 d¨ is'k djrs gq, laLFkk dh Òwfe esa ls fnukad 16-4-1982 d¨ vkoafVr 10 Msfley ¼4356 oxZQhV½ d¢ Òw[kaM dh jftLVªh çR;FkÊ d¢ i{k esa djus ,oa vkfèkiR; le; lhek fuf'pr dj çnku djkus fo"k;d vkns'k gsrq fuosnu fd;k x;kA mDr fookn iath;d }kjk vfèkfu;e dh èkkjk 66¼1½ varxZr mi&iathd] LFkkiuk] eq[;ky; d¨ varfjr fd;k x;k] ftud¢ }kjk çdj.k Øekad 64&96@2001 d¢ :i esa ntZ dj vkns'k fnukad 6-6-2003 }kjk fookn çR;FkÊ d¢ i{k esa t;if=r dj çR;FkÊ d¢ LoŒ ifr Jh dsŒihŒ vfXug¨=h d¢ LFkku ij Jherh deyk vfXug¨=h d¨ fofèkor lnL;rk çnku djus ,oa e`rd dsŒihŒ vfXug¨=h dh lnL;rk d¢ çkIr g¨us okys leLr ykÒ] vU; lnL;¨a d¢ leku çnku fd, tkus d¢ vkns'k çnku fd, x,] ftlls O;fFkr g¨dj vihykFkÊ }kjk orZeku vihy vfèkdj.k d¢ le{k is'k dh xà gSA

3- vihykFkÊ vfèkoDrk }kjk vihy Kki d¢ vuqlkj rdZ çLrqr djrs gq, vfÒdfFkr fd;k x;k gS fd mi&iathd }kjk bl vk'k; dk fu"d"kZ fd ^^vfèkfu;e dh èkkjk 64¼1½ vuqlkj fookn esa------ d¨Ã lnL;] ÒwriwoZ lnL; ;k fdlh l¨lk;Vh d¢ lnL; gSa] fdlh lnL;] ÒwriwoZ lnL; ;k e`r lnL; dh ekQZr nkok djus okyk d¨Ã O;fDr^^ fofèk vuqdwy ugha gS D;¨afd fopkj.k U;k;ky; d¢ le{k çLrqr fookn fdlh ÒwriwoZ lnL; ;k fdlh e`rd lnL; d¢ ekQZr is'k u g¨dj lhèks O;fDr fo'ks"k vFkkZr Jherh deyk vfXug¨=h }kjk is'k fd;k x;k gSA laLFkk dh vkn'kZ mifofèk Øekad&13 esa lnL;rk lekfIr d¢ Li"V çkoèkku gS bld¢ vuqlkj lnL; dh e`R;q g¨ tkus d¢ dkj.k lnL;rk lekIr g¨ tkus fo"k;d rF;] t¨ orZeku çdj.k esa laLFkk lnL; Jh d¢ŒihŒ vfXug¨=h d¢ fnukad 4-7-1998 d¨ gqà e`R;q d¢ n`f"Vxr laKku esa ysus esa mi&iathd }kjk fofèkd =qfV dkfjr dh xà gSA mifofèk Øekad 13¼6½ vuqlkj laLFkk lnL; dh e`R;q dh n'kk esa laLFkk ls mld¢ va'k ;k tek jkf'k;¨a esa ls mlls olwyh ;¨X; jkf'k de djd¢] 'ks"k jkf'k mld¢ }kjk ukekafdr O;fDr ;k mld¢ oSèkkfud mÙkjkfèkdkjh d¢ :i esa mDr jkf'k d¨ çkIr djus d¢ vfèkdkjh g¨ Indeminity bond Òjus ij Òqxrku dh tk ld¢xhA lnL; dh e`R;q dh n'kk esa mldh lnL;rk fdlh vU; d¨ varfjr fd, tkus vFkok mld¢ LFkku ij fdlh vU; O;fDr d¨ lnL;rk çnku fd;k tkuk mifofèk;¨a esa çkoèkkfur ugha gSA vfèkfu;e d¢ çkoèkku varxZr x`g fuekZ.k lgdkjh laLFkk dk lnL; g¨us dh ik=rk ifjokj d¢ d¢oy ,d gh O;fDr d¨ g¨us ,oa bPNqd O;fDr d¢ ikl Ò¨iky ,oa eŒçŒ lfgr vU; d¨Ã futh Òw[kaM ;k vkokl ugha g¨uk v©j mld¢ fdlh vU; x`gfuekZ.k lgdkjh laLFkk esa lnL; ugha g¨uk vkKkid çkoèkku gSA vfèkfu;e dh èkkjk 26 ;g çkoèkkfur djrh gS fd laLFkk lnL; d¨ ;g vfèkdkj gS fd og viuh 'ks;lZ d¢ lacaèk esa ukekadu dj ldrk gS fd mldh e`R;q mijkar mld¢ LoRo fdls çkIr g¨\ fdlh lnL; dh e`R;q ij mld¢ oSèk mÙkjkfèkdkjh g¨us d¢ çek.k is'k fd, tkus ij fookn dh fLFkfr esa laLFkk lapkyd e.My d¨ ;g vfèkdkj çnku fd;k x;k gS fd og ,sls e`r lnL; d¢ oSèk mÙkjkfèkdkjh d¨ e`r lnL; d¢ LoRo çnku dj ld¢A ,sls e`r lnL; }kjk vftZr LFkkà laifRr d¨ fdlh e`r lnL; d¢ ukekafdr O;fDr

Click Here to Read the rest of this document
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
supreme today icon
logo-black

An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers

Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance

qr

Scan Me!

India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!

For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :

whatsapp-icon telegram-icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top