2017 Supreme(MP) 1123
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
S.K. SETH, ANJULI PALO, JJ.
Buddha Sen Kumhar - Appellant
Versus
State of Madhya Pradesh - Respondent
M. Cr.C. No. 17905 of 2017
Decided On : 15-11-2017
Important Points
Subject
Criminal Law - Evidence and Procedure
Act Referred
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE : S.482, S.173(8)
EVIDENCE ACT : S.65(b), S.62, S.73
INDIAN PENAL CODE : S.120(b)
PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION ACT : S.7, S.13(1)(d), S.13(2)
Headnote
Section 482 - Quashing of Order - Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, Section 7, 13(1) D, 13(2), IPC Section 120-B - The court discussed the admissibility of voice samples as evidence, citing relevant legal provisions and interpretations from cases such as 'Ritesh Sinha v. State of Uttar Pradesh' and 'Sudhir Chaudhary v. State (NCT of Delhi)'. The court emphasized the importance of voice samples for identification purposes and concluded that the impugned order did not violate Article 20(3) of the Constitution of India.
Fact of the Case:
The accused filed an application to quash the order directing him to provide his voice sample to the Lokayukta Police after a charge sheet was filed against him for offences under the Prevention of Corruption Act and IPC Section 120-B.
Finding of the Court:
The court found that the voice sample was essential for identification purposes and admissible as evidence, and that the impugned order did not violate the Constitution of India.
Issues: Admissibility of voice samples as evidence after filing of charge sheet, violation of Article 20(3) of the Constitution of India.
Ratio Decidendi: The court held that voice samples for identification purposes are admissible as evidence and do not violate Article 20(3) of the Constitution of India.
Final Decision: The application under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C. was dismissed.
For the Appellants : Pramod Thakre, Counsel
For the Respondents: Pankaj Dubey, Counsel.
ANJULI PALO, J.
1. This application has been filed by the accused under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C. for quashing of order dated 20.07.2017, passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Anuppur in Special Case No.10/2016, whereby the Special Court directed the applicant to give his voice sample to the Lokayukta Police.
2. It was alleged that the applicant was trapped by Lokayukt Police with other co-accused persons for taking bribe and money was recovered from the applicant. After completing investigation, charge sheet has been filed before the learned trial Court for offences punishable under Sections 7, 13(1) D read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 and Section 120-B of the IPC.
3. An application for voice recording of the applicant was filed by the prosecution as Annexure-A/1 on the grounds that, the accused/applicant was called for so many times by the Lokayukta Police for his voice test but the applicant and other co-accused persons were not present before the Lokayukta Police. Therefore, under the order of learned trial Court, the prosecution prayed to collect their voice samples.
4. After considering the submissions of learned counsel for both the parties and the principle laid down in the case of "Ritesh Sinha v. State of Uttar Pradesh, AIR 2013 SC 1132", the trial Court allowed the application and directed the applicant and other co-accused persons to provide their voice samples to the Lokayukta Police following the principles laid down by the Supreme Court in the case of "Sudhir Chaudhary v. State (NCT of Delhi), (2016) 8 SCC 307".
5. Aforesaid order was challenged by the applicant on the ground that there is no provision for recording the voice sample when investigation is over and charge sheet has been filed. The impugned is violation of Article 20(3) of the Constitution of India, therefore, requested to set aside.
6. Learned counsel appearing on behalf SPE/Lokayukta has vehemently opposed the prayer.
7. Heard and perused the record.
8. The charge sheet has been filed against the applicant for offences punishable under Sections 7, 13(1)D read with Section 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act and Section 120-B of the IPC. It was alleged that demand of bribe was made by him. Such conversation was recorded through voice recorder. CD of that voice record was filed along with certificate under Section 65-B of the Indian Evidence Act. Copy of the aforesaid document has been provided to the applicant and other co-accused persons. Charges have not been framed by the trial Court. Hence, at this juncture, if voice sample of the applicant is provided to the prosecution, it would not prejudice to the applicant.
9. It is important to note here that, trial has not yet commenced.
10. We feels that voice samples ought to be taken for the purpose to establish the identity. In our opinion, such direction can be given to provide the voice samples only for the purposes of identification and does not contain any culpability statement so as to be hit by Article 20(3) of the Constitution of India. In this regard, reference can be made to "Rakesh Bist v. Central Bureau of Investigation, 2007 Cr.L.J. 1530".
11. In the case of "State of Bombay v. Kathi Kalu Oghad, AIR 1961 SC 1808", it was observed that:-
"It is obvious however that these dangers remain the same whether the evidence which the accused is compelled to furnish is in the form of statements, oral or written about his own knowledge or in the shape of documents or things, which though not transmitting knowledge of the accused person directly helps the Court to come to a conclusion against him. If production of such documents, or things is giving evidence, then the person's producing it is being a witness. On what principle or reason can it be said that this does not amount to "being a witness" within the meaning of Article 20(3).
We can therefore find no justification for thinking that "to be a witness" in Art. 20 (3) means to impart personal knowledge and find