SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2025 Supreme(MP) 479

IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
Sanjay Dwivedi, J.
Sandeep Soni v. Smt. Chandra Kanta Vyas & Others
Miscellaneous Appeals No. 9049 of 2024 and 9050 of 2024 (Jabalpur); Decided on 17.6.2025

Act Referred

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : O.39 R.1, O.39 R.2

Headnote

flfoy çfØ;k lafgrk] 1908 && vk-39 fu-1 rFkk 2 && oknh d¢ LokfeRo d¢ fo"k; esa d¨Ã lk{; ugÈ && çfroknh us jftLVªhÑr foØ; foys[k ls Òwfe Ø; dh && og Òwfe dk Lokeh gS && oknh d¢ dCts d¢ fo"k; esa d¨Ã fofufnZ"V fu"d"kZ ugÈ && okni= d¢ vuqlkj oknh dk dCtk vfrØked d¢ :i esa gS && rkfRod la?kVdksa vFkkZr~ çFken`"V~;k ekeyk] lqfoèkk dk larqyu rFkk viwj.kh; {kfr ij fopkj fd, fcuk oknh d¢ i{k esa O;kns'k çnku fd;k x;k && fopkj.k U;k;ky; us O;kns'k çnku dj fofèkekU; Øsrk dk vfèkdkj de fd;k && fupys U;k;ky;¨a d¢ vkns'k vikLr fd, && vLFkk;h O;kns'k dk vkosnu [kkfjt fd;kA 2019 ¼1½ ts,yts 354 ¾ 2019 ¼3½ ,eih,yts 406] 2011 vkj,u 347 ¾ 2011 ¼1½ ,eih,yts 106 rFkk 2000 ¼1½ ,eihtsvkj 465 voyafcrA ¼iSjk 13 lsa 16

Civil P. C., 1908 -- O. 39 Rr. 1 and 2 -- no evidence about ownership of plaintiff -- defendant purchased land by registered sale deed -- he is owner of land -- no specific finding about possession of plaintiff -- as per plaint, possession of plaintiff is as trespasser -- injunction granted in favour of plaintiff without considering material ingredients, i.e., prima facie case, balance of convenience and irreparable injury -- trial Court curtailed right of valid purchaser in granting injunction -- orders of Court below set aside -- application of temporary injunction rejected. 2019 (1) JLJ 354 = 2019 (3) MPLJ 406, 2011 RN 347 = 2011 (1) MPLJ 106 and 2000 (1) MPJR 465 relied on. [Paras 13 to 16

Advocates appeared:
Satish Kumar Shrivastava and Amit Dave for respective appellants; Manoj Sanghi for respondents No. 1, 2 and 5; S. N. Tiwari for respondents No. 3 and 4; Ajay Ojha, Government Advocate for respondent No. 7.

JUDGMENT

1. With the consent of learned counsel for the parties, the matters were finally heard on 13.03.2025 and today the order is being pronounced.

2. These are two separate miscellaneous appeals filed under Order XLIII rule 1(r) of CPC challenging the order dated 7.1.2024 passed by the Court below in a pending Civil Suit bearing RCS No.1077-A/2024 whereby an application for temporary injunction has been allowed.

3. Challenging the said order, two separate appeals have been filed by defendant No.1 and 2. Since the parties are same in the civil suit and in both the appeals same order is assailed by the appellant, therefore, both the appeals are heard and decided analogously by a common order. Although for the purpose of convenience the facts of M.A.No.9049/2024 are being taken note of.

4. As per the facts of the case, the plaintiffs (respondents No.1 to 5) filed a civil suit registered as RCS No.1077-A/2024 against the defendants (present appellant and respondent No.6) for declaration and permanent injunction. An application for grant of temporary injunction has also been filed under Order XXXIX rule 1 and 2 of CPC. As per the claim set-up by the plaintiffs in their plaint and also in the application for grant of temporary injunction, they jointly purchased the suit property with Indubala Sharma D/o. Ravi Shankar Sharma with the plaintiffs. The suit land bearing Khasra No. 306 comprised with total area 5.15 acres situated in village Maharajpur Patwari Halka No.664 Patwari Circle No.20 Tehsil Adhartal, District Jabalpur vide registered sale-deed dated 22.5.1967. Thereafter the name of plaintiff No.1 got mutated on the land of Khasra No.306/1 area 4.15 acres which is the disputed land in the instant suit. The plaintiff No.1 has claimed that from the date of purchase, the land is in her possession and she has been cultivating the same i.e. area 4.15 acres.

5. To substantiate her title, she filed a document showing that earlier she filed a suit bearing C.S. No.185-A/2011 against Raj Kumar Yadav and in the said suit, the Court i.e. First Civil Judge, Class-II, Jabalpur has granted a temporary injunction vide order dated 23.12.2011. Although the name of father of plaintiff was wrongly shown as Ramchandra but by moving an application before the Naib Tehsildar it got changed as Ram Charan but later on that order of Naib Tehsildar in an appeal has been set aside and the name of Ramchandra was restored.

6. However, it is averred in the plaint that the defendant/respondent No.6 herein by taking undue benefit of recording the name of defendant No.1 executed a sale-deed in favour of defendant No.2 on 19.9.2024 and she impersonated herself to be a true owner and as such defendant No.2 (present appellant) started threatening the plaintiffs to take possession of the suit land. A suit has been filed claiming temporary injunction. In the suit a declaration has also been sought that sale-deed dated 19.9.2024 executed by defendant No.1 (respondent No.6 herein) in favour of present appellant (defendant No.2) be declared null & void and a decree of permanent injunction has also been claimed.

7. The application for temporary injunction was replied by the defendant (present appellant) on the ground that the plaintiff did not come with clean hands and good conscience to get the equitable relief of declaration and injunction and also denied their possession over the suit land. It is also stated that plaintiff Chandrakanta is not having title or lawful possession over the suit land or house situated over the area 230 square feet. It is also stated in the reply that the plaintiff is trying to usurp the suit property by impersonating herself as a true owner on the basis of resemblance of her name with defendant No.1 and also of the coincidence describing the name in the registered sale-deed dated 22.5.1967. The title over the suit land claimed by the plaintiff has been denied. The application was also sought to be dismissed on the ground that claiming injuncti

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top