Back
2013 Supreme(MP) 288
HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
Prakash Shrivastava, J.
Badrilal and others v. State of M.P. and others
Writ Petition No.10072 of 2012 (Indore); Decided on 14.5.2013.
Sanjay Jamindar, Prateek Maheshwari, K.C. Raikwar, Akash Sharma, G.P. Singh, Surendra Patwa, Anand Bhatt, Subhash Upadhyaya, Abhishek Tugnawat, K.L. Purohit, M.R.Sheikh and Manoj Manav etc. for petitioners;
Ms. Vinita Phaye, Deputy Government Advocate assisted by Arun Kumar Ingle, Assistant Director, TPI, Bhopal for respondents/State;
Abhishek Soni for Board of Secondary Education.
Subject
Education Law - TEACHER RECRUITMENT
Act Referred
PANCHAYAT RAJ EVAM GRAM SWARAJ ADHINIYAM : S.95(1), S.70(2)
Headnote
Held : In view of the aforesaid analysis, it is held that the petitioners who were not holding the requisite qualification which have been prescribed in the Rules, have rightly been found ineligible for appointment to the post in question. (2003)3 SCC 541 and (2003)3 SCC 548 followed. Writ Petition No.4529 of 2013, Writ Petition No.6559 of 2013 and Writ Petition No.6686 of 2013 relied on.
iapk;r jkt ,oa xzke Lojkt vf/kfu;e] 1993 ¼e-iz-½ & /kkjk 95¼1½ lgifBr /kkjk 70¼2½ & e-iz- iapk;r lafonk ‘kkyk f’k{kd ¼fu;kstu ,oa lafonk dh ‘krsZ½ fu;e] 2005 & fu-6] vuqlwph 2 & lafonk f’k{kdksa dh fu;qfDr;k¡ & lacaf/kr fu;eksa ds vuqlkj dh tk,xh & p;u izfdz;k esa lfEefyr gksuk rFkk fyf[kr ijh{kk mRrh.kZ djus ek= ls visf{kr vgZrk u gksus dh vik=rk ij dksbZ izHkko ugha gksxkA
vfHkfu/kkZfjr % iwoksZDr fo’ys”k.k dks n`f”Vxr j[krs gq,] ;g vfHkfu/kkZfjr fd;k tkrk gS fd ;kphx.k] ftuds ikl fu;eksa esa fofgr dh xbZ visf{kr vgZrk ugha Fkh] iz’uxr in ij fu;qfDr ds fy, Bhd&gh vik= ik, x,A ¼2003½3 ,l lh lh 541 rFkk ¼2003½3 ,l lh lh 548 vuqlfjrA fjV ;kfpdk dz- 4529 lu~ 2013] fjV ;kfpdk dz- 6559 lu~ 2013 rFkk fjV ;kfpdk dz- 6686 lu~ 2013 voyafcrA
1. This order will govern the disposal of Writ Petitions No.10072/2012, 4126/2013, 3977/2013, 2528/2013, 2530/2013, 2645/2013, 2676/2013, 2758/2013, 2857/2013, 2896/2013, 2898/2013, 2899/2013, 2900/2013, 2901/2013, 2902/2013, 2926/2013, 2928/2013, 2929/2013, 2990/2013, 3200/2013, 3526/2013, 3260/2013, 3263/2013, 3267/2013, 3272/2013, 3274/2013, 3275/2013, 3276/2013, 3290/2013, 3410/2013, 3412/2013, 3623/2013, 3626/2013, 3629/2013, 3630/2013, 3680/2013, 3690/2013, 3699/2013, 3721/2013, 3731/2013, 3732/2013, 3733/2013, 3734/2013, 3735/2013, 3736/2013, 3737/2013, 3738/2013, 3739/2013, 3740/2013, 3741/2013, 3742/2013, 3743/2013, 3744/2013, 3745/2013, 3746/2013, 3747/2013, 3748/2013, 3925/2013, 3979/2013, 4001/2013, 4002/2013, 4018/2013, 4021/2013, 4023/2013, 4024/2013, 4031/2013, 4032/2013, 4040/2013, 4048/2013, 4049/2013, 4051/2013, 4052/2013, 4054/2013, 4055/2013, 4056/2013, 4059/2013, 4063/2013, 4070/2013, 4071/2013, 4072/2013, 4073/2013, 4074/2013, 4075/2013, 4077/2013, 4078/2013, 4079/2013, 4082/2013, 4083/2013, 4084/2013, 4085/2013, 4093/2013, 4099/2013, 4100/2013, 4102/2013, 4103/2013, 4106/2013, 4108/2013, 4110/2013, 4115/2013, 4116/2013, 4117/2013, 4118/2013, 4120/2013, 4122/2013, 4123/2013, 4124/2013, 4125/2013, 4127/2013, 4128/2013, 4129/2013, 4132/2013, 4134/2013, 4139/2013, 4141/2013, 4146/2013, 4147/2013, 4148/2013, 4149/2013, 4150/2013, 4151/2013, 4152/2013, 4153/2013, 4154/2013, 4155/2013, 4156/2013, 4157/2013, 4158/2013, 4159/2013, 4160/2013, 4161/2013, 4162/2013, 4163/2013, 4164/2013, 4172/2013, 4176/2013, 4179/2013, 4181/2013, 4188/2013, 4189/2013, 4190/2013, 4193/2013, 4196/2013, 4197/2013, 4198/2013, 4202/2013, 4206/2013, 4221/2013, 4227/2013, 4264/2013, 4265/2013, 4268/2013, 4307/2013, 4357/2013, 4386/2013, 4387/2013, 4388/2013, 4389/2013, 4398/2013, 4412/2013, 4433/2013, 4561/2013, 4572/2013, 4580/2013, 4277/2013, 3120/2013, 3321/2013, 3722/2013, 3723/2013, 3724/2013, 3725/2013, 3728/2013, 3729/2013, 3730/2013, 3753/2013, 3762/2013, 3796/2013, 3831/2013, 3832/2013, 3834/2013, 3835/2013, 3836/2013, 3837/2013, 3838/2013, 3919/2013, 3921/2013, 3922/2013, 3931/2013, 3933/2013, 3934/2013, 3935/2013, 3936/2013, 3947/2013, 3961/2013, 3962/2013, 3963/2013, 3964/2013, 3975/2013, 3976/2013, 3982/2013, 3984/2013, 3985/2013, 3987/2013, 3988/2013, 3989/2013, 3996/2013, 4236/2013, 4244/2013, 4270/2013, 4275/2013, 4290/2013, 4291/2013, 4292/2013, 4313/2013, 4356/2013, 4373/2013, 4446/2013, 4460/2013, 4461/2013, 4482/2013, 4487/2013, 4488/2013, 4489/2013, 4490/2013, 4491/2013, 4492/2013, 4493/2013, 4494/2013, 4495/2013, 4498/2013, 4499/2013, 4702/2013, 4703/2013, 4713/2013, 4719/2013, 4720/2013, 4658/2013, 4659/2013, 4660/2013, 4661/2013, 4662/2013, 4663/2013, 4664/2013, 4665/2013, 4666/2013, 4668/2013, 4679/2013, 4683/2013, 4691/2013, 4694/2013, 4698/2013, 4699/2013, 10040/2012, 5412/2013, 5431/2013, 5432/2013, 5559/2013, 5560/2013, 5561/2013, 5562/2013, 5925/2013, 5924/2013, 5873/2013, 5874/2013, 5875/2013, 5876/2013, 5878/2013, 5879/2013, 5880/2013, 5768/2013, 5872/2013, 5932/2013, 5796/2013, 3563/2013, 5794/2013, 5793/2013, 5956/2013, 6134/2013, 6135/2013, 6136/2013, 6006/2013, 6010/2013, 6007/2013, 5015/2013, 5013/2013, 5720/2013, 5717/2013, 5711/2013, 5708/2013, 5702/2013, 5662/2013, 5520/2013, 5525/2013, 5533/2013, 5430/2013, 4672/2013, 4500/2013, 5594/2013, 5595/2013, 5660/2013, 5009/2013, 4807/2013, 5735/2013 and 5795/2013. It is stated by the counsel for both the parties that all these writ petitions involve same issue on the similar fact situation.
1A. These writ petitions relate to the recruitment to the post of Samvida Shala Shikshak Grade I, Grade II and Grade III (for short “Samvida Shala Shikshak”). Since respondents have not considered the petitioners for appointment to the post of Samvida Shala Shikshak on the ground that the petitioners do not possess the requisite minimum qualification prescribed for the post, therefore, the petitioners have approached this Court.
2. In brief, the advertisements were
