2022 Supreme(Telangana) 448
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
K. SURENDER, J.
The State, Represented by Inspector of Police, Anti-Corruption Bureau - Appellant
Versus
Sri G. Rajendra Prasad - Respondent
Criminal Appeal No. 1466 of 2006
Decided On : 26-07-2022
Important Points
Subject
Criminal Law - Corruption
Act Referred
PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION ACT : S.7, S.13(1)(d)(i), S.13(ii), S.13(2), S.20
Headnote
Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 - Section 7, 13 (1)(d)(I)&(II), 13(2), 20 - Indian Evidence Act - Section 27 - Criminal Appeal - Recovery of amount - PW1 defacto complainant was owner of M/s.Maks Casting Private Limited, Uppal, R.R.Districrt. In January, 2000 pursuant to scheme of Government of Andhra Pradesh giving incentives to Small Scale Industries, PW1 approached for incentive certificate - Respondent issued a temporary incentive certificate and stated that permanent incentive certificate will be issued after six months - Supreme Court reiterated powers of appellate Court in case of appeals in re-appreciating and reweighing of evidence to draw conclusions. (Para 15)
Finding of the Court :
Complaint was lodged by AO regarding demand said factum of demand was not proved by attending circumstances. On trap date, admittedly PW1 and PW2 met AO. However, recovery of amount was from a hand bag which was placed in rack in office. Though PW1 and PW2 stated that AO had demanded said amount, when viewed in totality of circumstances as narrated above in finding of Special Judge, it can be safely concluded that amount was planted in bag - Test on hands of AO proved negative and prosecution was not able to prove that hand bag belongs to AO. Amount was not recovered at instance of AO to infer factum of recovery to fall within ambit of Section 27 of Indian Evidence Act. In absence of recovery of amount from AO or at instance of AO, said recovery cannot be attributed to AO and it cannot be conclusively said that there was a demand and consequent to which AO had accepted amount. At earliest point of time AO had denied receiving any amount and ACB had in fact recovered money at instance of PW2 and PW9.
Results : Appeal dismissed.
For the Appellant : Sri Ch. Vidyasagar Rao.
For the Respondent: Sri Jaya Prakash Rokkala.
JUDGMENT :
1. This Criminal Appeal is filed by the State aggrieved by the acquittal of the respondent in C.C.No.9/2001, dated 28.03.2006 on the file of Special Judge for SPE and ACB cases, Hyderabad recorded by the I Additional Sessions Judge, Nizamabad, in APTS CC.No.35 of 2001, dated 11.02.2009, acquitting the respondent/accused for the offence punishable under Section 7 and 13 (1)(d)(I)&(II) read with 13(2) of Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.
2. The case of the prosecution is that the respondent was working as Deputy Director in the Industries Department. PW1 the defacto complainant was the owner of M/s.Maks Casting Private Limited, Uppal, R.R.Districrt. In January, 2000 pursuant to the scheme of Government of Andhra Pradesh giving incentives to Small Scale Industries, PW1 approached for the incentive certificate. The respondent issued a temporary incentive certificate and stated that permanent incentive certificate will be issued after six months. One month there after the Deputy Director (Accused Officer) visited the factory of PW1 and after inspecting company went back and called PW1 and asked him to met in his chamber. When PW1 met the Accused Officer (herein after called as ‘AO’) there was a demand of Rs.50,000/- for the purpose of issuing permanent incentive certificate. However on repeated requests by PW1 the bribe amount was reduced to Rs.30,000/- and to be paid in two installments. The said meeting was on 04.05.2000 and the AO allegedly asked bribe to be paid on 05.05.2000 i.e. next day. Aggrieved by the demand of bribe, PW1 approached the ACB office and addressed a letter to the Director General of ACB on 04.05.2000 that there was a demand of Rs.30,000/- and narrated all these facts. The said complaint was registered for the offences under Section 7 and 11 of Prevention of Corruption Act and trap was laid on 05.05.2000. Accordingly two independent witnesses were called by the DSP and arranged for the trap. Pre-trap proceedings were drafted under Ex.P2 in the presence of trap party members and two independent witnesses i.e. the DSP and two inspectors.
3. Trap Party after conclusion of pre-trap proceedings at 3.20 p.m. on 05.05.2000 proceeded to the office of AO. At 4.30 p.m. PW1 and accompanying witness D.V. Rama Krishna (PW2) went into the office room of AO and found the AO sitting in a chair. On demand of bribe by AO, PW1 offered the same and AO took out one bag, opened the zip of the bag and asked PW1 to put the tainted amount in the bag. Accordingly, tainted amount was placed in the said bag. Then the AO kept the bag on his rack beside him. Immediately, PW2 went outside and gave the prearranged signal to the trap party. On seeing the signal, trap party entered into the office of the AO and questioned the AO about receipt of amount from PW1. The AO stated that he did not receive any amount from PW1. When PW2 was questioned he stated that the AO did not receive any amount however he asked PW1 to keep the said amount in a hand bag and then placed it on the rack on his left side where AO was sitting. The DSP asked the AO to produce the amount, however, he refused to do so. The test on the hands of AO was negative. The other mediator was asked to remove the amount from the bag. After removing the said amount, post trap proceedings were conducted. The DSP there after handed over investigation to PW10.
4. After conclusion of investigation, charge sheet was filed under Section 7, 13(1)(D) read with 13(2) of Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. The charges were also framed for the said offences and after conclusion of trial AO was found not guilty.
5. The learned Special Public Prosecutor Sri Vidyasagar Rao, submits that the learned Special Judge committed an error in acquitting the accused when the factum of demand and also subsequent acceptance was proved during the course of trial. Though the amount of Rs.15,000/- was recovered from the hand bag, false implication or planting the amount does not arise for the reason of