2024 Supreme(Online)(Bom) 7100
HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
M.W. Chandwani, J
Vasant Kashinath Salve – Appellant
Versus
Moreshwar Bhujangrao Niwalkar – Respondent
SECOND APPEAL NO.479 OF 2019
Important Points
Subject
Property Law - Hindu Succession
Act Referred
Headnote
(B) Appeal - Scope - Respondent support of decree - A respondent in an appeal can raise pleas challenging adverse findings recorded by the trial court without filing a formal cross-objection, provided they do not seek to modify the decree already in their favor. (Para 12)
(C) Hindu Law - Succession - Property inherited by a male Hindu under Section 8 of the 1956 Act assumes the character of self-acquired property and does not constitute coparcenary property; descendants do not acquire interest in such property by birth. (Paras 18, 21)
Facts of the case:
The heirs of a deceased donor challenged a sale deed executed by their father, claiming the property was ancestral and that they held rights by birth, thereby requiring their consent for alienation. The trial court held the property as ancestral but dismissed the suit on the ground of limitation. An appellate court reversed this decision and decreed the suit. The transferee appealed to the High Court challenging the classification of the property.
Issues: Whether a respondent is required to file a cross-objection to challenge an adverse finding of the trial court when the final decree is in their favor, and whether property inherited under the relevant succession statute constitutes coparcenary or self-acquired property.
Findings of Court:
The court determined that the property inherited by a male Hindu under the provided statutory framework becomes his self-acquired property. Consequently, the alienation by the donor without the consent of his progeny was valid. It further held that a party may contest adverse findings of the trial court in an appeal without filing an independent cross-objection, provided the challenge does not aim to modify the decree.
Ratio Decidendi: Property inherited by a male Hindu pursuant to Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, ceases to be ancestral/coparcenary and is held as absolute/self-acquired property. Therefore, descendants have no right by birth to such property, and the transferor possesses unfettered powers of disposal. Furthermore, Order 41, Rule 22 of the Code of Civil Procedure enables a respondent to attack adverse findings without filing a cross-objection.
Result: Appeal allowed. Suit partly decreed regarding possession.
For the Appellants/Petitioners: Rohit Joshi, Madhur Deo
For the Respondents: Kirti Satpute
| Table of Content |
|---|
| 1. procedural background and conflict regarding ancestral property inheritance. (Para 1 , 2 , 3) |
| 2. respondent may contest adverse findings in appeal without formal cross-objections. (Para 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12) |
| 3. property inherited under section 8 of hindu succession act is self-acquired. (Para 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 , 22) |
| 4. possessory rights entitled to permanent injunction despite property characterization. (Para 23) |
JUDGMENT:
1. This second appeal challenges the judgment and decree dated 12.06.2019 in Regular Civil Appeal No.50/2013 passed by the District Judge, Chandrapur, thereby reversing the decree of dismissal of suit in Regular Civil Suit No.167/2008 (Old RCS No.74/2006).
2. Respondent nos.1 to 3 the sons of deceased Bhujangrao Sitaram Niwalkar, original defendant no.2, filed a suit against the appellant herein claiming that the suit property is ancestral property and the same is in possession of respondent nos.1 to 3. Bhujangrao Niwalkar alienated the suit property in favour of the appellant without consent of respondent nos.1 to 3, the coparceners. The said alienation was not for the benefit of Hindu joint family and therefore, respondent nos.1 to 3 sought declaration that the said sale-deed dated 21.08.1974 executed by their father Bhujangrao Niwalkar in favour of the appellant is not binding on them. They also sought an injunction restraining the appellant from disturbing their possession over the suit property.
3. The trial Court held that the sale-deed dated 21.08.1974 executed in favour of the appellant is not binding on respondent nos.1 to 3 and also held that respondent nos.1 to 3 are entitled to injunction restraining the appellant from disturbing their peaceful possession over the suit property. However, the trial Court dismissed the suit on the ground that it is beyond the prescribed period of limitation. Dissatisfied with the decree of dismissal, respondent nos.1 to 3 preferred an appeal before the learned District Judge, Chandrapur. The appellate Court held that the suit filed by respondent nos.1 to 3 is within limitation and thereby decreed the suit of respondent nos.1 to 3, declaring that the said sale-deed dated 21.08.1974 is not binding on respondent nos.1 to 3 and also restrained the appellant from disturbing the possession of respondent nos.1 to 3 over the suit property. The appellant challenged the said judgment and decree by this second appeal.
4. By order dated 14.01.2020, this Court has framed following substantial questions of law:
“(1) Whether in appeal it is necessary for a party to file a cross-objection in respect of an adverse finding which is rendered by the Trial Court?
(2) Whether Order 41, Rule 22 of the Civil Procedure Code, permits the respondents to raise all pleas as are available to him, in respect of a finding rendered by the Trial Court?
(3) What is the nature of difference between the property held as a coparcener and as a person inheriting under Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956?”
5. Mr. Rohit Joshi, learned counsel for the appellant, would submit that though the appellant did not file a cross-objection or a cross-appeal, as per Order XLI Rule 22, the appellant who was respondent before the first appellate Court, had right to object to any issue which ought to have been in his favour without filing any cross-appeal or cross-objection. According to him, the trial Court without framing an issue on the point of nature of suit property, i.e. whether the suit property is ancestral or self-acquired property has held that the suit property is ancestral property of respondent nos.1 to 3. When the objection was raised by the appellant before the appellate Court it was overruled on the ground that no cross-appeal or cross-objection has been filed by the appellant. He submitted that as per Order XLI Rule 22 of the CPC, the respondent need not file cross-appeal or cross-objection to attack any finding recorded