1960 Supreme(Online)(Ker) 33
KERALA HIGH COURT
C. A. Vaidialingam, J.
Kunhukutty Sahib v. Veerankutty
S. A. No. 148 of 1956 (K)
Important Points
Subject
Civil - Tort Law
Act Referred
Headnote
(B) Elements for malicious prosecution - Onus on plaintiff to prove prosecution, favorable termination, lack of cause, and malice - Court found all elements satisfied, establishing liability against defendant. (Paras 32-33)
(C) Appeal outcomes - Appeals were allowed in part, modifying the damages awarded by the trial court. (Paras 18, 62)
1 This is an appeal by the plaintiff claiming enhanced compensation in a suit filed by him claiming damages as against the defendant for malicious prosecution. The plaintiff, according to the case set up in the plaint, was prosecuted for a charge under S.325 of the Indian Penal Code on the basis of a complaint made by the defendant to the Police at Chowghat. The Second Class Magistrate at Chowghat in C.C. No. 45 of 1952 enquired into the matter and ultimately discharged the accused on 14-7-1952 under S.253 (1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure. The said judgment is Ext. A2 in these proceedings.
2 It was the further case of the plaintiff that the complaint filed by the defendant, namely, Ext. A1, on 3-10-1951 was false to the knowledge of the defendant and he has given the complaint without any reasonable and probable cause and with malice just to put the plaintiff to disgrace and loss.
3 In consequence of the judgment in his favour of the criminal court evidenced by Ext. A2, the plaintiff called upon the defendant by his notice, Ext. A8, to pay him damages as claimed therein. The defendant by his reply notice Ext. A7 has affirmed the allegations made by him in his complaint and also the charge which has been found to be false by the criminal court.
4 Therefore, the plaintiff claimed damages in the sum of Rs. 1000 from the defendant for malicious prosecution under three heads of claim: (a) Rs. 200/- for the expenses incurred by him in connection with the proceedings before the criminal court; (b) Rs. 100/-, travelling expenses incurred by him for obtaining documents and other incidental expenses; (c) Rs. 700/- as damages for mental pain caused to him and also loss of reputation in consequence of the malicious prosecution launched by the defendant.
5 The suit was defended on the ground that the defendant was not the prosecutor as understood in law. He affirmed, no doubt, the various allegations made by him in his complaint to the Police on 3-10-1951 namely, Ext. A1 as also the charge that he levelled against the plaintiff. The defendant further contended that he was beaten by the plaintiff and his arm also was fractured, and he sustained grievous hurt. According to the defendant, the allegations made by him in the circumstances, as also the evidence given by him in the criminal court were all true. He also denied that, in any event, he has complained without reasonable and probable cause and with malice as alleged by the plaintiff. This is only an attempt by the plaintiff to extort some money, if possible, from the defendant and to root out the defendant and his family from the place where he was living.
6 There was also an allegation that the defendant cannot be said to have acted without reasonable and probable cause and what he did was only to lay information to the Police and it was the Police who investigated the matter and ultimately laid the charge as against the plaintiff. He had nothing to do with the actual conduct of the prosecution by the Police. Therefore, he is not liable in law to answer the claim of the plaintiff.
7 On the claim for damages, the defendant also alternatively contended that though the plaintiff may be a man of property he is utterly devoid of all decency and has no respectability whatsoever. The plaintiff, according to the defendant, was a terror in the locality and he is only out to harm poor people like the defendant who do not see eye to eye with him in some of the political matters.
8 The defendant further averred that the plaintiff sent for him on the night of 20-9-1951 and he was severely beaten by the plaintiff as a result of which he sustained serious injuries as also a fracture of his arm. Due to fear of the plaintiff, he did not make any complaint to the Police. But this incident appears to have come to the knowledge of one Dr. K.B. Menon, a member of the Madras Legislative Assembly and who is Dw. 2 in this case. The said Dr. K.B. Menon, on seeing the defendant was fully satisfied about the occu