2009 MarsdenLR 4253
HIGH COURT SABAH & SARAWAK KUCHING
POLEON AJAN – Appellant
Versus
PP – Respondent
[Criminal Appeal No: 41-86-2009-II]
Important Points
Subject
Traffic Offences - Reckless and Dangerous Driving
Act Referred
Headnote
(B) Legal Standards - Distinction between reckless driving and dangerous driving defined; reckless driving involves a conscious disregard for obvious risks, whereas dangerous driving relates to being at fault in creating a dangerous situation. (Paras 3, 4)
Facts of the case:
The appellant was convicted of causing death through reckless driving on 7 January 2002; evidence was challenged on the grounds of admissibility and interpretation of key facts regarding the accident.
Findings of Court:
The original conviction was set aside due to prosecutorial errors concerning offense categorization; the appellant was instead convicted of careless driving.
Issues: The main issues included misapplication of legal standards in determining whether the evidence supported a conviction for reckless or dangerous driving.
Ratio Decidendi: The court emphasized that the prosecution's failure to distinctly categorize offenses under s 41(1) improperly burdened the appellant with disproving separate legal elements. The distinction between the offense categories is critical to ensure fair trial rights.
Result: Appeal allowed; conviction changed to careless driving with revised sentence.
| Table of Content |
|---|
| 1. conviction for reckless and dangerous driving under road transport act. (Para 1) |
| 2. appeal challenges regarding evidence and prosecution failure. (Para 2) |
| 3. distinction between reckless and dangerous driving offenses. (Para 3 , 5) |
| 4. misdirection of the magistrate on legal principles. (Para 4) |
| 5. evidence assessment and admissibility affect the conviction. (Para 6 , 7 , 8 , 9) |
| 6. victim's position on the road is legally justified. (Para 10) |
| 7. appellant's implausible defense considered in judgment. (Para 11 , 12 , 13) |
[1] The appellant was convicted and sentenced by the magistrate's court for an offence of "reckless and dangerous driving" under s 41(1) of the Road Transport Act 1987 which had caused the death of one Apap ak Nguoh. The offence was alleged to have been committed on 7 January 2002 at about 8.10am at Mile 54, Kuching/Serian Road. He was sentenced to 30 months imprisonment and fined RM5,000 in default two months imprisonment. As required by the law, he was also disqualified from holding a driving licence (of any class) for three years from the date of the conviction which was 15 April 2009. The appellant's appeal is against both the conviction and sentence.
[2] In the appeal, the decision of the learned magistrate was attacked along these lines and I reproduced it in the order that they appeared in the appellant's counsel's written submission but in a summarized form.
(i) The prosecution's failure to tender the rough sketch plan rendered the neat sketch plan and its key (exh. P5 and exh. P5k, respectively) inadmissible.
(ii) The presence of scratch marks and scattered glass fragments were not sufficiently indicative of the point of impact.
(iii) Undue weight was given to the brake marks which were on the road shoulder.
(iv) Failure to give due weight to the victim's position in the middle of the road before the collision and the evidence of PW2 (Sjn Angat anak Dusi) that the point of impact was in the middle of the road.
(v) Failure to give proper and adequate consideration to the evidence adduced by the defence and giving reasons for rejecting the same.
(vi) Failure to distinguish between two categories of offences under s 41(1) of the Road Transport Act ie causing death by reckless or dangerous driving.
[3] I will take the last point first.
Two Separate Categories Of Offence
I am in agreement with Mr. Bernard Philip for the appellant that indeed s 41(1) provides for two separate offences but which attract the same punishment - one is dangerous driving and the other is reckless driving. I also agree with him that case law has decided that the ingredients of each differ from the other, though the distinction maybe fine but they are still obviously different as reckless driving is a more serious offence than dangerous driving. In this regard, I would adopt the definitions from case law which he has highlighted to me to show the distinction as aforesaid.
Reckless driving
to be guilty of the more serious category of the offence of reckless driving the driver (defendant) must have created an obvious and serious risk of injury to the person or damage to property and must either have given no thought to the possibility of that obvious risk, or have seen the risk and nevertheless decided to run it. (per Vincent Ng J, in Public Prosecutor v. Zulkifli bin Omar , ).
Dangerous driving
1. In a case of dangerous driving, the prosecution must establish that:
(a) a situation created by the accused is dangerous, eg, turning right into the said road without stopping to give way to through traffic; and
(b) when creating such situation the accused was at fault. Fault involves a failure; a falling below the care and skill of a competent and experienced driver in relation to the manner of driving and relevant circumstances (per Raja Azlan Shah) (now HRH the Sultan of Perak) in Ramiah v. Public Prosecutor , at page 258 I right column to 259L left column. (per Low Hop Bing J (as he then was) in PP v. Ong Kia Chan ; ;