SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Judicial Analysis Court Copy Headnote Facts Arguments Court observation
judgment-img

2019 Supreme(SC) 1306

AJAY RASTOGI, INDU MALHOTRA
Uttarakhand Purv Sainik Kalyan Nigam Limited – Appellant
Versus
Northern Coal Field Limited – Respondent


Advocates Appeared:
For the Petitioner(s):Kailash Pandey, Ranjeet Singh, Jyoti Kr. Mishra, Sushmita Mishra, Gaichangpou Gangmei, Advocates
For the Respondent(s):Ashwani Kumar Dubey, Chandra Shekhar Mishra, Advocates

ORDER :

1. The issue which has arisen for consideration is whether the High Court was justified in rejecting the application filed under Section 11 for reference to arbitration, on the ground that it was barred by limitation.

2. The factual background of the case arises from an agreement dated 21.12.2010 entered into between the parties, under which the Petitioner-Contractor was to provide security to the Respondent-Company around the clock on need basis, as per the agreed contractual rates. The Agreement contained an arbitration clause which reads as follows:

    “13. Arbitration:

    13.1 If any dispute, difference, question or disagreement shall at any time hereafter arise between the parties hereto or the respective or assigns in connection with or arising out of or in respect of contract, application of provision thereof, anything thereunder contained or arising thereunder or as to rights, liabilities or duties of the said parties hereunder or any matter whatsoever incidental to this contract shall be referred to the sole Arbitration of the person appointed by Director (Pers.) of NCL. CONTRACTOR shall have no objection to any such appointment that the arbitrator so appointed is an employ

Click Here to Read the rest of this document
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
Judicial Analysis

D. Biswas vs Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited - 2025 0 Supreme(MP) 329: This case explicitly indicates bad law treatment. It states "SCC 455 , while over-ruling the order of this Court in the case of Uttarakhand Purv Sainik Kalyan Nigam Limited Vs." – referring to the Supreme Court overruling a prior court order involving or related to the Uttarakhand Purv Sainik Kalyan Nigam Limited case (2020) 2 SCC 455, marking it as overruled in that context.

All references to "Uttarakhand Purv Sainik Kalyan Nigam Limited v. Northern Coal Field Limited (2020) 2 SCC 455" or minor name variations (e.g., Sadanand Singh Construction Pvt. Ltd. VS Managing Director, National Building Construction Corporation - 2020 0 Supreme(Pat) 549, Royal Orchid Hotels Limited VS Rock Reality Private Limited - 2020 0 Supreme(Kar) 2284, Liquidator, The Karamsad Urban Co Operative Bank Ltd. VS Suprintendent Of Post Offices Anand - 2020 0 Supreme(Guj) 1001, Rawani Construction vs National Thermal Power Corporation Ltd. - 2020 0 Supreme(Ori) 217, Jain Automobiles H. P. C. Dealer Through Its Dealer And Proprietor D. C. Jain VS Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited - 2020 0 Supreme(All) 1385, Manju Gupta VS Vilas Gupta - 2021 0 Supreme(Del) 1959, Raghunath Madhukar Mandrekar VS Prabhakar Vernekar - 2021 0 Supreme(Bom) 619, Rakesh Enterprises VS Union Of India - 2021 0 Supreme(Raj) 347, Rakesh Enterprises VS Union of India - 2021 0 Supreme(Raj) 1088, Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd. VS Nortel Networks India Pvt. Ltd. - 2021 0 Supreme(SC) 138, Kamalakanta Engineering And Construction Company Private Limited VS National Projects Construction Corporation Limited - 2021 0 Supreme(Ori) 204, Delhi Airport Metro Express Pvt. Ltd. VS Delhi Metro Rail Corporation Ltd. - 2021 6 Supreme 145, Manisha Kulkarni Proprietor Of Mani Engineers Pune VS NCC Limited - 2021 0 Supreme(Del) 851, DLF Home Developers Limited VS Rajapura Homes Private Limited - 2021 6 Supreme 284, Simplex Projects Ltd. , through its Director VS State of Manipur, through its Chief Secretary, Secretariat, Imphal - 2021 0 Supreme(Manipur) 9, Pooja Infotech Pvt. Ltd. VS Prabhuprem Infotech Pvt. Ltd. - 2021 0 Supreme(Del) 643, MD and others (J&K Power Development Corporation) VS Trust House Construction Engineers and Builders - 2021 0 Supreme(J&K) 506, Trade Swift Developers Private Limited VS Gopal Prasad Kanodia - 2021 0 Supreme(Raj) 2030, Tarun Aggarwal Projects LLP VS Emaar MGF Land Ltd. - 2021 0 Supreme(Del) 751, M/s Tarun Aggarwal Projects LLP vs M/s Prajakta Colonilers Pvt. Ltd. - 2021 Supreme(Online)(DEL) 620, Lindsay International Private Limited VS Laxmi Niwas Mittal - 2022 0 Supreme(Cal) 33, Sandipbhai Ashokbhai Parmar VS Arbitrator, Kumari Neetaben Vitthabhai Patel - 2022 0 Supreme(Guj) 1822, Eveready Industries India Ltd. VS KKR India Financial Services Limited - 2022 0 Supreme(Del) 709, Eveready Industries India Ltd. VS KKR India Financial Services Limited - 2022 0 Supreme(Del) 630, Eveready Industries India Ltd. VS KKR India Financial Services Limited - 2022 0 Supreme(Del) 69, Writer Business Services Pvt. Ltd. VS Aditya Birla Retail Ltd. - 2022 0 Supreme(Telangana) 169, Gail (india) Limited VS Kesar Alloys & Metals Private Limited - 2022 0 Supreme(Del) 1508, Orissa Concrete And Allied VS Union Of India - 2022 0 Supreme(Del) 135, Orissa Concrete And Allied VS Union Of India - 2022 0 Supreme(Del) 1062, Parsvnath Developers Ltd. VS Future Retail Limited - 2022 0 Supreme(Del) 116, India Tourism Development Corporation VS Bougainvillea Multiplex Entertainment - 2022 0 Supreme(Del) 860, Lite Bite Foods Pvt. Ltd. VS Airports Authority Of India - 2022 0 Supreme(Guj) 807, M/s Garg Construction Company VS State Of Haryana - 2022 0 Supreme(P&H) 841, M/s Garg Construction Company VS State Of Haryana - 2022 0 Supreme(P&H) 845, Indian Oil Corporation Limited VS NCC Limited - 2022 6 Supreme 593, Rajsheel Builders And Developers VS Shakuntlabai W/o Shri Kanhaiyalal Hardia - 2022 0 Supreme(MP) 1263, Rajsheel Builders and Developers Indore v. Shakuntlabai - 2023 Supreme(Online)(MP) 27265, Vatsala Jagannathan VS Tristar Accommodations Limited, Represented by its Managing Director - 2023 0 Supreme(Mad) 194, METCON INDIA REALTY AND INFRASTRUCTURE PVT. LTD. VS DELHI METRO RAIL CORPORATION LTD. - 2023 0 Supreme(Del) 192, Antique Art Export Pvt. Ltd. VS United India Insurance Company Limited - 2023 0 Supreme(Del) 2577, Kuldeep Kumar Contractor VS Hindustan Prefab Limited - 2023 0 Supreme(Del) 1058, M/s Kuldeep Kumar Contractor v. Hindustan Prefab Limited - 2023 Supreme(Online)(Del) 18154, INDIAN OIL CORPORATION LIMITED VS JALARAM PETROLEUM COMPANY - 2023 0 Supreme(Guj) 257, Zillon Infraprojects Pvt. Ltd. VS Bharat Heavy Electricals Limited - 2023 0 Supreme(Cal) 578, Sanjay Kumar Bhagat (HUF) VS Sanjan Kumar Bhagat - 2023 0 Supreme(Cal) 545, Himachal Pradesh Power Corporation Ltd. VS KSR Infra Structure Pvt. Ltd. - 2023 0 Supreme(HP) 327, Amazing India Contractors Pvt. Ltd. VS Airport Authority of India - 2023 0 Supreme(Cal) 1182, Union of India VS J & S Construction - 2023 0 Supreme(Del) 3409, Jupiter Rubber Pvt. Ltd. VS Union of India - 2023 0 Supreme(Del) 5696, Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd. VS Vihaan Networks Ltd. - 2023 0 Supreme(Del) 5871, Wapcos Ltd VS Jyoti Sarup Mittal - 2023 0 Supreme(Del) 5757, Mbl Infrastructures Limited VS Delhi Metro Rail Corporation - 2023 0 Supreme(Del) 6042, IN RE: INTERPLAY BETWEEN ARBITRATION AGREEMENTS UNDER THE ARBITRATION AND CONCILIATION ACT 1996 AND THE INDIAN STAMP ACT 1899 VS . - 2024 1 Supreme 366, Sushma Shivkumar Daga VS Madhurkumar Ramkrishnaji Bajaj - 2023 8 Supreme 502, Vedanta Limited VS Prowess International Pvt. Ltd - 2023 0 Supreme(Bom) 1974, Suresh Dhanuka VS Shahnaz Husain - 2024 0 Supreme(Cal) 79, Meiden T&d India Limited VS Pci Limited - 2024 0 Supreme(Del) 418, Lifeshine Medical Services Pvt. Ltd VS Alety Jeevan Reddy - 2024 0 Supreme(Telangana) 105, Lifeshine Medical Services Pvt. Ltd vs Alety Jeevan Reddy - 2024 0 Supreme(Telangana) 1214, FORGINGS PRIVATE LIMITED ( IN LIQUIDATION) THROUG Vs. PIVOTAL INFRASTRUCTURE PRIVATE LIMITED & ORS. - 2024 Supreme(Online)(DEL) 28291, Shameem Sultana Khan vs Faizunnissa Begum - 2025 0 Supreme(Telangana) 351, Surat Municipal Corporation Through Commissioner VS Patel Engineering Co Ltd. - 2024 0 Supreme(Guj) 1184, SBI General Insurance Co. Ltd. VS Krish Spinning - 2024 6 Supreme 518, Cox & Kings Ltd. VS Sap India Pvt. Ltd. - 2024 7 Supreme 43, Ajay Madhusudan Patel VS Jyotrindra S. Patel - 2024 0 Supreme(SC) 804, Airport Authority Of India VS S. S. Enterprise - 2024 0 Supreme(Guj) 2148, Adavya Projects Pvt. Ltd. VS Vishal Structurals Pvt. Ltd. - 2025 0 Supreme(SC) 652, BVM Property Leasing Pvt. Ltd. vs Sree Venkataraya Builders Pvt Ltd - 2025 0 Supreme(Telangana) 443, ASF Buildtech Private Limited VS Shapoorji Pallonji and Company Private Limited - 2025 4 Supreme 385, G4S Secure Solutions (India) Pvt. Ltd. vs CGI Information Systems and Management Consultants Pvt. Ltd. - 2025 0 Supreme(Kar) 136): These overwhelmingly cite the case approvingly, often with phrases like "reliance was placed on", "the Hon'ble Supreme Court held", "this Court took note of", "followed its earlier decision", "continue to hold the field", or direct quotes from paragraphs (e.g., 7.3, 7.10, 7.11). They treat it as good law on issues like scope of judicial intervention under Section 11, limitation, and kompetenz-kompetenz.

Rawani Construction vs National Thermal Power Corporation Ltd. - 2020 0 Supreme(Ori) 217: Distinguished – Explicitly states "Uttarkhand Purv Sainik Kalyan Coal Field Limited (supra)... are distinguishable".

Jharia Petrol Supply, Durgapur, through its proprietor Maina Devi VS Indian Oil Corporation Limited, through its D. G. M. (R. S. ) - 2022 0 Supreme(Jhk) 162: Distinguished – Refers to "Purv Sainik Kalyan Nigam Limited (Supra)" alongside others as distinguishable.

Writer Business Services Pvt. Ltd. VS Aditya Birla Retail Ltd. - 2022 0 Supreme(Telangana) 169: Questioned/declined to follow – States "In view of what has been discussed above, the decision rendered in Uttarakhand Purv Sainik Kalyan Nigam Limited... to More Retail Limited", implying it was not followed in the final disposition.

National Thermal Power Corporation LTD. VS Siemens Atkeingesellschaft - 2007 2 Supreme 987, National Insurance Co. Ltd. VS Boghara Polyfab Pvt. Ltd. - 2008 6 Supreme 725, Union of India VS Master Construction Co. - 2011 3 Supreme 441, TRF Ltd. VS Energo Engineering Projects Ltd. - 2017 5 Supreme 358, Duro Felguera, S. A. VS Gangavaram Port Limited - 2017 7 Supreme 486, Dresser Rand S. A. VS Bindal Agro Chem LTD. - 2006 1 Supreme 212, Itw Signode India LTD. VS Collector Of Central Excise - 2004 1 Supreme 217, S. B. P. & Co. VS Patel Engineering LTD. - 2005 7 Supreme 610, PSA Mumbai Investments Pte. Limited VS Board of Trustees of The Jawaharlal Nehru Port Trust - 2018 0 Supreme(SC) 1050, Indian Farmers Fertilizer Co-Operative Limited VS Bhadra Products - 2018 1 Supreme 306: These appear as standalone summaries of holdings ("Important point", "Important Point") without explicit citation by other cases in the list or treatment indicators like "relied upon", "overruled", etc. No language shows subsequent judicial treatment.

None identified. All cases fit into the above categories based on explicit language or context. Cases with minor spelling variations (e.g., "Uttarakhan", "PurvSainik", "Northern Coal Fields") clearly refer to the same 2020 SCC 455 case and are grouped as followed/cited approvingly.

SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
logo-black

An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers

Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance

qr

Scan Me!

India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!

For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :

whatsapp-icon telegram-icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top