The Madras High Court has issued a significant ruling in favor of Edac Engineering Limited, affirming its entitlement to capital gains tax relief under Section 54G of the Income-Tax Act, 1961, following the company’s decision to shift its industrial unit from Chemmenchery to Puzhal during the 2009-10 assessment year. A Division Bench comprising Justice Anita Sumanth and Justice Krishnaswamy Govindarajan clarified that the eligibility for such relief is not precluded by subsequent government notifications concerning municipal boundary expansions. While the Court ruled in favor of the assessee on the core issues of capital gains and tax deduction at source (TDS) obligations, it simultaneously reversed a tribunal decision that had partially allowed the company’s claim for road construction expenses, citing a complete lack of supporting documentation.

The dispute over the capital gains exemption hinged on whether Chemmenchery qualified as an "urban area" for the purposes of the Act during the relevant financial year. The Revenue had argued that because the Tamil Nadu government only officially integrated Chemmenchery into the Chennai city corporation limits via a 2009 notification that became effective in 2011, the assessee did not meet the necessary criteria at the time of the land sale in April 2009. The Court rejected this restrictive interpretation, noting that the legislative intent behind Section 54G was to encourage the decongestion of urban agglomerations by facilitating the movement of industries to alternate sites.

The Bench observed that the 2009 government order was primarily administrative, intended to manage the terms of local elected representatives, and did not retroactively strip the area of its status as an urban center for tax purposes. "Section 54G was inserted with the avowed object of decongesting city limits. It provided for a beneficial methodology in computation of capital gains where a unit, earlier located in an urban area was shifted to an alternate location, the object being to encourage decluttering of urban agglomerations ," the Court noted in its judgment. Furthermore, the Court highlighted that other land-related statutes, such as the Tamil Nadu Urban Land Tax Act of 1966 and the Second Master Plan for the Chennai Metropolitan Area , already categorized Chemmenchery within the urban sprawl well before 2010 .

In addition to the capital gains issue, the Court addressed a complex dispute regarding payments made by Edac Engineering for boiler flushing services performed at a facility in Toranagallu. The Revenue had attempted to invoke Section 40(a)(ia) and Section 195 of the Income-Tax Act, arguing that because the primary work order was issued to a Dubai-based entity, the assessee was required to deduct tax at source on all payments, regardless of whether the funds were routed to domestic companies.

The Court dismissed this position after finding that the work had been definitively subcontracted to two Indian entities, Fairline Shipping Services Limited and AMS Enterprises, and that the payments were made directly to these companies. The Bench emphasized the necessity of a strict interpretation of TDS provisions, noting that the law does not allow for disallowance when payments are made to domestic entities, provided there is no evidence that the Indian subcontractors were mere conduits for a non-resident beneficiary. Finding that the Revenue had failed to produce any material to challenge the legitimacy of these transactions, the Court upheld the Tribunal’s decision to allow the expenditure.

The proceedings took a different turn regarding the company's claim for road construction expenses. During the assessment, the company had claimed significant costs, yet it failed to produce the necessary records or make the claimed contractors available for examination when queried by the Assessing Officer. Although the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal had previously attempted to salvage a portion of this claim by allowing 25% of the expenditure on an estimated basis, the High Court found this approach legally unsustainable.

The Bench observed that a business entity’s overarching involvement in a project does not waive the fundamental requirement to substantiate every claim of expenditure with verifiable documentary evidence. "In these circumstances, the Tribunal has, in our view, erred in accepting 75% of the claim of expenditure in the absence of any supporting material and on an estimated basis. We find no basis for such an estimate in the light of the concurrent findings of all authorities, including the Tribunal, that the claim of expenditure was unsupported by any evidence or supporting material," the Court stated.

The ruling serves as a reminder of the strict evidentiary standards required in tax litigation. While the Court demonstrated flexibility in interpreting the purpose of urban development exemptions to favor the assessee, it maintained a rigid stance on the necessity of proof for expense claims. By reversing the Tribunal’s decision to allow the road construction costs, the High Court has solidified the principle that tax authorities are not obligated to grant relief on an estimation basis when an assessee provides no evidence of the actual cost incurred.

Ultimately, the High Court decided five of the six substantial questions of law in favor of Edac Engineering Limited, effectively granting the company the tax benefits associated with its industrial relocation and confirming the correct application of TDS rules for its subcontracted work. The decision brings finality to the assessment dispute for the 2009-10 period, with the disallowance of the unsubstantiated road construction expenditure remaining in force. This outcome confirms the company’s capital gains relief while establishing a clear boundary regarding the necessity of substantiated documentation in corporate tax filings.