The has set aside the of a man found guilty by a lower court of committing rape and offences under the , ruling that a sexual relationship between adults cannot be deemed forceful simply because a subsequent promise of marriage did not materialize. The Division Bench, comprising Justice Michael Zothankhuma and Justice Sanjeev Kumar Sharma, the appellant, Dipan Ghosh, after finding that the evidence presented did not support the charges of or the status of the victim as a minor at the time of the incidents.
The verdict concludes a protracted legal battle that originated in , when a complaint was filed by the mother of the victim at the . The original case alleged that the appellant had repeatedly engaged in sexual acts with her teenage daughter, initially under and subsequently while promising marriage. The had initially sentenced the appellant to ten years of under and twenty years for offences under , alongside substantial monetary fines.
Evaluating Evidence and Victim Age
Central to the appeal was the ambiguity surrounding the victim's age at the time the sexual relationship commenced. The prosecution had relied on an unexhibited birth certificate and the testimony of the victim, while the defense challenged the victim's assertions, citing her own cross-examination statements. The High Court observed that in the absence of a corroborated birth certificate, the court must rely on the medical examination report to determine the age of the .
The medical report, which included an , indicated that the victim was between 17 and 18 years of age at the time of the examination. The High Court applied established legal precedents regarding medical age assessments, noting that allows for a margin of error of one to two years in such reports. Justice Zothankhuma, writing for the bench, noted that even if the benefit of a one-year margin were applied to the upper end of the assessment, it would place the victim at 18 years of age during the period the sexual relations occurred. Consequently, the provisions of the POCSO Act were deemed inapplicable.
Discrepancies in Legal Testimony
The High Court further scrutinized the consistency of the victim’s statements, highlighting a significant divergence between her testimony during trial and her earlier statement recorded under . While the victim claimed in court that the sexual encounters were forced, the and the frequency of the encounters—amounting to approximately 40 to 50 occasions—suggested a sustained relationship. The Court observed that the sexual activity had occurred within the victim’s residence during times when her family members were absent, a detail that contradicted the narrative of persistent, involuntary confinement.
The judgment emphasized that the legal system cannot classify a liaison as rape simply because the relationship eventually soured following the appellant’s refusal to marry. According to the bench, the appeared to be a reaction to the failure of the marriage proposal rather than a genuine case of sexual violence. “The sexual act between the parties cannot be said to be forceful, only on account of a change in the relationship between the two parties, which in our view, would not attract the provisions of either the IPC or the POCSO Act,” the Court observed.
Application of
The High Court also addressed the approach of the trial court, noting it violated . This provision mandates that when an act constitutes an offence under both the IPC and the POCSO Act, the offender should be punished under either the IPC or the POCSO Act, specifically selecting the provision that carries a greater degree of punishment, rather than imposing concurrent sentences for both. However, because the Court found the fundamental unsustainable, this procedural error became secondary to the broader finding of acquittal.
The ruling reinforces the principle that where two competing interpretations of evidence exist—one favoring the state and one favoring the accused—the interpretation leaning toward the accused must be preferred to avoid a . By setting aside the judgment of the , the High Court has directed the immediate release of the appellant from judicial custody, provided he is not required in any other pending litigation.
This decision marks a significant moment for the in its interpretation of consent in cases. By distinguishing between personal grievances arising from broken relationships and the criminal threshold for rape, the Court has emphasized that criminal liability cannot be anchored to non-criminal breaches of social expectations. The acquittal of the appellant serves as a reminder that the in serious criminal offences requires clear, consistent, and corroborative evidence that stands the test of , particularly when the life and liberty of an individual are at stake. The case file has been ordered to be returned to the trial court, effectively bringing the proceedings against the appellant to a close.
consensual sexual relationship - sexual assault acquittal