The Delhi High Court has dismissed two appeals filed by the Income Tax Department, ruling that assessment orders passed by an Assessing Officer in direct violation of directions issued by the Dispute Resolution Panel (DRP) are legally invalid. The court affirmed that the failure to adhere to the statutory mechanisms governing tax assessment proceedings renders the resulting orders void ab initio , confirming that the Income Tax Department cannot bypass the binding mandate of the DRP.

The dispute involved Bechtel Limited, a United Kingdom-based entity that had entered into an engineering and procurement support services agreement with Reliance Industries Limited (RIL) in 2012. The contract concerned technical services provided for a plant construction project at RIL’s refinery complex in the Jamnagar Special Economic Zone, as well as operations within the Domestic Tariff Area. When Bechtel filed its income tax returns for the assessment years 2016-17 and 2017-18, declaring "NIL" income, the Assessing Officer initiated scrutiny proceedings. The officer sought to classify the receipts as "Fee for Technical Services" or "Fee for Included Services" under Article 13 of the India-UK Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement.

Upon receiving the draft assessment order, Bechtel challenged the classification before the Dispute Resolution Panel. The DRP, after analyzing the terms of the agreement and the physical presence of Bechtel’s employees at RIL’s Mumbai office and the Jamnagar site, concluded that the company maintained a permanent establishment in India. Consequently, the panel directed that the income be taxed as business income rather than technical fees. Crucially, the DRP instructed that the classification of the receipts as technical fees be considered only on a protective basis.

Despite these explicit directions, the Assessing Officer issued final assessment orders that substantively treated the receipts as technical fees, effectively ignoring the panel’s primary directive. Bechtel challenged this move before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), which quashed the assessment orders. The Tribunal found that the Assessing Officer had failed to implement the DRP’s instructions in their letter and spirit, despite technically reproducing them within the order.

Judicial Emphasis on Statutory Compliance

In upholding the Tribunal’s decision, the Delhi High Court emphasized that the procedural framework established under Section 144C of the Income Tax Act, 1961, is not a mere formality. The court highlighted that once the DRP issues directions, the Assessing Officer is statutorily bound to conclude the assessment in conformity with those findings. The court cited established precedents to underscore that an officer’s personal disagreement with the panel’s interpretation of the law does not empower them to deviate from its binding authority.

Addressing the Department’s appeal, the division bench consisting of Justice Subramonium Prasad and Justice Renu Bhatnagar noted the significance of strict procedural adherence. The court quoted the principle that: "The Assessing Officer had no option but to comply with the order of the Dispute Resolution Panel."

The bench underscored that the Assessing Officer’s failure to observe the statutory mandate resulted in a fundamental jurisdictional error . By confirming the draft assessment order in defiance of the panel’s specific directives, the officer vitiated the entire assessment process. The court stated, "Non-compliance with the DRP’s binding directions renders the final Assessment Order without jurisdiction and void ab initio ."

Resolving Divergent Interpretations

During the proceedings, the Income Tax Department argued that the DRP had issued conflicting or "twin" directions regarding the underlying receipts. Counsel for the Revenue contended that the Tribunal should have resolved these apparent inconsistencies rather than quashing the assessment on technical grounds. The Department further suggested that the matter should have been remanded to the Assessing Officer for a fresh determination of the appropriate taxation methodology.

However, the High Court rejected this line of reasoning. The bench observed that the case was squarely covered by the precedent set in ESPN Star Sports Mauritius S.N.C. v. Union of India , which established that failing to follow the procedure mandated by Section 144C is a fatal flaw. The court remarked that while the Revenue attempted to rely on other legal precedents, the facts of this case did not permit the AO to disregard the DRP’s findings. The court clarified that the statutory duty is to implement the directions as given, not to adjudicate upon the wisdom of the panel.

Implications for Tax Administration

The decision reinforces the primacy of the Dispute Resolution Panel as an essential layer in the Indian tax assessment hierarchy, intended to prevent arbitrary additions by Assessing Officers. By confirming that jurisdictional errors arising from the defiance of DRP directions are substantive rather than procedural, the court has signaled a zero-tolerance approach toward administrative non-compliance.

The High Court’s refusal to interfere with the ITAT's order confirms that when an assessment is deemed "void ab initio," the entire exercise of raising the demand is set aside, leaving the Revenue with no legal basis for the recovery of the disputed tax amounts. This ruling serves as a cautionary note for tax authorities, emphasizing that the finality of assessments depends entirely on the faithful execution of hierarchical mandates. Following the dismissal of these appeals, the current assessment orders remain quashed, effectively concluding the litigation for the specified assessment years. The case underscores that procedural integrity remains a cornerstone of tax jurisprudence, regardless of the merits of the underlying taxability of international transactions.