Searching Case Laws & Precedent on Legal Query.....!
Analysing the retrieved Case Laws
Scanned Judgements…!
Searching Case Laws & Precedent on Legal Query.....!
Analysing the retrieved Case Laws
Scanned Judgements…!
Courts have clarified that leases for commercial purposes involve activities like running a hotel, petrol pump, or retail store, and such use generally qualifies the dispute as commercial under the applicable law ["T.Vijaya Kumar, S/o T.Narayana Rao vs Sree Vijaya Timbers Corporation - Madras"], ["PSM Energy Pvt. Ltd. Through its director/Authorized Representative Shri Ajay Vishwakarma vs ZAM Engineering and Logistics Pvt. Ltd. - Telangana"].
Analysis and Conclusion
References:["Jayanta Krishna Datta VS Indian Oil Corporation Limited - Calcutta"] ["Nexon Omniverse Limited vs N.P. Raveendranath Naidu Son Of Krishna Naidu - Karnataka"] ["Goukaran Nath Mishra VS Giridharilal Jalan - Calcutta"] ["Varun Ahuja VS M3M India Private Limited - Consumer"] ["Mamta Kapoor VS Vinod Kumar Rai - Allahabad"] ["T.Vijaya Kumar, S/o T.Narayana Rao vs Sree Vijaya Timbers Corporation - Madras"] ["PSM Energy Pvt. Ltd. Through its director/Authorized Representative Shri Ajay Vishwakarma vs ZAM Engineering and Logistics Pvt. Ltd. - Telangana"]
Imagine signing a lease for a building to kickstart your business dreams—setting up a shop, warehouse, or office—only to face a dispute with your landlord. A common question arises: A person entered into an agreement for lease to a building for business purpose. Is it a commercial suit?
The short answer is yes, typically, if the property is used exclusively for trade or commerce. This classification falls under the Commercial Courts, Commercial Division and Commercial Appellate Division of High Courts Act, 2015 (Commercial Courts Act). However, actual use, not just intention, is key. This blog dives deep into the legal framework, judicial precedents, exceptions, and practical tips to help business owners navigate such matters. Note: This is general information, not specific legal advice. Consult a qualified lawyer for your situation.
Under Section 2(1)(c)(vii) of the Commercial Courts Act, a commercial dispute includes disputes arising out of agreements relating to immovable property used exclusively in trade or commerce Bangalore Blues Entertainment India Private Limited VS One Ikigaii Edutech Private Limited - 2023 0 Supreme(Kar) 432. The phrase used exclusively in trade or commerce is pivotal. Courts stress that the property must be actually used for these purposes, not merely intended or potentially so Hanumanta Vissu Arsekar VS Upendra Narayan Katkar - 2014 0 Supreme(Bom) 293.
For lease agreements, this means if the building is leased for business activities like running a shop, factory, or storage—solely for trade—the resulting disputes (e.g., eviction, damages, or breach) generally qualify as commercial suits. This ensures faster resolution in specialized commercial courts.
Indian courts have consistently upheld this view through landmark rulings:
In Ambalal Sarabhai Enterprises Ltd. (AIR 2000 SC 1122), the Supreme Court clarified: the agreement must pertain to immovable property actually used exclusively for trade or commerce. Mere readiness or intention to use the property for trade does not suffice; actual use is necessary Hanumanta Vissu Arsekar VS Upendra Narayan Katkar - 2014 0 Supreme(Bom) 293.
The Gujarat State Warehousing Corporation case (2020 SCC OnLine Guj 583) involved a godown leased for storage of goods—a clear trade activity. Disputes over damages or recovery were deemed commercial 00600046442.
In Jagdish Lal v. Parma Nand (2000 SCC 44), a lease for business purposes with actual trade use qualified as a commercial dispute State NCT of Delhi VS Surender Kumar Jain - 2014 0 Supreme(Del) 763.
Additional cases reinforce this. For instance, a lease for a commercial space to run a hospital and allied services was held commercial, as the cause of action for the petitioner to file the present suit... arises from a registered Lease Deed... for running the Hospital... which is a commercial activity Rhea Healthcare Pvt. Ltd. VS Raj Alkaa Park - 2024 Supreme(Kar) 436. Similarly, where defendants admitted using the property for family business and commercial purposes, it supported commercial classification, though absence of a direct lease agreement affected jurisdiction in that instance Jaspal Singh Chandhok VS Sandeep Poddar - 2023 Supreme(Cal) 733.
When a person enters a lease for a building explicitly for business—such as an automobile showroom, cinema, or diagnostic center—the dispute often qualifies. Courts look at:
In one case, a lease for shell space in a mall for motion pictures (entertainment business) involved disputes over rent and services, falling under commercial purview, though interim relief was denied for resembling main relief Time Cinemas And Entertainment Pvt. Ltd. VS Infrastructure And Developers Pvt. Ltd. - 2022 Supreme(Guj) 448. Another example: a 'Leave and License Agreement' for business activities was scrutinized but upheld as enforceable for arbitration if not a lease, highlighting intent and substance Sandeep Sharma VS Sai Chhaya Autolink (P) Ltd. - 2012 Supreme(MP) 202.
Even partnerships developing commercial complexes via leases can trigger commercial disputes if tied to trade use N. Marappan VS V. S. T. Sengottaian - 2016 Supreme(Mad) 1498.
Not every business-related lease dispute is commercial. Key caveats include:
Running a petrol pump on leased premises doesn't automatically make eviction commercial if not tied to the lease's trade use Amalgamated Fuels Limited vs Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited - 2025 Supreme(Cal) 938. Nature of property (residential vs. commercial) and timing of use matter.
To avoid ambiguity:
In disputes, courts prioritize substance over form—e.g., collaboration agreements for business benefits treated as commercial ventures IG Builders & Promoters Pvt. Ltd VS Ajit Singh, (Dr. ) - 2011 Supreme(Del) 918.
Generally, a lease agreement for a building for business purposes qualifies as a commercial suit if the immovable property is exclusively and actually used in trade or commerce under Section 2(1)(c)(vii) Bangalore Blues Entertainment India Private Limited VS One Ikigaii Edutech Private Limited - 2023 0 Supreme(Kar) 432. Judicial trends from Ambalal Sarabhai to recent High Court rulings affirm this, promoting efficiency for business disputes Hanumanta Vissu Arsekar VS Upendra Narayan Katkar - 2014 0 Supreme(Bom) 293Rhea Healthcare Pvt. Ltd. VS Raj Alkaa Park - 2024 Supreme(Kar) 436.
Key takeaways:- Focus on actual use, not intent.- Document everything to strengthen claims.- Exceptions abound for non-exclusive or expired agreements.
Business owners should proactively structure leases and seek expert advice early. Stay informed, protect your ventures, and resolve disputes swiftly in the right forum.
This post draws from legal precedents and statutes for educational purposes. Laws evolve; professional counsel is essential.
#CommercialDispute #BusinessLease #LeaseLawIndia
The parties have proceeded on negotiations/agreement for the purpose of extension of the said lease. g. ... In the present case, lease deeds were executed on 10th September, 2008 for 20 years with effect from 01.08.1998 for the purpose of running the business of petrol pump and thus the submissions of the Counsel for the defendant is not sustainable. ... The present case is covered under Section 111(a) of the Transfer of Property Act as there is no nexus with the lease#HL_END....
It was further stated that defendants No.1 to 3 owned the commercial property in 11th Main Road, Jayanagar and the MOU was entered into for the purpose of taking the Schedule Property out on lease for the said commercial purpose of conduct of retail business of the plaintiff. ... In the instant case, as on the date of the agreement between the parties, there is no such averment and the contract in question is a simple lease deed wit....
Banerjee further submits that the defendants have also admitted that the defendants were using the suit property for their family business and also admitted the fact that the suit property was in use for commercial purpose. 7. Mr. ... There is no averment in the plaint that there was any lease or tenancy agreement was entered between the plaintiff and the defendant. The plaintiff has relied upon the lease deed of Nirode Bihari Lahi....
Rule 2(1) (d) clarifies again that the person liable to pay service tax in respect of renting/leasing building for commercial purpose shall be the provider of such service. ... Obviously, service tax for renting out building for commercial purpose is outgoings in respect of premises and not in respect of business. Therefore, the Meattles Pvt Ltd case relied by the appellant is not supportive to the appellant. ... They were not paying the service char....
Referring to the Buyer’s Agreement, which is almost common in respect of all the Complainants, it is urged that the allottee has entered into an agreement for the development of a “commercial complex” and acquisition of “commercial unit”. ... For this reference, be had to Clause H, J and L of the Preamble of the Buyer’s Agreement. The definition of the word Agreement is also a “Commercial Unit Buyer’s Agreement”, which is also defin....
the lease by the respondent, he suffered injuries in his business and he has filed a suit for recovery of money. ... As per the averments made in the plaint, the petitioner entered into a registered Lease Deed with the respondent to take on lease a commercial space for a specified period for running the Hospital and other allied healthcare services, which is a commercial activity. ... Thus, the cause of action for the petitioner to file the present #....
(2) A runs a hotel in the entire building but lets out a room to B for a purpose unconnected with the hotel business; (3) A runs a hotel in the entire building and lets out a room to B for carrying on his business different from that of a hotel, though incidentally the inmates of the hotel take advantage ... The room, therefore, for the purpose of the Act, ceases to be a part of the hotel and becomes a place of business of the respondent. ... Counsel has further submi....
Kankani submits that the plaintiff has filed the suit against the defendant no.1 for eviction. The defendant no.2 is running the business of petrol pump or using the premises for commercial purpose does not make the dispute commercial. ... Ray submits that by way of a registered lease deed dated 5th December, 1952, one Burmah Shell Oil Storage and Distribution Company was granted lease in respect of the suit property. He submits that the le....
The Hotel was actually being used for trade and commerce, and the agreement between the parties was for the purpose of business management and operations exclusively. ... Lease agreements for commercial properties can lead to disputes over rent payments, lease renewals, property maintenance, and compliance with lease terms. ... Petitioners and Vinod Kumar Rai (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Respondent’) entered into a business #HL_....
Lalwani (AIR 1965 SC 716) drawing a distinction between the lease of a building and the lease of a business held that what was protected under the Act was the lease of the building and not the lease of the business. ... The deed has not been described as a lease but as "an agreement for five years". ... It was observed that, legislature intended to cover within the meaning of word "accommodation", premises simplici....
The appellant is a private limited company carrying on business in the name of Time Cinemas, involved in running motion pictures and other such entertainment activities. The appellant entered into a lease agreement with the respondent, which is a company engaged in the business of leasing the real estate properties developed by it. Another lease deed dated 26.8.2019 was executed between the parties, whereby additional shell space adjacent to the space under the first lease deed was leased out. The lease deed dated 14.4.2017 was in respect of shell space admeasuring 17,459 s....
An agreement was entered into by the complainant’s husband for allotment of commercial space in the newly – constructed building. 2 to 4 – land owners entered into an agreement with and empowered opposite party no.1 – promoter–cum–developer to construct a multi–storeyed building on their land. It is not evident that this was exclusively for the purpose of earning his livelihood by means of self-employment.
The plaintiffs claimed that the partnership was dissolved by a Deed of Dissolution of partnership dated 11.12.1985. The above said partnership contract was entered into for the purpose of developing the suit property into a commercial complex. However, according to the plaintiffs' case, the partnership did not last long and on the other hand, it had to be dissolved due to the fact that the tenants did not vacate the portions in their occupation and also due to difference of opinion among the partners. It was valued at Rs.6,00,000/-and the said property was accepted as the p....
Respondent is a company registered under the provisions of the Indian Companies Act. Initially, a lease agreement was entered into between the petitioner and the respondent for the purpose of giving the building in question to the respondent for the purpose of establishing an Automobile Showroom and carrying out various business activities. Annexure P-1 is a copy of the said 'Leave and License Agreement'. After expiry of the lease, it was terminated and, thereafter, a fresh agreement termed as the 'Leave and License Agreement' was executed between the parties on 1st April, ....
Treating it as a business venture, a reasonable profit from such a venture can be taken as 15% of the investment proposed, which works out to Rs. 3 lakhs. It is admitted by him that he has entered into the transaction as a commercial collaboration agreement for business benefits. The appellant has further stated in the plaint, that under the collaboration agreement, he is required to invest Rs. 20 lakhs in all, made up of Rs. 16,29,000/- for construction and Rs. 3,71,000/- as cash consideration and that in lieu of it he will be entitled to ground floor of the new building t....
An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers
Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance
Scan Me!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :
Back to top
